It is a singular distinction to be known as the most notorious and controversial statesman of a political epoch as dynamic, as volatile, as rich in provocative personalities and political intrigue as that of ancient Athens. Yet this is the distinction that unambiguously belongs to Alcibiades. The extant accounts of his life and times portray a career of breathtaking twists and turns in which the whole Greek world became entangled, a wild zigzagging path blazed across the Mediterranean and marked by sensational political victories, audacious military exploits, astonishing errors of judgment, scandalous acts of double-crossing and treason, and calamitous turns of fortune. At its core, Alcibiades's is a story driven by the passions and longings of a soul of incomparable extremes and intensity, a potent combination of nimble mind, spirited confidence, daring boldness, skillful cunning, roguish swagger, devastating charisma, multifaceted and exuberant immodesty, moral elasticity, uncanny political acuity, powerful love of glory, and above all, insatiable ambition. It is this whirlwind of heart-stopping, sensational drama that David Stuttard has attempted to capture in his beautifully written Nemesis: Alcibiades and the Fall of Athens. For despite the made-for-Hollywood quality of Alcibiades's biography, none of the ancient sources that tell his story have been written for the sake of technicolor thrills. Alcibiades plays an important but only intermittent role in the complex didactic works of Thucydides and Xenophon, historians of the Peloponnesian War (the broad setting for the whole of Alcibiades's career), and Plutarch's biography, while devoted to Alcibiades, is a vehicle for his own highly edifying but relatively tersely composed moral lessons in character, virtue, and political prudence. As for more recent biographies, such as the notable works of Hatzfeld, Ellis, and Rhodes, they generally and understandably present academic attempts—historiographical, philological, etc.—to sort fact from legend in the vast collection of contemporary and posthumous accounts and anecdotes surrounding Alcibiades. Each of these works has its place and relative merit, but none provides the page-turning excitement that their utterly fascinating subject seems so inherently able to provide.
Hence, Stuttard has attempted to stitch together what is known about Alcibiades's life into a smooth, readable, engaging narrative “written not for the specialist but for the general reader” to enjoy (7). Although he claims that he has been “forced to make hard choices over which precise path to follow” through contradictory historical, biographical, and anecdotal evidence, the truth is that Stuttard appears to have fit almost every extant mention of Alcibiades's name, from the well-attested dates and places to the surely apocryphal lore, into his novelistic narrative, leaving admissions of dubious authenticity to parenthetical asides and to the endnotes in which he cites his sources after nearly every paragraph. We follow Alcibiades from his boyhood days, through his formal education and relationship with Socrates, and into his meteoric rise to prominence in Athens and the meat of his political career: the ill-fated Sicilian expedition, the treacherous defection to Sparta ended by a royal sex scandal, life with the Persian satraps, a short-lived but glorious return to Athens, and ignominious death by assassination in exile. And every step of the way, Stuttard strains to bring the scene to life before our eyes, mustering his extensive knowledge of ancient Greek and Persian custom, culture, dress, diet, geography, religion, and myth to put flesh on the historical skeleton he has painstakingly assembled from ancient literature. From Thucydides we learn what happened and when, but only in Stuttard can we indulgently imbibe the atmosphere in which it took place. We see and smell the dust rising from the thunderous approach of a hoplite phalanx and are dazzled by the glint of the afternoon sun off of their spearheads; we gaze upon the temples and statues of the Acropolis, silhouetted against the setting sun, as Alcibiades's peroration rises to its climax in the Pnyx; we watch lovers exchange furtive glances, and listen to the murmured counsels of scheming emissaries in the courts of kings. Stuttard never misses an opportunity to awe us with the thought of how it must have felt to be a witness to the monumental events of this tumultuous era.
