‘Mind–body medicine’, it becomes clear in the conclusion to The Cure Within, is the name current since the mid-1990s for all those therapies which build on the mind–body connection. It is a deliberately generic term for a host of options – ‘something for everyone’ (p. 245) – whereas earlier terms such as ‘psychic healing’, ‘positive thinking’, ‘psychosomatic medicine’, ‘holism’ and many others now appear linked to too specific and at least partly discredited approaches. Anne Harrington's book, written at one and the same time for historians, for anyone intrigued by the relations between science and the massive contemporary market for alternative therapy, and as part of her own quest for an unfractured humanness, is a most readable history of the origins and fate of the options. She is consistently even-handed and fair-minded, not caught up in the hype or denigration which so colours the world of therapy. Because she writes so well for a general audience, it is important to note just how wide her reading has been in the relevant sources, both expert and popular, and what a long engagement she has had with the issues, both as a historian and as a participant observer.
Harrington distinctively organizes her material around six ‘stories’ – themes around which people have shaped and still do shape what they say about mind's connection to body in the context of illness. She tells these ‘stories’ so that the reader can see where they come from, why, and with what therapeutic effect; she also discusses them as key ways in which people – not only patients – make sense of problems of well-being in the modern world. This scheme works extremely well as a way of organizing a mass of sources and holding the reader's attention. Her six plots, corresponding to six chapters, are: the power of suggestion (hypnotism), the body that speaks (hysteria), the power of positive thinking (positive emotions, the placebo effect), broken by modern life (stress), healing ties (community support) and eastward journeys (the wisdom of the East). I put in parentheses classic instances or buzzwords, just to signal the sort of phenomenon the author has in mind; in each case, her historical discussion is in fact wide-ranging.
Harrington is surely right to say that modern practice ‘is a recently constructed patchwork of quite distinct narrative traditions’ (p. 244), and it is no mean achievement to have so clearly described each of them and to have shown how they currently appear to have run together. In the conclusion, she puts forward some general reasons as to why mind–body medicine might appeal: the practical, therapeutic possibilities where physicalist medicine is demonstrably limited (for example, in cancer); the power of re-creating religious tradition in a supposedly secular age; the ability of mind–body viewpoints to be ‘amplifiers of a range of very distinctive moral and social concerns about the costs of modernity’ (p. 246); and the capability of mind–body medicine to take shape both in mainstream medicine and among its alternatives, and in expert communities and lay ones.
Writing the book in this way may have certain costs, though views about this will reasonably differ. First, with an eye on conventions of presentation in popular media, the style of writing is highly personalized: widely discussed intellectual arguments become moments of personal discovery for the author, and the personal pronoun ‘we’ does a lot of work. A certain kind of US audience is very much presupposed, and it is therefore striking that little is said about the material circumstances of this audience, such as the insurance industry and consumption. For the earlier periods, the book turns to Europe, but for the last two-thirds of the twentieth century the reference point is almost entirely North American. Second, the book has a built-in asymmetry. The author's motivation, on her own account, is for a larger view of being human than that which orthodox physicalist medicine, at least in much of modern practice, would seem to have. This history is of alternatives to the mainstream and does not ask how and why physicalist medicine acquired the authority it has – how and why it became the norm against which alternatives must measure themselves – even though those alternatives have been legion, indeed even sometimes the mainstream, in different ages and cultures. A naive reader might start from the assumption that ‘of course’ all therapy is mind–body therapy, and wonder what the fuss is about. But Harrington is not inclined to tackle the social and epistemological question of the standing of science. Third, the book is in effect a significant contribution to the medical anthropology of American culture. The concepts and theories which might connect with that field and open possibilities for the comparison of belief systems, however, are avoided (though the ubiquitous ‘we’ shows the extent to which informal sociological thinking is present).
These thoughts are not offered in an attempt to say the book should be something other than it is. In its own terms, it achieves what it sets out to do with admirable clarity, and it will surely have a large audience with reflective doctors and patients, actual or potential. As it also constructs a synthesis from a mass of historical material, it will greatly inform and stimulate historians interested in modern therapeutic culture.
