The essays collected in this volume were written for a workshop on “Marshall, Schumpeter, and Social Science" held at Hitotsubashi University in 2007, organized around two themes: evolution “loosely defined,” but generally taken to be an explanatory device for economic change through time, and “economic sociology,” also loosely defined as a broadening of the scope for legitimate analysis of economic activity. As might be expected of a collection of conference papers deliberately organized around loosely defined terms, the contributions are a variegated lot.
Shionoya and Nishizawa provide a useful introduction in which they make the points that Schumpeter sought a “reasoned” economic history—a story that was not just one thing after another, but a “conceptually clarified” account of the past—and that he thought that an economic sociology that was an analysis of institutions would make such analysis possible. Although Marshall was more concerned with ethical issues as he sought to move beyond static analysis, both men were influenced by and were reacting to the German Historical School, and both, the authors suggest, have more in common than often thought.
Part I consists of three essays by Yuichi Shionoya, Tiziano Raffaelli, and Roger Backhouse. Shionoya offers one of the best essays in the collection in his “ontological exploration” of Schumpeter's work. The essay is too rich to be summarized here but I do recommend it, especially for those “neo-Schumpeterians” who, as Shionoya tells us, base their views on an abridged translation of The Theory of Economic Development, which was published in 1934 without an important chapter that had been included in the original German version. Shionoya makes a good case that an awareness of the broader perspective taken by Schumpeter would either substantially change the nature of neo-Schumpeterian evolutionary thought or, perhaps, cause the practitioners to find another founding father. Raffaelli also provides an interesting article in which he explores Marshall's lack of comfort with a Darwinian theory based on chance variation. Marshall wanted and found a major role for purposeful design and human improvement—an evolutionary process the analysis of which would require something in addition to his own partial equilibrium analysis—but quite different from the general equilibrium approach that is often assumed as the logical extension of Marshallian thought. The essay by Backhouse complements Shionoya's and Raffaelli's essays nicely through a careful account of Schumpeter's views on Marshall—an account that adds depth to our understanding of the way in which both economists struggled to combine economic theory that tended always toward the static with an interest in historical change.
Part II offers three essays on “Social Science and Evolution.” The first two essays, one by Richard Arena, “On the Relation Between Economics and Sociology: Marshall and Schumpeter,” and the second by Geoffrey Hodgson on “Marshall, Schumpeter and the Shifting Boundaries of Economics and Sociology,” add detail in support of the arguments offered in the deeper essays of Part I. Both authors find Schumpeter and Marshall to have been less “economistic” in their approaches than their modern followers and both to advocate greater integration of economics and sociology. The third article by J. S. Metacalfe on “The Broken Thread: Marshall, Schumpeter and Hayek on the Evolution of Capitalism” departs from the theme, and stresses that in the work of Marshall and Schumpeter, change, which is equated with evolution, is an inevitable consequence of capitalism as they envisioned it; capitalism is a system “with instituted rules of conduct that promote economic mutation through the search for an application of new knowledge,” and it is knowledge that is the root cause of evolution (p. 117). Hayek then becomes a fellow-traveler by virtue of his insistence that economies are a product of specialized individual knowledge that is put to use to produce ever-changing systems. In this view, something very like Marshallian partial equilibrium analysis is an appropriate starting point (but only that) and in many ways this is the message of the entire volume: a start, but only a start, toward an evolutionary understanding of capitalist development was taken and remains to be developed.
Parts III and IV contain a varied set of essays, several of which offer interesting ideas for further development. For example, Richard Swedberg, in an essay on “Rebuilding Schumpeter's Theory of Entrepreneurship,” suggests ways in which a better understanding of Schumpeter's concept as well as a rethinking of some basic terms of social science—habit, tradition, and norm—might lead to better understanding of organizations in which “many chief executive officers know that constant change has to be on the agenda” if their corporations are to survive (p. 200).
On the basis of these essays, Thorstein Veblen would be correct in concluding that Economics is still not an evolutionary science, and skeptics would be equally correct in thinking that the overlap between Marshall and Schumpeter is not as great as the title of the volume might lead one to believe. Still, in all, these essays offer both some sensible ways of thinking about why the idea of evolution recurs in economic thought and some very tentative suggestions about ways in which sometimes ignored aspects of Schumpeter's and Marshall's work might be incorporated into a richer tradition of evolutionary analysis.
