This book looks at theatre and performance in Australia, Japan, Singapore, and Indonesia through the lens provided by Zygmunt Bauman's theory of liquid modernity. Each of the four authors is a specialist in the theatre and performance, cultures, and politics of one of the countries from which their case studies are drawn. Their individual voices are effectively woven together into a collective whole, analyzing key performances and playtexts with specificity and depth, while creating a fluid exploration of the way “new or alternative modernities emerge and become significant in the global era” (2). As such, Theatre and Performance in the Asia-Pacific not only brings diverse performances in the region to light; it makes tangible, illuminates, and activates our understanding of liquid modernity.
Theatre and Performance in the Asia-Pacific is structured into four parts. In Part I, “Changing Forms of Theatre and Drama,” the authors consider the histories and theatres of each country, looking particularly at the destabilizing effects of modernity on the making of plays in relation to communities. Part II takes “Mobile Performance and Fluid Identities” as its paradigm for exploring the fluctuations and contradictions between solid and liquid modernities in theatrical representations of places and peoples. Part III, “Beyond Regionality: The Asia-Pacific's Global Reach,” examines theatrical negotiations between the local and the global, looking at intercultural collaborations, adaptations, and transnational productions as evidence of the liquefaction of borders and identities. The final part, “Regional Flows,” locates liquid modernity in the “circulation of touring companies and the sharing of repertoire across the region” (14) as it argues both for a deeper engagement with the question of transnationalism and for a shift from Eurocentric theatre and performance research.
Each of Parts I–III is further divided into four chapters, each in turn using the topic to analyze case studies drawn from the countries in question. Analysis of text-based theatre work and playtexts tends to predominate, but attention is paid to ritual, puppet and street performance, performance art, and performance of everyday life as well. Each example represents a particular set of dramaturgical and theatrical strategies by which the local can be seen to align with and/or confront the global, and each is shown to be significant for its deployment of “alternative modernities” (2) as a way of engaging and challenging British, North American, and European hegemonies. On the surface, this structure would seem a rather rigid solution to the challenge of incorporating four distinctive academic perspectives and performance cultures with consistency and equity. But the effect is really that of a collective act of inquiry, in which each element is clearly presented and valued, united by a shared desire to investigate the ways in which the “increasing circulation of performance techniques and styles around a global performance industry and culture contribute to the greater fluidity of culture that [the authors] articulate through the metaphor of liquid modernity” (3). Together the authors argue that “Liquid modernity may offer increased mobility and access to communication, but its freedoms in the Asia-Pacific region are tempered by the legacy of heavy modernity, especially in the era of colonial conquest, imperial rule and neocolonialism” (7–8). In their view, the residue of the colonial runs through the contemporary exploitation of workers, who are made mobile in the service of capitalism without necessarily becoming emancipated as a result. Instead, these not-quite-postcolonial peoples experience transience and dislocation from their communities in ways that the theatre as “that most fluid of the arts” (8) might serve to reflect and perhaps even redress. By situating their analyses of specific theatrical events in carefully considered representations of the performances' social contexts, the authors demonstrate that modernity is an ambivalent force with which to be reckoned, theatrically as well as socially.
The book does have some odd quirks that should have been resolved at the editorial level, including a number of proofreading lapses: inconsistencies whereby a play's name, for example, somehow shifts midchapter, and the authorial “we” at points becomes an “I” then floats back to “we.” There are also occasional, distracting slippages between the present and past tenses in reference to characters and stage directions as read in playtexts versus actors and actions as seen in specific productions. These are relatively minor issues, indicative of current trends by presses toward minimizing editorial interventions, and thus the costs of production, more than of problems in the work itself.
Theatre and Performance in the Asia-Pacific makes a comprehensive contribution to our knowledge of the performance practices and cultures of Australia, Singapore, Indonesia, and Japan. Scholars and students alike will certainly see this book as a necessary resource for research in the region. But this book is even more important for the way it pushes against dominant discourses on both liquidity and modernity from perspectives that are informed by the West without being so westernized that significant differences are erased. In presenting the book as the outcome of a more extensive, ongoing conversation, the authors effectively invite readers to join them in considering how our own theatre and performance research—especially in related regions and social contexts—might be similarly engaged.
