The reviewed volume stems from a two-day conference held at the Casa de Velázquez in Madrid in 2016, and is a compilation of the contributions from the participants at that event. The first part of the book title, “Lapidum natura restat” (“It now remains for us to speak of stones”), refers to the beginning of the first paragraph in Book 36 of Pliny's Naturalis Historia. In it, among other topics, the Latin historian discusses marble, introducing the first paragraph with the controversial comment that marble appeared only to be appreciated for its commercial value (HN 36.1.1). However, the volume edited by Anna Gutiérrez Garcia-Moreno and Pierre Rouillard goes beyond that model of discussion traditionally linked to the use of stone in Roman timesFootnote 1 to focus on the identification and organization of quarries. It pays particular attention to non-prestigious building materials, as well as the challenges relating to their study. The second part of the book's title explains its specific thematic and geographical context: a discussion of the chronology, techniques, and organization of quarry sites on the Iberian peninsula in ancient times.
The volume features 13 papers, in addition to an editors’ presentation and an introductory paper by J.-C. Bessac. It consists of 200 pages organized into three sections: considerations of strategies for analysis, study methods, and techniques (Section I, “Exploitation areas and territories: Strategies for analysis, methods and techniques for global studies”); specific case studies and strategies for analysis (Section II, “Case studies from Tarragona to the Paris basin: Strategies for analysis, methods and techniques”); and research into the organization of the supply and use of stone (Section III, “Supply organization and the uses of the stone”).
Interest in stone building materials and their study from an archaeological point of view has expanded greatly in recent decades, especially in relation to ornamental stone or marmora. Since Ward-Perkins's pioneering article on the Roman marble trade in the ancient world,Footnote 2 studies of extraction techniques, quarry ownership, and the trade, distribution, and use of marble have increased considerably. The economic, political, and prestige implications of marble in the ancient world, beginning in the Late Republic and reaching a peak during the Imperial period, have fostered an increase in studies of its use and dissemination, and a flourishing of this field of research.
With reference to the Iberian peninsula, the number of studies of Roman marble has grown significantly in recent decades, generating one of the most profitable lines of research in Spanish classical archaeology. Paradoxically, although studies have intensified recently, the ancient sources contribute little on the subject in relation to Spain. The only testimony is that of Pliny who, as the editors of this volume remind us (7), refers to the abundance of mining resources in Hispania, as well as the presence of marble quarries (sunt et marmorum lapidicinae; Pliny, HN 3.3.30).
Studies of the identification, trade, and use of Roman marmora in Hispania, whether local or imported,Footnote 3 are numerous and well known.Footnote 4 However, in his introductory article to the volume, J.-C. Bessac brilliantly draws attention to the current scarcity of studies of building material quarries, which are instead treated almost exclusively from the point of view of the hard sciences. The French scholar is undoubtedly the best person to outline a critical excursus on the subject. In fact, and not by chance, the first archaeological excavations in the western Mediterranean of ancient quarries of non-prestigious stone were carried out in France in the late 1970s. Suffice it to mention, among others, the archaeological excavation and important research carried out at the Bois des Lens site in the Nîmes region.Footnote 5 It is still one of the most comprehensive studies of the economy of a construction site in a specific context, in which the study of the monuments is related to the extraction sites from which the building materials came. In fact, it addresses in a truly global way the technical and economic study of a territory and the operating mode of the construction site (13).
Following the introduction, the volume has 13 articles that are organized into the three aforementioned sections. They mainly refer to contexts on the Iberian peninsula, as the book title itself indicates, although some studies of French and Greek contexts are included. This choice can be justified both by the important tradition of French studies on the subject and by the relevance of some of the proposed case studies, such as the quarries on the Greek island of Thasos.
Despite examples that refer to marble (e.g., that from Thasos or Almadén de la Plata), the papers mainly focus on extraction sites of non-prestige building materials. It is not common to find such a focus and, in my opinion, this is the most important contribution of the conference and volume. In fact, to date little attention has been paid to so-called non-prestige building materials such as limestone. However, they were fundamental for construction and the manufacture of stone objects for local/regional use and circulation. We must consider that the raw material is always the starting point of the construction cycle. That makes ancient stone quarries supplying building materials a fundamental chapter in the history of construction; but also, and even more importantly, they are an aspect of cultural identity for a specific historical and geographical context.
