Alison Morrison-Low's book covers the period from 1760 to 1851, during which the manufacture and retail of scientific instruments developed in provincial centres such as Liverpool, Birmingham and Sheffield. Although London still dominated production, by the time of the Great Exhibition firms away from the capital were making names for themselves, both domestically and abroad, and had in some cases developed niche production areas, such as the making of rules and scales in Birmingham. Three pairs of provincial cities with clear similarities – Bristol and Liverpool, York and Sheffield, Manchester and Birmingham – are the subjects of the book's opening discussions. From here it considers other smaller production centres such as the English ports and spa towns, and then London. These factually rich chapters are followed by explorations of industrial organization and production in the provinces, the different markets for instruments that evolved and the mechanisms for supplying those markets.
The agenda here derives from the late John Millburn, who in a 1986 review bemoaned historians' scant knowledge of the scientific instrument industry and set out the challenges faced in studying it, notably those arising from what Morrison-Low describes as ‘the maddeningly elusive information that lies just below the surface of the available historical evidence’ (p. 296). In addressing Millburn's concerns, Morrison-Low has attempted to reveal a great deal about financing, marketing, organization, workforce skills and industrial relations. She shows convincingly that the provincial trade grew into something more extensive than has been previously assumed. She also addresses the effects of the Industrial Revolution on the trade and vice versa.
At heart the book is about making and selling objects. A key contention – and an appropriate standpoint for an experienced curator at the National Museums of Scotland – is that museums should be promoting the study of surviving artefacts. It is the more gratifying, therefore, that Morrison-Low explicitly considers the vagaries of the preservation of objects in museums and the consequences for a study such as this one. In the end she favours a balanced approach, drawing on artefacts as evidence while remaining aware of the potential pitfalls of relying on them as the only evidence. To complement her instrumental base, Morrison-Low has assembled an impressive array of sources – directories, business records (the few that remain), probate and insurance records, first-hand accounts, among many others – with much of the data usefully illustrated and summarized in the many graphs and charts. The evidence from these sources is brought together very effectively through a self-consciously cross-disciplinary approach that will make this book a model for future studies. In her foreword, Ludmilla Jordanova gives a fair impression of the coverage: ‘economic history, gender and family, the history of science and technology, material culture, business history, patterns of migration, and much more besides’ (p. 2).
Commendable for its excellent survey of existing literature – the bibliography alone is an ideal starting point for anyone interested in scientific instrument-making – Morrison-Low's book also adds to that literature by providing a comprehensive overview of the English trade. As such, it complements publications in recent years by John Millburn, Anita McConnell and others on individual firms such as that of the Adams family and Troughton & Simms. Likewise, it puts flesh on the bones of Gloria Clifton's Directory of British Scientific Instrument Makers 1550–1851 (London, 1995). The appendix of regional makers, for example, adds to Clifton's work by providing a geographical overview that is difficult to extract from the Directory alone.
As a read, the book is factually dense, although this is also a strength: it is a work to refer to and draw from. And there are lighter touches – for instance, the revelation that the need to diversify in regional centres with small customer-bases led makers to sell apparently unrelated products such as hearth brushes, toasting forks, umbrella frames, dog collars and coffin furniture.
Only occasionally did I feel that there was scope for expansion. Although London is not the book's focus, I wondered, for example, if the discussion of the capital could have been developed further. By concentrating on the precision end of production, Morrison-Low's analysis does not explore regional differentiation within the metropolis, with upmarket retailers in the City and west offering different ranges of products to quite different clients from those around London's docks in the east. Such emphases might in turn have allowed interesting parallels to be drawn with changes in the provincial trade. I would also like to have seen some illustrations in colour, since the author has assembled a good range of images, to which the black-and-white reproductions do not do justice. But these are minor points that do not undermine the overall value of the work. Making Scientific Instruments in the Industrial Revolution can be recommended to anyone studying the history of science during the period. It is a resource to come back to again and again.
