Yasser Elsheshtawy and his contributors examine complex transformations in Middle Eastern urbanities. This group of architects travels across space, examining Algiers, Baghdad, Sanaءa, Tunis, Cairo, and Dubai, and also covers temporal distances, including explorations of medieval, colonial, and contemporary urban features and developments. As architects, they have keen eyes for spatial, structural, and formal elements that make and remake cityscapes and urban cultures. The realization that, in Western literature, Middle Eastern/Arab cities frequently have been dealt with as extensions of an ill-defined concept of “Muslim” cities initiated this collection. In his introduction, Elsheshtawy notes that such conceptualizations stifle meaningful engagements with complex past and present urban transformations. He somewhat overemphasizes the prevalence of such approaches in contemporary Middle Eastern urban studies. Central to this volume is the quest for an adequate analytical framework that does justice to the complexities of globalizing Middle Eastern metropolises.
Ultimately, however, Elsheshtawy and his contributors do not throw Islam as an analytical category overboard. On the contrary, they firmly reestablish Muslim forms and traditions as one concept among others that is relevant to Middle Eastern/Arab urban studies. Elsheshtawy indeed notes that “Islamic traditions” are a “vital part of this region” (p. 19). Moreover, he insists that, instead of focusing on “the narrative of loss” (p. 1) as an urban theme in the Middle East, scholars need to see these cities for what they currently are, that is, “vibrant, cosmopolitan entit[ies]” (p. 4) that are caught in complicated processes of globalization. Finally, he stresses the importance of examining local historical conditions, political climates, and their articulation with globalizing dynamics to understand contemporary Arab cities.
Jamel Akbar's short introductory piece discusses ideals of Islamic urban planning. He explores ideas of how to (re)establish a truly Islamic city and in the process eliminate current spatial and social problems. Akbar argues for a reorganization of cityscapes from an abstract formal level to achieve a better city, or Muslim utopia. Although thought provoking, this chapter sits uncomfortable with Elsheshtawy's critiques of analyses too centrally concerned with Islamic issues. The six city case studies are divided into two sections. The first examines Algiers, Baghdad, and Sanaءa from a historical perspective, focusing on the impact of modernity and modern architectural forms and planning. The second section (Tunis, Cairo, Dubai) engages more recent globalizing dynamics.
The chapter about Algiers by Karim Hadjri and Mohamed Osmani chronicles the rapid and often violent urban transformations that started to unfold after the French conquest of 1830. They review interactions between larger political and social phenomena (e.g., French military considerations, large-scale rural to urban migration) and how they created a new cityscape, but also political unrest and discontent. They note that, in the new millennium, Algiers is only reluctantly globalizing. The authors suggest that to become a successful regional hub, Algiers needs to “attract…businesses and ensure…a sustainable economic and social development” (p.54). Hadjri and Osmani identify hesitation on the part of the Algerian government to turn the city into an international hub.
Contemporary Baghdad is a difficult city to analyze. Hoshiar Nooraddin takes up this task focusing on modernist architecture and transformations in the city throughout the 20th century. He examines the changing legal structure of the city and traces the implementation of modern planning schemes, in particular until the 1960s. More specifically, he explores the role of local and international architects and “people” in the making and remaking of urban spaces.
Khaled Al-Sallal provides a detailed historical overview about Sanaءa, starting from the 11th century. He emphasizes how spatial forms, ecological/climatic requirements, and social aspects had for centuries developed and been refined in harmony. Socioeconomic changes starting from the 1960s engendered architectural changes in Sanaءa, whose modern quarters reflect developments in Egypt (apartment buildings) and the Gulf (villas behind concrete walls). However, neither one, Al-Sallal notices, is socially or environmentally adequate. He explains that recent changes have drawbacks—from water shortage to the restructuring of family units to the breakup of neighborhood communities. Instead of preserving the Old City of Sanaءa for the benefit of tourism, Al-Sallal insists that it needs to be taken seriously to “teach cultural and ecological values that can help us create an appropriate architecture for Yemen today” (p. 112).