The aim of generating a debate on the methodology for studying and analyzing these sites, and therefore of compiling updated research on the subject, constitutes an extremely interesting and original perspective of the volume. In the last 20 years, studies with a particular focus on building material quarries have certainly emerged.Footnote 6 However, until now, a volume that not only included a compilation of updated research but also attempted to address questions and challenges that are common to several contexts had yet to be proposed.
The main objective of this book, according to its editors, is to approach questions related to research methods. Their aim is to take into account several features of each extraction site, such as the type of stone and its properties – aspects that, for example, influence the extraction techniques and work organization. At the same time, they question the possible methodologies that might be adopted to analyze either a single quarry or a group of extraction sites. In my opinion, the methodological issue merits attention, taking into consideration not only recording methods, technical analyses, or technological tools applied. In fact, the use of innovative technologies, currently very popular in various archaeological disciplines, is sometimes considered not the means but the purpose of research. In many instances, adequate results could have been achieved with simpler rather than such complex technologies. The articles in this book integrate those aspects that are undoubtedly relevant, while shining a particular spotlight on issues and challenges that the entire extraction process and use of the stone can generate.
The only article that focuses with particular emphasis on the technology applied to the identification of extraction sites is the first (L. Costa, J. Moratalla, and P. Rouillard). It examines the extraction area south of the town of Elche (El Ferriol, Peligros, and Las Canteras). In this case, the results obtained by applying LIDAR technology combined with cartography and aerial images demonstrate how a suitable application of the so-called new technologies has constituted a valid approach to identifying the precise location of quarries.
Next is a study on a large territorial scale, namely the present region of Murcia (J. A. Antolinos Marín, J. M. Noguera Celdrán, and B. Soler Huertas). It was Roman Carthago Nova, the most important town in the investigated area, that promoted the exploitation of different extraction sites. This study has the merit not only of reconstructing the extractive activity in a specific geographical context, but also of proposing a study of the technical work processes through the analysis of extraction evidence and the work tools used in ancient times.
A further territorial analysis is presented by M. Wurch-Kozelj's contribution on Thasos. In fact, although the volume focuses on quarries on the Iberian peninsula, the study of quarries on the Greek island, with their exceptional evidence for ancient exploitation of stone resources, is a subject of undisputed interest. Beyond the extraction techniques, the preserved evidence allows us to reconstruct the organization of the different quarrying activities and phases, such as the presence of workshops involved in the maintenance of the quarrymen's tools and their production (57), or the construction of a lifting machine for moving heavy stones.
In the second section of the book the methodological approach and analytical strategies are investigated through case studies of individual extraction sites. The section opens with the exceptional limestone quarry of El Mèdol (Tarragona) that supplied the building material mainly for the public and domestic architecture of Roman Tarraco (A. Gutiérrez Garcia-Moreno and J. López Vilar). In fact, El Mèdol stone defines the architectural landscape of the town's historic center even today. The archaeological excavation carried out between 2011 and 2013, supported by the application of 3D photogrammetry, allowed the reconstruction of part of the quarry's extractive activity and some of the phases of the work process. It undoubtedly remains one of the most interesting ancient quarry sites anywhere on the Iberian peninsula.
Next, the use of new technologies (such as GIS and LIDAR, 83) combined with archaeological survey was fundamental to studying the ancient quarries of Cuenca de Caravaca and, in particular, Cerro de la Ermita de La Encarnación de Caravaca (F. Brotóns Yagüe and S. F. Ramallo Asensio). The quarry faces were opened a few meters from the two Iberian-Roman temples and used for their construction.
Among the few contributions on marble quarries is that concerning Almadén de la Plata (Seville) marble, considered one of the most important types of marmor in Hispania Baetica province (R. Taylor). Several studies, both archaeological surveys and excavations, as well as archaeometric analysis for characterizing and identifying lithotypes, have added considerably to our knowledge of the Almadén de la Plata quarries.Footnote 7 In this contribution, it is worth noting the reconstruction of the logistical aspects of the extraction process, as well as the first phase of marble working carried out at the quarry (102–3) in the Loma de los Castillejos area (northern Seville province).
Turning to the French side, the case of the ancient quarries at La Couronne once again shows (as previously mentioned for the quarries of the Murcia region and the use of El Mèdol stone in the Tarragona area) how a locally sourced stone indelibly influences the production and constructive aspects of a town and its territory (C. Pedini). The limestone of this area, located about 25 km west of Marseille, has supplied building material for the aforementioned town since the 2nd c. BCE, characterizing the colony's architecture in both Greek and Roman times. However, it is a stone that has never ceased to be used, right up to the modern age, with a particularly important period of use in Late Antiquity. Concerning the medieval and modern phases, the study of both the quarries and the monuments in which the use of Couronne stone has been attested was carried out by combining new technologies (photogrammetry, 3D scanner, drones) with an analysis of archival documentation. These methods have demonstrated how interdisciplinarity, and therefore the application of different research approaches, can lead to more comprehensive results.
