The notion of masculinity in crisis has long held both cultural and social currency in the modern and postmodern eras. However, it is only in the past two decades that the broader study of men and masculinities has made some small inroads into theatrical, film, visual art, and cultural studies. Until recently, for the scholar of masculinities in these fields, there has been a distinct lack of critical material, with researchers in the arts all too often finding themselves consulting social science journals or wandering over to the sociology sections of their libraries. Fintan Walsh's Male Trouble: Masculinity and the Performance of Crisis addresses this lacuna in a broad, complex, and interdisciplinary manner by examining the concept of masculinity in crisis in several performing art forms: live art, film, drama and theatre, social happenings, and public spectacle.
Walsh's book is heavily inflected by psychoanalytic and queer theory; indeed, he informs the reader quite early on not only that his title Male Trouble is drawn from Judith Butler's polemical Gender Trouble (Routledge, 1990), but also that his work is driven by a series of scholarly interventions in the area of masculinity and queer studies, citing Lynne Segal, Michael D. Snediker, Bracha Ettinger, and Susan Faludi among others as the direct impetus for his research. However, the psychoanalytic and queer slant to his writing should not deter any readers who themselves may not be heavily invested in such critical paradigms. Throughout his culturally and theoretically enlightening introduction, Walsh explicates very clearly the fundamental tenets of each of the theories upon which he will later draw. These explications are augmented with both cultural and political examples, and with ample references to further critical and theoretical writings on the topics. Indeed, the introduction to Male Trouble could easily stand alone as part of the reading list for graduate seminars and classes that aim to trigger student discussions of the psychoanalytic study of gender-masculinity. Furthermore, within this already compelling introduction, Walsh successfully differentiates his work from other investigations into the concept of masculinity in crisis by questioning the social and cultural entity of “crisis” itself. Finding that crisis is a performative act (in the Butlerian sense) rather than an epistemological state, he interrogates not only the notion of exactly what “crisis” might be and might mean, but also whom it might benefit.
One could worry after such a strong introduction that Walsh may have peaked too early, but such fears are quickly allayed in the chapters that follow. Walsh's approach proves its worth, with his psychoanalytic modes of analysis expertly complementing his interdisciplinary flexibility. Beginning in Chapter 2 with an examination of sacrificial masculinity in Mel Gibson's 2004 film The Passion of the Christ, each of the following chapters gives an extremely close and erudite reading of one or two artworks, films, plays, or public spectacles, each one (with the exception of the activist group Fathers 4 Justice in Chapter 6) performed or produced by an individual male artist. Walsh widens the concept of masculinities in crisis to such an extent that at first the reader is often surprised that his various artistic sources could fall under the remit of crisis-ridden masculinity, only to feel—after absorbing his persuasive analyses and arguments—slightly confounded that she or he didn't think of reading these works within this particular framework before.
Walsh sustains his argument throughout the book without ever giving a sense of repeating himself. The flow of chapters seems organic to his thesis, moving from the aforementioned reading of The Passion of the Christ into an examination of impotent hypermasculinities in two works by Irish writer Mark O'Rowe, the play Made in China and the film InterMission. From there Walsh segues nicely into an analysis of the gay male subject and his cultural journey toward self-punishment and sacrifice in two 1990s plays by “in-yer-face” dramatist Mark Ravenhill, the notoriously titled Shopping and Fucking and Faust Is Dead. Walsh's fifth chapter examines the male body in crisis through the lens of the work of live artists Franko B and Ron Athey, finding in their art a performance of control and inviolability underwriting masculine biopolitics. Chapter 6 interrogates the public spectacles of escapologist David Blaine and the guerrilla activism of protest group Fathers 4 Justice, eliciting from their social spectacles and public happenings a trend toward heroic masculinity that goes to great pains to avoid notions of vulnerability. The penultimate chapter, through a reading of the MTV television show and resultant movie Jackass, examines the new laddism of the 1990s and beyond, and discovers moves toward the normalization of abjection. It is in his conclusion, however, that Walsh is most polemic, using the work of performance artist Taylor Mac to offer a “wishful epilogue” (183) for an ethic of fragilization, which dissolves the hyperbolized, victimized norm of masculinity in crisis while simultaneously calling for a rethinking of the feminine as traumatized and abject.
Walsh is at his strongest when examining narrative dramatic forms, particularly theatre. This is not to say that his analyses of live art, film, or social spectacle are weak. Indeed one of the major benefits of this study are the nuanced ways in which Walsh broadens psychoanalytic interrogations of his chosen art forms out into wider cultural and social analyses. This is one of those rare books that successfully forges links between the psychoanalytic and the cultural spheres of art and lived experience. Probing in its analyses of its artistic sources, and unafraid in its interrogations of Western masculinity, Walsh's Male Trouble is a unique and persuasively rigorous ethicopolitical intervention into the notion of “masculinity in crisis.” It belongs on every gender, performance, or cultural studies scholar's bookshelf, and should also be required reading for graduate programs within these fields.
