Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T03:22:06.458Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

An empirical analysis of the annuity rate in Chile

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 November 2007

ROBERTO ROCHA*
Affiliation:
World Bank
MARCO MORALES
Affiliation:
Diego Portales University
CRAIG THORBURN
Affiliation:
World Bank
*
*Communications should be addressed to Roberto Rocha: Rrocha@worldbank.org
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Summary

Empirical analyses of annuities markets have been limited to a few developed countries and restricted by data limitations. Chile provides excellent conditions for research on annuities due to the depth of its market and the availability of data. The paper utilizes a panel of life insurance company data to examine econometrically the main determinants of the annuity rate, defined as the internal rate of return on annuities. The results indicate that the annuity rate is determined by the risk-free interest rate, the share of privately issued higher yield securities in the portfolio of providers, as a proxy for the spread over the risk-free rate, the leverage of providers, the level of broker's commissions, the market share of individual providers, the level of the premium, and the degree of market competition. The results also show that efforts to improve market transparency produced structural shifts in the parameters of the annuity rate equation. The results are consistent with separate research on money's worth ratios, and indicate the need to develop appropriate financial instruments, allowing providers to hedge their risks while extracting higher returns, and also to ensure competition and transparency in annuities markets, in order to ensure good outcomes for annuitants.

Information

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2007
Figure 0

Table 1.Money's worth ratios in March of 1999, 2002, 2003, and 2004

Figure 1

Figure 1.Average Interest Rates on Annuities (RV-85), Central Bank Bonds and Corporate Bonds (% p.a.), 1993–2004

Sources: SVS, Central Bank of Chile.
Figure 2

Table 2.Portfolio of life insurance companies (in % of total), 1991–2004

Figure 3

Figure 2.Commission Rates (% of the Premium), 1990–2004

Source: SVS.
Figure 4

Figure 3.Supply and Demand for Annuities

Figure 5

Table 3.Panel unit root tests (p-values)

Figure 6

Table 4.Fixed effects estimationDependent variable: AR(EARLY) Sample: 1993Q1–2003Q3; cross-sections included: 24 Total panel observations (unbalanced): 693 R2=0.7968; Adj. R2=0.7854; F-statistic=69.4348; p-value (F-statistic)=0.0000

Figure 7

Table 5.Fixed effects estimation, with robust standard errorsDependent variable: AR(EARLY) Sample: 1993Q1–2003Q3; cross-sections included: 24 Total panel observations (unbalanced): 693 R2=0.7968; Adj. R2=0.7854; F-statistic=69.4348; p-value (F-statistic)=0.0000

Figure 8

Table 6.Fixed effects estimation, with robust standard errorsDependent variable: AR(EARLY)Sample: 1993Q1–2003Q3; Cross-sections included: 24 Total panel observations (unbalanced): 725 R2=0.7995; Adj. R2=0.7890; F-statistic=76.2162; p-value (F-statistic)=0.0000

Figure 9

Table 7.Fixed effects estimationDependent variable: AR(OLD) Sample: 1993Q1–2003Q3; Cross-sections included: 24 Total panel observations (unbalanced): 675 R2=0.7909; Adj. R2=0.7787; F-statistic=65.1110; p-value (F-statistic)=0.0000

Figure 10

Table 8.Fixed effects estimation, with robust standard errorsDependent variable: AR(OLD) Sample: 1993Q1–2003Q3; Cross-sections included: 24 Total panel observations (unbalanced): 675 R2=0.7909; Adj. R2=0.7787; F-statistic=65.1110; p-value (F-statistic)=0.0000

Figure 11

Table 9.Fixed effects estimation, with robust standard errorsDependent variable: AR(OLD) Sample: 1993Q1–2003Q3; cross-sections included: 24 Total panel observations (unbalanced): 675 R2=0.7933; Adj. R2=0.7821; F-Statistic=71.3020; p-value (F-statistic)=0.0000

Figure 12

Appendix Table 1.Pairwise correlation matrix