Again on the French side, but in this case in the Val d'Oise on the Île-de-France, a detailed study of a technical aspect of the work (in this case the tools involved) was carried out at the Nucourt quarries (C. Blondeau). In fact, thanks also to the application of experimental archaeology, this evidence, together with the analysis of ancient extraction methods, has made it possible to define different chronological moments in the quarry's use (127). At the same time, three phases have been identified during which the material was used to reconstruct the town walls between the 10th and 12 c. CE (133).
Finally, the third section of the volume features a series of contributions on the organization, supply, and use of stone. The first essay presents an interesting approach to Iberian sculpture (T. Chapa, M. Belén, and J. García Cardiel). In fact, as the authors themselves point out, the analysis of the working process, from the stone extraction to the sculpting, is a line of research that has been completely absent from Iberian studies (138). Unfortunately, the investigation can only be carried out “in reverse order”: the starting point would be not the quarry sites but the sculptural elements. These would be linked to the extraction sites according to compatible stone compositions (145). Despite this challenge, the study makes an effort to learn about some of the economic aspects of those communities and that historical period.
The next contribution is devoted to granite quarries that supplied construction material to the Roman town of Augusta Emerita, modern Mérida (A. Pizzo, M. I. Mota, R. Fort, and M. Álvarez de Buergo). The characteristics of this stone make it difficult or even impossible to find preserved evidence that would allow us to reconstruct the extraction methods and work organization at the quarry sites. In this article the outcomes of the identification of new extraction faces around the Roman town are presented. Moreover, as a result of several archaeometric analyses, the Mérida theater is proposed as a case study in which the different types of granite used to build the monument have been linked to their extraction sites. The study is undoubtedly useful to ensure suitable restoration and conservation projects for historical buildings (154).
The last three contributions in the volume present approaches aimed at examining the relationship between monuments and extraction sites in specific contexts, even if they are from different historical periods. The use of sandstone (C. Roqué Pau and X. Rocas Gutiérrez) from the Folgueroles quarries (Bartoniense), near the town of Girona, is already attested in the construction of 6th-c. BCE Iberian settlements (167), as well as in Ampurias between the 2nd c. BCE and the 2nd c. CE, or in Gerunda and its area of influence. In the proposed study of Can Blai (Formentera, Balearic Islands), a fortress dating to Late Antiquity was built using stone from the local marès quarries (R. González Villaescusa, J. H. Fernández, G. Fronteau, and P. Vázquez). However, those quarries would not have provided sufficient stone for the completion of the building and therefore it is possible that other extraction sites were also exploited, although coastal erosion may mean that they have not been preserved. The last contribution in the volume is devoted to the limestone and conglomerate of Espejón which was quarried in the modern provinces of Soria and Burgos (V. García-Entero, A. Gutiérrez Garcia-Moreno and E. Zarco Martínez). This limestone is highly appreciated for its aesthetic value, mainly due to its chromatic variety. It was used in Roman times and even more abundantly between the 15th and 19th c. CE. This intensive exploitation in the modern era permitted the use of written sources, especially from archives, to integrate the data acquired during the fieldwork with interesting information on quarry management (192–93).
In conclusion, the articles present enough detailed plans for each studied site, as well as illustrations that help make the texts easy to follow. The footnotes and the bibliography are given in each article, making it simple to consult all the sources used at any moment. Perhaps it would have been desirable to attempt to add a concluding note highlighting the key points and challenges that arose about exploitation techniques and the organization of ancient quarries on the Iberian peninsula, perhaps arising from the debate held at the end of the conference.
This collection of papers presents contributions of considerable scientific interest. The attention is focused on the importance of studying even non-prestigious building materials, taking into account a wide chronological range. Unfortunately, little attention has been paid to these questions to date, as they are often perceived as less interesting than those centering on valuable materials such as marble. Questioning the analytical methodology to be adopted is important, and offers an opportunity for debate that takes into account the particular geographical and cultural characteristics, as well as the state of conservation, which is inevitably different for each site. All in all, there can be no doubt that this is a fundamental volume for the study of quarries in ancient times. We hope that the scientific meeting can be repeated in order to continue updating the state of the question.
