Nile Green, a prolific scholar of Sufism in South Asian Islam, has written another work of impressive, even humbling, scholarship. In Bombay Islam, he focuses on Bombay in the 19th and early 20th centuries as a locus for Muslim religious developments that affected places as far distant as Iran and South Africa. The metropolis drew Muslim laborers and religious figures from its hinterlands of Gujarat, the Konkan coast, and the princely state of Hyderabad into a vortex of sectarian and devotional interaction. The port city then exported its multifarious religious innovations throughout the Indian Ocean region. Green's work reminds us that Islam is what Muslims do, and what Muslims did in that time period included both reformist proselytizing and popular pageantry, abetted by the market forces of this vibrant imperial city.
The Bombay marketplace portrayed by Green encompassed the industrial settlements that attracted workers to the factories and tenements, the railroad hub that brought people of all classes and callings to the city, and the steamship lines that enabled an increased volume of both trade and hajj pilgrimage. Furthermore, the development of the press (especially lithography) led to an explosion of publications, among them newspapers and periodicals, missionary tracts, translations of scripture, and a cacophony of cheap guides to prayer, devotional practice, and saints’ exemplary lives. The urban and industrialized environment thus enabled not only the production of modernity but also ironically—and this is Green's main point—a reinforcement of tradition, or the invention of new traditions, to the detriment of modernist reform. Christian missionaries may have shown the way with their associations and tract publications, but their methods of propagation were soon adopted and adapted by other religious practitioners, whether Hindu, Muslim, or Parsi. Green details the rise of new Sufi shrines in the city, centers for workers and pilgrims to express their devotion and pay for religious services that involved comradeship, solace, and bodily healing. He also recounts the careers of, among others, the first Agha Khan, who came to Bombay from central Iran in the 19th century and revived Ismaʿilism, and of Habib ʿAli Shah, a Sufi pīr from Hyderabad who became the religious guide for mill hands and dockyard workers.
This is a fascinating and challenging account of popular Islam in a modernizing context, demonstrating the complexities of religious evolution and cautioning against rigid modern versus traditional and reform versus custom dichotomies, although certainly the idea of “the modernity of tradition” has been heard of prior to the publication of this book. I was particularly impressed by Green's discussion of printed texts as sources of individual religious instruction, in which he poses the question of why they did not displace Sufi pīrs in that role. He resolves this puzzle with a detailed argument concerning the centrality of the mediating role of the Sufi as a source of personal spiritual guidance. Even a deceased Sufi can be contemplated by the disciple in ways that textual instruction cannot touch.
While a convincing portrayal of the tenacity of customary Islam in a time of rapid change, Green's work is not without flaws. Its utilization of terminology of international capitalism to characterize the process it describes is distracting, even mildly exasperating. Why, for example, are missionary societies called “missionary firms” and Sufi brotherhoods “Sufi brotherhood firms”? The Agha Khan's enterprise (the terminology is catching) is described as a very successful “family firm.” Sufis supply “religious services,” and some of the newly constructed shrines are “franchises” of original shrines in the provinces. The notion of franchises summons up visions of Golden Arches. But while Green illustrates his text (p. 5) with a variety of headdresses indicative of those worn by Muslims in Bombay, nowhere does he include a paper hat! Green could have made his point about the persistence of the need for religious “enchantment” in the modern marketplace of ideas without using distracting nomenclature. So (paper) hats off to Nile Green for writing a provocative as well as instructive addition to the literature on both Bombay and modern Islam in all their complexity.
