This study of extremist Shiʿi groups in early Islamic Iraq and (to a lesser extent) Iran is a most welcome addition to the literature on Shiʿism and early Islamic history. It is well written, thoroughly documented, and convincingly argued. The author focuses on the four early extremist Shiʿi groups that developed around the anti-Umayyad rebel leaders Bayan ibn Samʿan, al-Mughira ibn Saʿid, Abu Mansur al-ʿIjli, and ʿAbd Allah ibn Muʿawiya.
Prior to looking at each of these movements separately, Tucker provides a brief treatment of Umayyad rule in Iraq, which elucidates the geographic and temporal context of this study. He also discusses the two earliest proto-Shiʿi groups and the leaders around whom these movements coalesced (Ibn Sabaʾ and the Sabaʾiyya, and al-Mukhtar and the Kaisaniyya) as a prelude to addressing the four Shiʿi groups of the Umayyad period that are the main object of his study. In addressing these precursor movements, Tucker describes their beliefs, theorizes about the potential sources of such beliefs, and delineates the ideas that each of these movements brought to Shiʿism. Aside from observing the possible ideological influences of these two movements on the later ones, Tucker notes some of the continuities between these groups and the later Shiʿi movements under discussion. In particular, he examines how they attracted the same segments of the population, such as the mawālī who became a significant part of later Shiʿi movements after their participation in al-Mukhtar's rebellion, and some Arab tribes such as the Banu ʿIjl who participated in al-Mukhtar's rebellion as well as in the movements of al-Mughira ibn Saʿid, Abu Mansur, and possibly Bayan ibn Samʿan.
In four subsequent, elaborate chapters, Tucker investigates the groups that constitute the main subject of his study. He lays out what is known or claimed about their leaders and judiciously attempts to meet the historiographical challenge of reconstructing these heresiarchs’ thoughts and teachings, as well as what may have been elaborations on these thoughts and teachings by the heresiarchs’ followers. Indeed, the bulk of the material available to the historian is derived from sources that were clearly hostile to such unorthodox movements and their ideas. Tucker also traces the connections between these four later movements and notes the contribution of each group to the doctrinal evolution of the ghulāt as well as the influence of their ideas upon later Shiʿi movements. Tucker additionally suggests the possible sources of the four groups’ religious doctrines and shows how their ideology was “a synthesis of non-Islamic and Islamic ideas,” a fact that, he surmises, may account for the attraction these groups held for elements such as the mawālī (pp. 109–10). Tucker goes on to examine the possible influence of these sects on other types of groups, namely, the later Sufis and the early Abbasid, mostly Persian sects (such as the movement associated with Ishaq the Turk, al-Muqannaʿ, Babak, the Khattabiyya, and the Qarmatians) and even some much later sects (such as the Hurufiyya and the Mushaʿshaʿiyya), pointing to some similarities in their ideas and teachings. Tucker is aware that he cannot be categorical in this regard but points to interesting similarities that lend possible credence to his suggestions.
The most important and truly original feature of this study, however, resides in Tucker's broad scope. He goes beyond merely elucidating the role played by these movements in an Islamic context by emphasizing their larger significance as millenarian movements. Throughout his treatment of the four later Shiʿi groups, then more significantly in a subsection of Chapter 6, entitled “Millenarism and the Sects” (pp. 120–32), Tucker builds on the works of Norman Cohn, Peter Worsley, Wilhelm Mühlmann, and Yonina Talmon, who have in past decades investigated the nature and features of millenarian movements. He shows that the movements he studied share many characteristics with other millenarian movements that are both geographically and temporally diverse (be they medieval, colonial or postcolonial, European, Asian, African, or Latin American) but that they also have their own peculiarities. By positioning his book as one that deals with early Islamic history but fits comfortably in the much larger phenomenon of millenarianism, Tucker calls upon scholars of the latter to pay attention to these Islamic movements and to account for the variations they have to offer to the millenarian models. In doing so, he posits these movements not merely as marginal groups that had a significant, though somewhat limited, influence in one cultural context and one historical time period but also as movements that are part of a global phenomenon of religious revolution; further, he suggests that their echoes are still perceptible in contemporary Middle Eastern religious and political life, by pointing to the strength of some of the motifs associated with these early Shiʿi groups in the Iranian Revolution and to their more perceptible influence on the greater Shiʿi revival in the 21st century.
The only unfortunate aspect of this book is the frequency of Arabic transliteration mistakes. In the body of the text, one encounters such inexcusable errors as dabbat al-ʿard for dabbat al-ard (p. 16), al-ʿAnsari for al-Ansari (p. 20), al-ʿAshtar for al-Ashtar (p. 21), ʿIjli for ʿIjlī, Azariqa for Azāriqa (p. 71), and most egregiously, the Battle of Mutʿa for the Battle of Muʾta (p. 101); numerous other (sometimes shocking) infelicities can be found in sections I and II of the bibliography.
Despite such regrettable oversights, William Tucker's Mahdis and Millenarians remains a book well worthy of a read. It should be on the reading list of every graduate student of Islamic history and of great interest to any serious student of comparative millenarianism.
