Well known as an accomplished interpreter of the cosmologies and epistemologies of Descartes and Francis Bacon, Stephen Gaukroger has conceived an ambitious project requiring no fewer than five projected volumes, of which The Emergence of a Scientific Culture is the first. His overarching goal is to document and explain the processes that produced one of the distinctive features of modern Western culture : not merely the primacy of the sciences as a source of knowledge but, more specifically, the assimilation of all cognitive values to the scientific. To make headway it is necessary first to understand how an incipient and heterogeneous scientific culture in sixteenth- and seventeenth-century Europe was consolidated into an enduring body of enquiry with goals, methods and institutions all its own. Cross-cultural comparisons do not dominate the book, but in a revealing preface Gaukroger explains that they played a heuristic role in his appreciation of the contingency and precariousness of scientific values, the contrast with China in particular persuading him that the legitimation of controversial reconstructions of natural philosophy in Europe probably had a lot to do with the Christian religion. Gaukroger is not in the business of diminishing the achievements of earlier scientific movements, in China and Arabia, but their ‘boom-and-bust’ character does invite an investigation into the peculiarities of intellectual life in Western Europe that engendered distinctive and resilient forms of legitimation. The thesis of his substantial and impressive book is that Christianity indeed played a major role, not, as often proposed, through the dissociation of science from religious concerns, but through a reconstituted partnership between Christianity and (a reconstructed) natural philosophy : a partnership very different from the failing Christianized Aristotelianism of the Thomists. This thesis is not a religious apologia, but it is boldy stated. It is not merely that there were resources within Christianity that could provide justification for new empirical methods of enquiry; rather ‘Christianity set the agenda for natural philosophy in many respects and projected it forward in a way quite different from that of any other scientific culture’ (p. 3).
How did this come about? Gaukroger is especially instructive when analysing the deficiencies of the limited conciliation between Christian theology and Aristotelian philosophy achieved by Aquinas, and the new pressures to which it was subjected in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. Theological concerns about the inadequacy of Thomas's discussion of the origins of the universe and the constraints he had placed on the discernment of design in nature were compounded by the challenge from the autonomous naturalism of Pomponazzi and Bruno. Crucially : and this is at the heart of the book : the integrity of Aristotelian natural philosophy was challenged by new developments in disciplines, such as practical mathematics (notably astronomy and mechanics) and natural history, whose standing was problematic precisely because they had been excluded from natural philosophy by Aristotle. It was in the legitimation of these aspiring disciplines that need was felt for new forms of conciliation, which Christian theology could provide and which helped to mould a new persona for the natural philosopher : the priest in the temple of nature, as Robert Boyle would describe it.
Gaukroger observes that the novel disciplines were at a sufficiently early stage in their development to be easily connected with a religious view of the world. As an early example from astronomy he includes Kepler's commitment to a cosmological archetype that he believed did justice both to the Copernican innovation and to God's intentions. A ‘symbiotic union’ between a revised natural philosophy and Christian theology reached its zenith in England in the 1680s, realized not only through a higher profile for the kind of natural theology epitomized by Boyle, but also through a method of ‘triangulation’. By this Gaukroger means the effort to attain knowledge of nature that would simultaneously be a legitimate interpretation of a biblical text and a legitimate interpretation of empirical data. With specific reference to natural history, he contends that ‘the relation between accounts of natural events in revelation and the natural-historical understanding of such events was a particularly promising area as far as the convergence of interests was concerned’ (p. 507). Illustrating the change from earlier emblematic readings of nature, he observes that the Garden of Eden and the Flood no longer signified spiritual truths accessible via allegorical interpretation. In the newly Christianized natural history, the location of the Garden and the extent of the Flood became empirical questions requiring, for an answer, physical exploration and analysis.
The ‘symbiotic union’ to which Gaukroger refers could be achieved only by changes in both Christianity and natural philosophy. For his discussion of biblical hermeneutics and the demise of allegorical interpretation he owes a transparent and acknowledged debt to Peter Harrison, whose The Bible, Protestantism and the Rise of Natural Science (Cambridge, 1998) maps similar preconditions for the possibility of a socially and religiously respectable interrogation of nature. Other commentators have preceded Gaukroger in stressing the catalytic role played by Christian values in the early stages of modern science, and in recognizing the irony that in the process a natural theology that had once belonged to the discipline of theology was to become the property of natural philosophy and eventually to marginalize rather than corroborate revelation. But I am not aware of any other treatment of these themes that combines so magisterially a discerning account of changing boundaries between disciplines with a dispassionate analysis of the changing relations between theology and the sciences. The result is a scholarly exploration on the grand scale, the bibliography of works cited extending to some forty pages. Even so, there are omissions. Given Gaukroger's focus on changing understandings of the meaning and scope of natural philosophy, he would have been well qualified to offer diachronically sensitive reflections on the dispute between Andrew Cunningham and Edward Grant concerning the relationship between natural philosophy and natural theology. (For Gaukroger's comments on this dispute, see his review in this issue, pp. NN:NN.) And given his stress on the legitimating role of Christian values, one might have expected engagement with Mordechai Feingold's 2002 essay in Science in Context (15, 79:119), ‘Science as a calling? The early modern dilemma’, where the twin loyalties of clerical natural philosophers in England are shown, in practice, to have been under various forms of strain. But these are minor quibbles in the context of so fine a historical synthesis.
