No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 29 March 2004
Economist, central banker, trade diplomat, university chief, arts administrator, environmentalist, and, finally, outspoken advocate for Australia's indigenous people: H. C. “Nugget” Coombs was one of the most influential Australians of the twentieth century. This important new biography of Coombs by Tim Rowse, the first since Coombs's somewhat elusive autobiography in 1981, is a meticulously researched examination of its subject and, by extension, key episodes in Australian economic and social history.
Coombs's rise to iconic status in Australia was as meritorious as it was meteoric. Documenting and accounting for it occupies the core of Rowse's narrative, which begins with Coombs's birth in 1906 in a small outback town in Western Australia. Rowse explains that the nickname “Nugget” (by which Coombs was universally known) was acquired in his youth and was an allusion to both his small stature and “solid” qualities. From a poor family, Coombs was a scholarship student at the University of Western Australia, and in 1931 he won a fellowship to complete a Ph.D. at the London School of Economics. Coombs arrived at the LSE at the beginning of the ascendancy of Lionel Robbins and Frederick Hayek. Neither of these made an impression upon him, however, and at the LSE he was rather more influenced by R. H. Tawny, Harold Laski, and through them, J. M. Keynes.
Coombs completed his Ph.D. (on central banking) in the rapid time of two years. Arriving home to an Australia still in the grip of the Depression, he found employment at the Commonwealth Bank (then the central bank). In 1939 he was seconded to Treasury and in 1942, at the age of 36, he became Australia's wartime Director of Rationing. For the next 30 years he was never outside the first rank of administrators and advisers. In late 1942 he was elevated again to head the new Department of Post-War Reconstruction and, in 1948, Coombs was appointed Governor of the Commonwealth Bank. Coombs remained governor of Australia's central bank until his “official” retirement in 1968.
Rowse uses the story of Coombs's life as a public official to explore the question he says occupied Coombs throughout his professional life, namely: “how to secure within the political elite an economic rationality that was socially integrative.” For Coombs the answer was Keynesianism. He opened his 1981 autobiography with the declaration that the publication of “Keynes's General Theory …, was for me and many of my generation the most seminal intellectual event of our time.” Of course, as a practical economist, Coombs was only to approximate the application of Keynesian ideals in his work. Nevertheless, a somewhat dogged pursuit of full employment informed most of his actions—both as Governor of the central bank and, more overtly, as Director of Post-War Reconstruction.
Coombs's retirement from the machinery of economic policymaking scarcely dented his public activities, and it is a strength of Rowse's biography that these are given their due weight in terms of both Coombs's life and his impact upon Australian society. From 1968, however, Coombs played the role of public intellectual rather than official. As such he served as Chancellor of the Australian National University, Chairman of the Australian Council for the Arts, and Chair of the Council for Aboriginal Affairs. The last of these marked the pinnacle of Coombs's role as an advocate for Australia's indigenous population, but his interest and work on indigenous issues continued until his death in 1997.
Rowse's biography of Coombs has not been well received by all, but the criticisms boil down to two main issues. Firstly, for some reviewers the biography is not sufficiently revealing of “Coombs the man.” Rowse himself acknowledges that the book is “more impersonal than most readers of biographies would wish”—a result, he says, of commitments made to secure Coombs's cooperation. In the opinion of this reviewer, the absence of the “tell all” approach does not detract from the contribution the book makes to important questions of Australian economic history. The second set of criticisms concern what some have regarded as an excessive veneration for Coombs. In Australia, as in most countries, economic policymaking is contested domain and Coombs's political savvy, and success in gaining the ears of generations of politicians, did not endear him to some bureaucratic rivals. One reviewer of the biography, a former Secretary to the Treasury (the great institutional rival to the central bank in Australia) even went so far as to label Coombs a “phoney.”
This is a serious book that is a welcome addition to the study of Australian economic and social history, and the role of key officials and advisers in the nation's political economy.