Like other volumes in the Palgrave series Cognitive Studies in Literature and Performance, Shakespearean Neuroplay demonstrates ways in which recent cognitive theory can help us understand the impact of theatrical events on their spectators. Amy Cook sets out to provide new tools for theatre practitioners, as well as to deepen the academic conversation between humanists and scientists, choosing Hamlet as her central object of study because its status as ‘intellectual shibboleth’ makes it a good test of any theory's adequacy to explain the workings of language onstage (p. 2). She uses conceptual metaphor theory, as developed by George Lakoff and others, to analyse cognitive models that enable theatre audiences to process Shakespeare's complex imagery. Gilles Fauconnier and Mark Turner's cognitive blending theory provides Cook with another central tool. Rather than seeking to explain what Hamlet means, she uses these cognitive linguistic approaches to discuss Shakespeare's text and productions of Hamlet make their meanings. Cook argues that ‘one must be able to understand the elements compressed and intensified in a performance’ in order to ‘read, interpret, or even receive it’ (p. 36). This is something that a theatre audience does more or less easily and automatically. Those of us who stage plays or analyse productions would do well to understand the receptive process.
After an explanation of cognitive blending that ‘illuminates . . . the split between action and agency in Hamlet’, with Ophelia's drowning as a central example (p. 41), Cook turns to the play's use of mirror imagery. She shows how references to mirrors prime and evoke mental spaces that ‘share networks of associations’, gradually building up connections to create a ‘scaffolding of meaning’ (p. 76). Moving from text to production, she discusses stagings by Ingmar Bergman in 1988, and Livliu Ciulei in 1986, as well as Michael Almereyda's film adaptation of 2000 with particular emphasis on Sam Shepard's performance as the Ghost and the film's use of hand gestures. Here, as elsewhere, the analysis is promising. A reader primarily interested in performance analysis will wish for more development than the book's focus on cognitive linguistics allows. The discussion of gesture would benefit from a wider consideration of scholarship in discourse analysis. As Cook notes with respect to the study of rhetoric during the early modern period, the most recent work in cognitive studies can sometimes seem derivative. She argues, though, that the discipline aims not to ‘be the first to say it’ but instead to ‘to say it such that it fits with research not on theater, rhetoric, or poetry, but on how we think and communicate’ (p. 168 n. 29). Readers who share this interest will find in Shakespearean Neuroplay a useful consideration of some prominent theories.
