In her book, Elizabeth Emma Ferry introduces us to an alternative world of resource extraction. Rather than portraying a case of mining giants dumping toxic chemicals, exploiting the labour of impoverished workers and facing local resistance, this book tells an untold story that exists alongside the extraction of ore. It uncovers the extraordinary world of minerals and semi-precious stones: their discovery, collection, classification and the allure surrounding their physical beauty. Most importantly, this book shows how mineral specimens come to have value in very intricate and complex ways, not just from the moment of extraction but also through other important settings such as museum exhibits, private collections, mineral shows and scientific research. Because the collection and circulation of minerals is a pursuit of curiosity, science and aesthetics, the story told here is a distinct exploration of mutual reliance, power, racism, inequality and national hegemony between Mexico and the United States over the past 150 years. This analysis of transnational space is not examined through the familiar lens of migration, politics and popular culture, but through that of minerals and the landscapes in which estimations of their unique value are continually assessed, vied for and monopolised. Value, as Ferry explores it, is the ‘creation of meaningful difference’ – comparing qualities with which to rank items – as well as ‘making difference meaningful’ – deciding which qualities are worth ranking – ongoing processes that are ‘contingent, unstable and very consequential’ (p. 25). Ultimately the process of value-making produces both prized objects but also certain kinds of people who are themselves ranked and valued in specific ways; including miners, dealers, collectors, rich, poor, men and woman on both sides of the border.
While this is an anthropological monograph based on multi-sited fieldwork in multiple locations in both Mexico and the United States, the book also utilises archival data in order to offer a detailed historical account of mineralogy and collecting. Ferry brings to life a number of key actors in the North American mineral world who have played a central role (or even what was eventually to become a peripheral role) in the realisation of mineral specimen value. All the cases focus on how value-making creates and relies on difference.
Imperialism, knowledge appropriation and unequal forms of power between Mexico and the United States are prominent themes running throughout the chapters. We see in chapter 2 that Mexico initially had greater knowledge and funding for mineralogy in the mid-nineteenth century, which later shifted as a result of larger political and economic factors including the imperialist expansion and advanced technologies of the United States, alongside political turmoil in Mexico. From this moment on, the field of mineralogy was dominated by the United States with Mexico taking the subaltern position. In the process, the roles of the miner and dealer (in Mexico) were minimised, and that of the collector (in the United States) was brought to prominence. In chapter 3, Ferry shows how these same inequalities and quasi-colonial practices were historically reflected in the production of scientific knowledge, and gives the example of a highly accomplished Mexican scientist (Aguílar) who discovered a new mineral (aguilarite), but whose role was eventually eclipsed by a relatively unknown US mineralogist who was merely assigned to sample a specimen. Ferry's examples demonstrate well how US scientists were presented as ‘as the intellectual protagonists in the production of value’ and Mexicans as ‘passive recipients or intermediaries’ (p. 95). Chapter 4 shows how relations between the two nations are lived out in mineral collections and the transnational space that they bring to bear. The negotiations through which individual pieces are deemed appropriate for inclusion in specific collections is played out through a struggle for constructed values of universality, patrimony and market exchange, a process which sheds light on a relationship ‘rooted in empire and based on the extraction of value and the erasure of Mexican authoritative action’ (p. 124). Chapter 5 goes on to emphasise conflicting viewpoints on value through economic spatial arrangements, with Mexican miners placing minerals within a social, moral and occult economy at the local level, while those same minerals become re-invented as pristine natural art when entering the economic terrain of the United States. This process erases any social transaction and human intervention involved in mineral extraction, so that ‘value is … only recognized – and thus realized – by those in the United States and Europe’ (p. 154). The final chapter on arbitrage – that is, the attempt to make a profit by taking advantage of price differences in different markets – demonstrates how social and cultural capital (masculinity, connoisseurship, middle-class habitus and fluency in English) are essential to succeeding in the mineral marketplace. These processes, like those that make the minerals themselves valuable, exploit differences between people, specifically between Mexican and US actors.
While the insights of transnational appropriation of knowledge and the production of value unveiled in this text are provocative and compelling, it seems to lack some depth on how monopoly on value is developed and maintained between the two nations. The reader may feel that more needs to be included on the backdrop of the wider political and economic context that has facilitated this discrepancy in the power to define what is valuable and what is not. Most notably, very little explicit discussion on the more recent neoliberal restructuring of the economy exists, which has arguably determined many of the imbalances in power analysed in the book: the infiltration of foreign mining companies, lack of jobs and surplus labour, an increasingly powerful transnational corporate class of actors, as well as the free markets, legal channels, technology and information systems that are both controlled by and that bolster wider US power.
The analytical frame of actor-network theory also falls short of giving the reader a real sense of the materials as actants and how they transcend an existence as categories constructed by certain powerful humans, as is emphasised throughout the book. One feels that ethnographic data on materiality and value might need to be further expounded in order to bring such approaches to light; these might include more voices on aesthetics and desire, on the social ties and offering to saints, the conflicts within groups (hegemonic or otherwise), and local understandings of the distinction between nature and culture. Doing so might have added to a more detailed description of ‘assemblages’ on the ground and an unpacking of received categories such as inequality (perhaps itself a ‘black box’). Nevertheless, this does not detract from the strength of this unique exploration of minerals and the accompanying power differentials manifest in their value-making.
