Robert E. Sherwood, like so many other American playwrights from the late 1920s through the 1950s, seems to have dropped off the face of the scholarly landscape. An analysis of Sherwood's Reunion in Vienna by Attilio Favorini, published in the Journal of American Drama and Theatre in 2007, represents a rare recent effort to draw interest to one of the most consistently produced playwrights of his era. The fact that Sherwood's legacy has been taken up in Robert E. Sherwood: The Playwright in Peace and War by Harriet Hyman Alonso, who is a professor of history, not theatre, says something about Sherwood's position in the canon of American drama.
Although this book is a traditional biographical work, Alonso is primarily interested in how the contrary forces of peace and war played out in the playwright's life and work, an interpretation that unifies and focuses her study. She begins this exploration with a review of Sherwood's genealogy in the first of ten chapters. She notes the confluence of intrepid freedom fighting prevalent in Sherwood's lineage, not the least of which was the famous Irish patriot Robert Emmet, for whom Sherwood was named. In highlighting the successes and failures of Sherwood's notable progenitors, Alonso paints a picture of a man destined to find himself embroiled in world affairs. The playwright's pugnacious drive for a democratic society, so the author implies, was in his blood.
In her second chapter Alonso relates Sherwood's early theatrical proclivities, including anecdotal accounts of performances put on for his family as well as community productions he personally organized. Alonso effectively reveals the fun-loving side of the young Sherwood to counter his reputation as a shy and serious man, and elucidates the close family dynamic in which he was raised and that remained of utmost importance to him all of his life. In subsequent chapters Alonso zeroes in on her major theme with an examination of Sherwood's transformation from hawk to pacifist during World War I. Determined to join the war effort over the objections of his family, Sherwood endured injuries and unspeakable hardships that plagued him for the rest of his days and transformed him from militant to antiwar activist. Sherwood's traumatic war experiences would be most significantly manifested during the 1920s and 1930s in such plays as The Road to Rome and Waterloo Bridge.
Soon after World War I, Sherwood began his writing career as one of America's first film critics. Alonso points out that Sherwood's film reviews reflected his newfound pacifist stance, condemning films that glamorized war and praising those manifesting a more realistic view (at least in Sherwood's opinion). When he finally began writing plays in the late 1920s, he made it his mission to create dramas exposing the folly of warfare. Alonso's overview of Sherwood's early writing offers little critical evaluation, but her narrative proceeds coherently, in lively and vivid prose. Relying on evidence from Sherwood's diaries and letters, Alonso illuminates how the changing tide of world politics during the 1930s eventually led to Sherwood's renunciation of pacifism and his reversion to a warrior mentality. She provides concise synopses of his major plays from this period (Idiot's Delight, Abe Lincoln in Illinois, and There Shall Be No Night) while explaining how each fits into the transitions the playwright made both in his mind-set as well as in his writings. The attention Sherwood gained from the prowar There Shall Be No Night led to an offer to join President Franklin Roosevelt's staff, first as a speechwriter, then as the director of the Office of War Information. Sherwood abandoned playwriting to accept this offer, and became consumed with serving the war effort in a more direct way.
Alonso devotes Chapter 8 to Sherwood's nontheatrical activities during the war years, including an insightful overview of his personal relationship with Roosevelt. Theirs was largely a working relationship, and Sherwood took significant pride in his association with the president, channeling his gift for verbiage into speechwriting. Though he was never officially credited for the words Roosevelt spoke, Sherwood took delight in extending his personal thoughts about peace and war through the mouth of the chief executive of the United States. Alonso's final two chapters contend largely with the playwright's unsuccessful struggle to write a significant play during peacetime; none of Sherwood's post–World War II theatrical efforts (aside from the 1946 film The Best Years of Our Lives) came to much success, and the playwright died rather suddenly. The author conjectures that Sherwood's period away from the theatre during the war years, combined with his physical decline, significantly contributed to his artistic failures in the late 1940s and 1950s.
Prior to Alonso's study, those searching for book-length studies of Robert E. Sherwood's life have been confined to two main choices: Walter J. Meserve's slim and stolid biography published in 1970 or John Mason Brown's two-volume work The Worlds of Robert E. Sherwood: Mirror to His Times published in 1965 and The Ordeal of a Playwright: Robert E. Sherwood and the Problem of War published in 1970, though Brown's work concludes with the onset of World War II. Alonso's engagingly written study is a welcome and original addition to the field in that she provides a thorough single volume comprehensive biography of the playwright.
Her concentration on Sherwood's struggles with war and peace during one of the most volatile periods in history provides a glimpse of what life may have been like for many Americans struggling during the years of Depression and war, an aspect of the book that resonates today. Sherwood's story is relevant to anyone wishing a greater understanding of the sociopolitical impact of this period and how at least one significant theatre artist of the time responded.
