In 2006, John O'Malley, a well-regarded Jesuit historian of Christianity, taped thirty-six lectures on the history of the papacy. He then took the transcripts of those tapes and rewrote them to produce this book. The past decade has seen other histories of the papacy ranging from the execrable Absolute Monarchs by John Julius Norwich (Random House, 2011) to a 2006 revised third edition of Eamon Duffy's Saints and Sinners (Yale University Press). O'Malley pays fair tribute to the Duffy volume in introducing his own, noting that his own book is not as ample as that of Duffy. Both authors, it must be said, do share a common ability in writing clear, readable prose and a level of comfort when describing historical events.
The main problem with writing a cogent one-volume history of the papacy is that there have been so many popes over the two millennia of Christian history and, if one desires a history that does not degenerate into the turgid “one damn thing after another” reduction of the text into a mere chronicle, certain reductive choices must be made. O'Malley's approach is to cluster some of the popes into a time frame while breaking that narrative line with a chapter either highlighting one particular pope because of his critical role at a given time in history or taking a theme within which a number of popes are discussed seriatim. Thus, to cite one example from the beginning of the volume, O'Malley devotes an opening chapter on the issue of whether Peter should be considered the first pope or simply enjoy the higher classification as “apostle.” He then has a chapter on the bishops of Rome up to Constantine, with Constantine receiving a separate chapter, followed in turn by a chapter on Damasus and Leo the Great; part 1 ends with a (wonderfully balanced) chapter considering Gregory the Great.
O'Malley follows that strategy throughout this volume. While he sees his first responsibility as providing us a coherent narrative of the history of the papacy, he is also cognizant of the ways in which popes agglutinated to themselves titles, privileges, and powers that must be understood to avoid an ahistorical concept of the papacy. This is not only an important task for the historian but of interest to anyone professionally concerned with understanding the papacy in terms of ecclesiology and for serious ecumenical discussion. O'Malley shows how and when the bishop of Rome ceased calling himself the Vicar of Peter and assumed the title Vicar of Christ, which was once a title of every bishop. He explains the significance of the slow emergence in modern times of the use of the encyclical as an instrument of teaching when in older days the pope satisfied himself with entering theological discourse only when heresy became an issue. Similarly, the now universal practice of restricting to the pope the right of naming bishops is a very modern practice in the church while it is only from medieval times that canonizations became the sole prerogative of the papacy. Finally, O'Malley is excellent in delineating how pressures external to the papacy itself brought into strong relief papal claims; that pressure was regnant from the tensions between Rome and Byzantium as it was in clarifying the claims of general councils in the parlous days of the Babylonian Captivity and the Western Schism, to say nothing of the reactions to papal claims during and after the sixteenth-century Reformation. He is also cogent in showing how the office of the cardinals slowly evolved and how that office relates to the church in Rome.
The contemporary papacy, of course, has been largely shaped by events that occurred during the papacy of Pius IX who was in office from 1846 to 1878. It was during his papacy that the Papal States were lost when Italy was unified—a loss that was providential in that the pope was no longer burdened as a secular ruler. Almost, as it were, in compensation for that loss did the doctrine of papal infallibility, enhancing papal spiritual authority, become a dogmatic truth at the First Vatican Council in 1870. The loss of the Papal States with its attendant ramifications was not settled until the Lateran Treaties were negotiated in 1929 during the papacy of Pius XI. However, the inflation of papal claims enhanced by the infallibility declaration was a persistent theological problem, since Vatican I adjourned before the relationship between papacy and the office of bishops had been settled. The documents of Vatican II reflect an attempt at a balanced understanding of that relationship but the issue is still not articulated with full satisfaction.
O'Malley is quite balanced and judicious in his judgment about more recent popes. He recognizes the “silence” problem associated with the papacy of Pius XII but, rightly, refuses to judge the Pian papacy only though that lens. His profile of John XXIII disabuses any picture of that shrewd and intelligent person to be reduced down to a caricature of an innocent peasant priest. Similarly he recognizes both the gifts and the problems of Paul VI whose papacy, alas, is too often remembered only for the encyclical Humanae Vitae and its strictures about contraception. His chapter on John Paul II (surely to give the papal hagiographer George Weigel mild cramps) is fair in describing both the Polish pope's not inconsiderable accomplishments and his blind spots.
In an epilogue to his book O'Malley makes a very critical point: the history of the papacy is not the history of Catholicism. After all, as he notes, who is more important for the history of the church, Pope Innocent III or Francis of Assisi? That being said, it is the case that the story of Catholicism cannot be told without a grasp of that office which is the oldest in Western civilization.
This book, while not on a par with Eamon Duffy's Saints and Sinners, is a compact, readable, and reliable work on the papacy by one of our very best church historians.
