This is an intriguing book on a topic of great current importance. It is a book that poses questions about the political status of Muslims in France, but also invites us to think about the ways that we, as scholars, address such topics. The first question that can be raised is who it is that is constructing Muslims in France. Are they average French citizens—so-called français-français—who differ from Muslims culturally, religiously, and economically? Are they average Muslims living in the country who construct identities for themselves? Could these be France’s political leaders, or perhaps Muslim community leaders living in France? Or are Muslim identities constructed in the media? How do the perceived images of Muslims differ across these groups?
The author, a professor of public law and recognized expert on France, shifts purposefully across various groups’ images of French Muslims, but ultimately her gaze rests on the country’s political elite. As the reader works through this short book, a further, ironic, question emerges: Is Jennifer Fredette herself engaging in a social construction of the French political elite?
In this study, Fredette is posing a crucial set of questions about Muslim communities, and she offers a scholarly series of answers to them at a time when this undertaking is more important than ever as unrest is transformed into violence and acts of terror. She completed her work well before the Charlie Hebdo massacre was committed in January 2015, but the issues raised at the outset have now even greater salience. What do Muslim communities want and why is their Frenchness under scrutiny when many have lived all their lives in the country, speak no language other than French, and boast of French citizenship? Early in the study, she emphasizes that not all Muslim political claims are religious or even religiously motivated, thereby challenging reductionist and essentializing images of Muslims as defined exclusively by their faith. Fairly or not, she is more sensitive to the contested status of Muslims than she is to the attitudes of French elites, which are in themselves complex, nuanced, and frequently incoherent.
The author’s view of French elites is that they simplify and scorn Muslims, bringing upon Muslims daily social indignities and varieties of discriminatory practices, particularly in the spheres of education, employment, and housing, which represent her three case studies. I am sympathetic to the often-ignored argument that Europe’s political elites are not without blame for the rise of communal tensions in many countries that pit Christians against Muslims, nativists against immigrants, populists against fundamentalists. But attributing oversimplified views to elite members and using data of questionable quality to support this critique is not, in my view, the most persuasive way to pin responsibility on them. Fredette appears to build ignorant straw men by musing: “Why does elite French discourse commonly depict Muslims as a homogeneous group?” and, “What is it about the organization of the French elite that hinders its receptivity to Muslims’ claims?” (p. 7). Or asking the loaded rhetorical question: “French elites today ask, Do Muslims deserve French citizenship?” (p. 18). Much research by specialists on France examining the spread of populist, anti-immigrant, antiestablishment movements that challenge political elites focuses attention on just the reverse pathology—a dogmatic political correctness adopted by elites that insists on greater tolerance, inclusion, and immigrant numbers for Europe, not a deprecating view of often francisized Muslim communities.
Let me cite assertions made by the author reflecting such disparaging elite attitudes. Her principal claim is that “elite discourse focuses on how Muslims are failing to integrate into French norms, values, institutions, and society” (p. 8); it “contributes to hardships for Muslims in France” (p. 10). Put simply, “In this study, I argue that the standing of Muslims as citizens of France is primarily undercut by elite discourse” (p. 25). Put more analytically, “This book examines the power of elites to discursively shape the definition of deserving and undeserving citizens in a way that feeds on, but also enables, social indignities” (p. 29); Muslims are the ones characterized in these narratives as undeserving citizens. Taking this argument further, a reason for elites purportedly labeling Muslims as undeserving citizens is that “today’s French elites define the deserving French citizen as a sexually liberal, irreligious (indifferent or hostile to religion), culturally singular, abstract individual” (p. 42). Without hard empirical evidence supporting the assertion that elites do frame issues in such terms, these are problematic claims.
This book only in passing examines the composition of the French elite and its discursive practices. It devotes little attention to legal and public policy—for example, citizenship laws—as they affect Muslims that are likely to have a more significant impact on them than social constructions of identity. Content analysis of the press seems to equate the print media’s critical depictions of Muslims (and not even by a satirical publication such as Charlie Hebdo) with political elite perceptions. Assessment of political leaders considered Islamophobic is limited; Marine Le Pen receives only two references. Most of the interviews conducted by the author with leaders of Muslim organizations (there is no Appendix listing who they are) yield largely anecdotal information. For example, citing popular rumors that Muslims working at Charles de Gaulle airport are linked together in a terrorist network (pp. 111–12) is of dubious value. Analysis of legislative reports of the National Assembly provides better data points and might have been expanded. The author touches on many key problems confronting French Muslims, like police harassment, but its treatment is cursory (pp. 148–49).
The temptation for experts on French Muslims to turn to the tried and true subject of the headscarf and veil controversies as indicators of antipathy toward Muslims is hard to resist. The author is aware how appealing the subject has been: “The hijab has crowded out all other discussion about Muslims and education among French elites” (p. 16). Not only that: “The discourse of politicians, intellectuals, and the media (not to mention academic research) focuses intensely and nearly uniquely on the hijab” (p. 80); in sum, there is “media fascination with it” (p. 163). Nevertheless, attention to this topic dwarfs that given to securitization of Muslim communities, Islamic fundamentalism, and terrorism—frames that today’s political elites and the security apparatus do, rightly or wrongly, employ in considering Islam’s place in France.
Finally, the author urges that it is “important to end the stereotype that all Muslims are immigrants” (p. 121). French citizens generally have sophisticated and nuanced understandings of the country’s diverse Muslim population, and so this admonition seems unnecessary.
It is in terms of the relevance of political theory to differing constructions of Muslims that Fredette takes the reader on an insightful and valuable exploration. Her referencing of Marxist and feminist theories to allow her to critique critical views of Muslims—wherever they may come from—is genial. Finally, she is particularly convincing at the end in making the case for a critical republicanism that takes issue with a difference-blind abstract republicanism that all too often fails to appreciate how implementing its opaque principles may not bring France closer to the goal of equality. And it is in resting her case in terms that the French tradition privileges—the virtues of civic republicanism—that Constructing Muslims in France is at its most authoritative and illuminating.