To do this, of course, requires a good deal of conjecture on the author's part. We do not, in fact, have any idea whether Alcibiades choked back tears in his first address to the assembly upon his return to Athens, what tapestries adorned the walls of his houses, or what music the courtesans played when he courted the favor of Tissaphernes. But the eager reader is happy to shrug aside the many “perhapses,” and “surelys,” the “would haves,” “may well haves,” and “cannot but haves” for the sake of a gripping, well-told yarn.
Yet it must be said that the reader who knows of this enthralling story from the works of the ancient historians may find that Stuttard's florid retelling comes up surprisingly thin. In fact, the bones that Stuttard has gathered from the ancient histories, assembled, and sutured with his literary connective tissue, the people, dates, places, and events that populate Alcibiades's timeline, were not meant to be scavenged from those works in quite that way. In Thucydides, for example, the Peloponnesian War presents us with a microcosm in which to study the furthest-reaching permanent questions of politics, civilization, theology, science, and culture. The dichotomy of Athens and Sparta is framed and set in motion so as to unfold for us a great drama spanning fundamental human alternatives—tradition and innovation, piety and science, rest and motion—as they swerve toward and away from one another in their courses, guided by the complex forces of human nature. In this drama, Alcibiades is a peak manifestation of the Athenian spirit, a stark problematization of the puissant democracy's audacious imperialism and its culture of honing grand ambition. Thucydides's purpose is not so much to record faithfully the objective data of Alcibiades's deeds and speeches as it is to preserve the wisdom of his own understanding in his artful representation of events he saw as paradigmatic of the human condition. He wrote his history to be, in his own words, “a possession for all time.”
In disentangling and extracting the thread of Alcibiades's narrative from the greater works into which it had been woven—not only by Thucydides, but by Xenophon and even Plutarch, who themselves had philosophic and artistic priorities to rival historical precision or completeness—Stuttard at times gives the impression that he may be missing the bigger picture of those great works. Anecdotes are dislodged from their careful juxtapositions, and strange gaps and inconsistencies in one historian's account are plausibly filled in and explained away with the help of details included in another's. The literary and philosophic richness of the originals is inevitably diluted, to the likely disappointment of classics lovers who will squirm at overliteral readings of allegorical passages from not just the authors mentioned, but Plato, Aristophanes, and others.
Yet this too could well be forgiven. Not every book must plumb the depths of human nature, and at any rate the psychology of Alcibiades should make for a fascinating case study, ample food for thought to chew on as we are regaled with the salacious and incredible details, however accurate they may be, of his extraordinary life. In fact, Stuttard might have done well to take even more liberties in his retelling, to leave academic precision still further behind, to allow himself a freer hand in inventing speeches and scenes, so as to portray for us more fully what he has come to understand through his extensive studies of this endlessly captivating man. For the true difficulty with Nemesis is not precisely that the pedagogical richness of Thucydides and Xenophon is lost in translation, but rather that the final product falls between two stools. Having jettisoned the unifying themes and questions of the sources from which he culled his materials, Stuttard never seems to convey his own insight. He seems rather to count on the excitement of the story's twists and turns, and on his own always engaging prose, to carry the reader through. But in fact, the wild exploits and daring military tactics are not what is most interesting about Alcibiades. In him we have a lens through which to the examine the great longings of the human heart and the tensions inherent in political ambition. Stuttard seems in one place to sum Alcibiades up by saying, “everywhere he went at every stage of life, he needed constant stimulation” (295). But what did he want from it all? Was it the trappings of Persian luxury that most satisfied his most powerful desires, or the glory of triumph in the name of Athens? Was he utterly indifferent to the city he served, or did he have an abiding love of fatherland through all his treasonous double-crossing? Was he a moral man in the end, or was his wheeling and dealing the sign of a mind that had unmoored itself from all law, divine and human? Despite Stuttard's admirable rigor in adhering to the major details provided by ancient sources, and despite his manifestly comprehensive grasp of ancient culture and ability to bring it to life, Nemesis gives us merely the Hollywood version of Alcibiades: edge-of-your-seat fun, but in only two dimensions.
