The editor is to be congratulated on this rich collection of papers, originating from a conference at Heidelberg in April 2004. Unlike so many conference proceedings, this volume really does add up to more than the sum of its parts, becoming a major contribution to our understanding of the central problems of Roman — especially Augustan — time. Each of the chapters is very much worth reading; I concentrate here on picking out some key themes which the chapters cumulatively illustrate as being of particular importance.
It is exciting to see the benefits that come from reading Augustan texts through the lenses of chronology, the calendar, world or Roman history, and cultural or anthropological history. Some of the texts discussed here are ones which we are accustomed to reading through such lenses, such as Virgil's Aeneid, but some are not — Virgil's Georgics, for example, or Tibullus' elegies, or Ovid's exile poetry, as discussed here respectively by Philip Hardie, Jacqueline Fabre-Serris, and Stephen Hinds. In each case these new perspectives pay startling dividends, as they do in the case of Callimachus' Aetia, the subject of an excellent presentation by Damien Nelis, who shows that Virgil will have read the Aetia as a text concerned with the same issues as his own Aeneid — the causal relationships between the remote past and the present, the retrospective construction of imperial structures of meaning upon the morass of data in the past.
The editor, Jürgen Paul Schwindt, sets the scene with an important contrast between the Augustans and the preceding generation, highlighting the Neoterics' preference for a time in the here and now (hic et nunc), as opposed to the more open-ended or historically contextualized space-time of the Augustans. There is a great deal to this, as Schwindt shows in a series of acute readings, even if we should not lose sight of the layering of the past revealed in Catullus 64, with its movements from myth to history to the contemporary world, or in fr. 6 (Hollis) of Cinna's Propempticon Pollionis, in which Cinna opens up deep perspectives of time from comparative world chronology, reaching back to the foundations of Argos, Athens, and Thebes. The generation preceding that of Virgil, Horace, and Augustus had already had to do major work on assimilating the time-frames of the oecumenē, especially in response to the stunning conquests of Pompeius Magnus; when Catullus (and probably Cinna) went to Bithynia with Memmius in 57 b.c., the province had only been part of the Imperium for six years.
For the Augustan poets' conception of time, the outstanding figures of the previous generation were Varro qua chronographer, together with Lucretius and Cicero, the former for his cultural history, the latter above all for his literary history: Citroni here gives us a powerful argument about Cicero's views of the growth of oratory in Rome, showing how profoundly Horace engaged with Cicero's picture as he developed his views of the way poetry in Rome had moved through, phases of growth to reach maturity with his own work and that of his few peers. The crucial importance of Lucretius' understanding of the time-frames of the human past comes through especially in the chapter by Philip Hardie (now ch. 2 of Lucretian Receptions: History, the Sublime, Knowledge (2009)). Hardie's Cosmos and Imperium made it clear how absolutely central Lucretius was to the intellectual formation of Virgil's epic, and now Hardie compellingly demonstrates how central Lucretius was to the Eclogues and Georgics as well, while showing in addition how important Lucretian vistas of change and flux were to Horace's understanding of the destiny of human language and of human linguistic artefacts. Lucretius' cultural history also figures prominently in the chapters of Jean-Christophe Jolivet on Virgil's Polyphemus and of Alessandro Schiesaro on Virgil's Dido. Jolivet's fascinating chapter uses a Lucretian backdrop of cultural development as a new setting for the liminal life-style of the Cyclopes; his shrewd readings of the scholiasts' exegesis of the Odyssey make it plain that Virgil has systematically availed himself of the Homeric commentary tradition in order to produce a modernized and more coherent picture of the developmental stage of the Cyclopes. Schiesaro's use of Lucretian cultural history is part of a subtle and sophisticated analysis of Dido's alternative time-view, one un-anchored in the onward drive of Roman imperial teleology, where Dido might have remained free of ‘the contradictory demands of desire and duty’ (102–3). He could have historicized this highly valuable insight even more, for Dido's personal desire to deny time and history could be a figure for the Roman need to cast her people out of a rôle in world history, with the obliteration of Carthage setting the seal on the Carthaginians' non-participation in the shaping of Mediterranean history, so that they appear doomed from the start to be an eddy, a back-water.
The various negotiations between mythical and historical or contemporary time receive attention in a number of chapters, especially those of Jacqueline Fabre-Serris on Tibullus and Mario Labate on Ovid. Fabre-Serris presents a knowing Tibullus, perfectly capable of pushing back against Virgil in order to reclaim a foundational rôle for levis amor. Labate's rich chapter has now been substantially taken over to form ch. III.2 of his recent magisterial treatment of the ‘mythical period’ in Ovid, Passato remoto: età mitiche e identità augustea in Ovidio (2010). Labate shows how intricately intertwined Ovid's Fasti is with Hesiod's cosmologies, and his fine arguments consistently illuminate Ovid's recasting of Rome's primal time, the time of deep origins.
A more ‘personal’ kind of time-negotiation is treated by Gianpiero Rosati in his penetrating discussion of epistolary time in Ovid's Heroides, and by Stephen Hinds in his bold casting of the calendrical net over all of Ovid's poetry, not just the Fasti. Hinds acutely brings out how Ovid's understanding of Julius Caesar's new time-machine informs far more of his poetry than we usually assume; a particular high point in this eye-opening discussion is his treatment of Ovid's birthday, observance, or non-observance, of which becomes a running theme across the boundary between the Fasti and the exile poetry.
The collection, then, adds very substantially to our understanding both of Augustan poetry and of Augustan time. My only complaint, in conclusion, is that there is neither a general index nor an index locorum; given the very broad range of authors and topics treated, such indices would have further increased the utility of an already exceptionally useful book.
