Alexander von Humboldt has arrived in America, two centuries after his initial landing. In The Passage to Cosmos, Laura Dassow Walls reclaims Humboldt's legacy for American intellectual history, tracing the rise and fall of a Humboldt ‘cult’ in the nineteenth-century United States. If, as Walls writes, Humboldt ‘literally put America on the global map’ (p. 17) as the frontier of scientific exploration, then Walls is to be thanked for putting a European author on the map of American environmental studies.
Walls sets out to counter recent critiques of Humboldt from scholars such as Mary Louise Pratt and Jorge Cañizares-Esguerra, who charge that his scientific survey of South America sidelined indigenous accomplishments and paved the way for US expansionism. Instead, Humboldt appears here as the voice of a politics linking environmental and social justice. Expansionism in the name of science and civilization was quite simply ‘an obscene perversion of Humboldt’ (p. 145). For Walls, Humboldt is the father of ‘ecology’, meaning a ‘discourse … a way of speaking about nature … a planetary interacting causal network operating across multiple scale levels, temporal and spatial, individual to social to natural, scientific to aesthetic to spiritual’ (p. 11). She reads Humboldt's essays on the natural and human history of the Americas as a challenge to narratives of imperial progress and as a source of new narratives to serve the projects of postcolonial states. In the tradition of Richard Grove, who portrayed Humboldt as among the progenitors of a modern global environmentalism, Walls argues that Humboldt's critiques of colonial land use were inseparable from his objections to the subjugation of native peoples. Humboldt's travels in South America, she argues, instilled in him a poignant humility. Struck, for instance, by the grandeur and volatility of tropical nature, he reflected on a mountaintop near Caracas that ‘man no longer appears as the centre of creation. Far from taming the elements, all his efforts tend to escape from their empire’ (p. 68, my italics). Flashing forward to the late twentieth century, Walls notes that the land Humboldt gazed upon would avenge itself with floods. There imperial ambitions would in fact come to nought.
Aaron Sachs has presented a similar argument in his beautifully crafted The Humboldt Current (2006). Walls, however, goes beyond Sachs in the range of her claims for Humboldt's historical significance. She traces his influence on nearly the entire pantheon of nineteenth-century American arts and letters – from Poe and Melville to Thomas Jefferson, whom Humboldt managed to engage in a frank exchange about slavery. She gives Humboldt ultimate credit for a startling array of cultural developments, including ‘the aesthetic and visual vocabulary of the American West’ (p. 135), the professionalization of American science in the 1840s, ‘every weather map in the morning paper’ (p. 128), ‘the twenty-first-century understanding of climate change and global warming’ (p. 110) and contemporary ‘ecocriticism’ (defined as an ‘earth-centered approach to literary studies’ (p. 243)). At times her prose strains under the effort to convey the enthusiasm of Humboldt's followers. In the same paragraph, for instance, she writes of Humboldt's ‘breathtakingly modern view’ and of his ideas that ‘took Goethe's breath away’ (p. 31).
Nicholas Rupke has shown that every age invents its own Humboldt, and Walls's Humboldt is above all else a ‘poet’ – not a scientist but the author of ‘a humanistic world view’ (p. 237). The book is at its best in analysing Humboldt as a writer at odds with the emerging scientific ideal of objectivity. Walls also offers penetrating interpretations of the images that adorned Humboldt's publications on the Americas, bringing out the nineteenth-century assumptions about the interdependence of nature and culture. The final chapter on Cosmos introduces her concept of ‘cosmography’, a genre that ‘romances the phenomena’ and uses ‘accuracy and imagination’ to ‘reinforce each other’ (pp. 222, 227).
In the end, Walls, a literary historian, wants to use Humboldt to bridge the gulf between ‘the two cultures’. But she will leave historians of science wondering about the relationship between ecology as discourse and ecology as science or politics – as a tool for intervening in the world. To be sure, this book is not intended for historians of science, for whom Humboldt will certainly not come as a discovery. Nonetheless, readers in our field will appreciate Walls's lively survey of Humboldtian trends in nineteenth-century American culture and her thoughtful readings of his cosmic ‘poetry’.
‘The world likes to see’, Humboldt wrote of his Essay on the Geography of Plants, with its famous illustration of the relationship between climate and altitude on Mt Chimborazo (p. 108). Prestel Press apparently agrees: they have brought out a magnificently produced tome of the engravings of Humboldt's South American botanical collection. Walter Lack provides a painstaking account of the decades-long quest to publish the original nineteen ‘massive’ volumes. He frames the book as part of a history of the production of knowledge about biodiversity. It is also a lesson in the degree to which Humboldt relied on scientific collaborators and artisans to bring the results of his research to the public. If, as Walls insists, Humboldt promoted a ‘subversive vision of science for the people’ (p. 129), Lack's volume is unabashedly science for the well-off collector.