Bechir Kenzari probes the historical transformation of Tunis starting from the colonial period. His main focus is on the recent suburbanization of areas in the vicinity of the metropolis, more specifically with the “Project du Lac.” Using Middle Eastern money and Dutch technology, the northern part of this project, built in the 1980s and 1990s, elaborates on globalized notions of leisure and consumption. The project, a town apart from the city (a “third center”)—with upscale amenities (theme park, golf course), business facilities, and housing ranging from exclusive villas to condominiums—provides a beautiful and relaxed environment for those who can afford it and also relieves pressures on overstretched urban quarters and services elsewhere in Tunis.
Khaled Adham compares how the colonial planned quarter of Heliopolis and the contemporary project of Dreamland (gated community and malls; see Kenzari above) on Cairo's desert outskirts share interesting moments and features in their social and political conceptualizations. He describes Heliopolis as a “European vision of the Orient” (p. 144), and Dreamland as an “Oriental Vision of the Occident” (p. 157). Despite their temporal distance of almost a century, Adham notes that the two projects are surprisingly similar in that they reflect the rationales of capitalist real-estate companies, cater to the fantasies of specific cosmopolitan constituencies, and by their price tags and exclusive imageries, exert influences on the existing cityscape and its less privileged residents.
Yasser Elsheshtawy provides an excellent and intriguing account and analysis of recent transformations in Dubai. Dubai's growth and emergence as a global center are unparalleled. Elsheshtawy insists that these celebrated developments come at a critical cost and with controversial implications. The city's construction (and economic) boom is based on the availability of cheap, largely South Asian, labor. Dubai's glitzy cityscape (“not burdened by history” [p. 172]), its unabashed consumerism, and love for mega-projects (which “distinguish themselves by using superlatives” [p. 180]) make it a showcase for a broad scope of globalizing possibilities. Planners and developers aim to propel the city to the forefront of upscale global business and tourism. Elsheshtawy notes that, in the process, the city is (re)created by the gaze of global tourists, multinational corporations, and real estate developers. In recent years, Dubai has increasingly served as a point of reference/inspiration for other cities in the region. However, Elsheshtawy is worried that Dubai has lost touch with its roots and, therefore, suggests that, to legitimately serve as a regional model, the city needs to recover “the real Dubai.” Elsheshtawy does not explain how to identify real or authentic Dubai or how to reinsert its lessons into local and regional cityscapes.
The authors' architectural background, although a welcome addition to urban studies, has a few minor disadvantages, most notably, their occasionally uncomfortable use of theoretical concepts. For example, Elsheshtawy, who is adamant about the articulation of an adequate theoretical model for analysis of Middle Eastern urban complexities, fairly uncritically uses concepts such as “underdevelopment” (pp. 1, 3), which represent a very different theoretical outlook than the one he is aiming to construct. He also writes about “the Middle East city” when indeed his theoretical project aims at a refined understanding of the complexities of Middle Eastern cities. Similarly, in contrast to the volume's tone of a critical engagement with westernization and globalization, Hadjri and Osmani bemoan that politicians in Algiers are hesitant to open their gates to global businesses as agents of positive urban transformations.
Despite such minor flaws, this book is a very informative and lively read that certainly adds a fresh perspective to the study of Arab cities. Written from an architectural perspective, the chapters take a sharp view at the interplay of material form, planning, and urban life. What makes this volume so interesting is the tension between or even within chapters with regard to both theoretical views and empirical descriptions of complex processes or colonial, modern, and globalizing transformations. Whether enforced (Algiers) or fostered by local rulers (Dubai), whether specifically furthered by individuals (Baghdad) or by a series of broader transformations (Sanaءa), urban changes of the past century—taking different starting points and varying political, economic, social, and architectural routes—have yielded an urban kaleidoscope that cannot simplistically be analyzed using formulaic terms and concepts. That the authors at times contradict each other (Elsheshtawy and Akbar), use very different approaches (ecological in Al-Sallal; cultural in Adham), highlight different temporal contexts (Al-Sallal starts in the 11th century; Elsheshtawy and Kenzari focus largely on the past ten years), and take different stances toward globalization (Hadjri/Osmani and Elsheshtawy) makes this volume so inspiring, vibrant, and complex. The book draws out fascinating images of urban spatial, and to a certain extent also cultural, contexts and dynamics. The sum total of their analyses provides a glimpse of the contemporary complexity of Arab cities, which can best be analyzed one at a time but against the background of their shared and complex past and future. This collection could be an interesting text for undergraduate and graduate courses in Middle Eastern and urban/cultural studies.
