This symposium on provenance research and the restitution of Nazi-looted art was organized by the auction house Sotheby's and sponsored by the Muggenthaler International Genealogical Research Institute. After prior meetings hosted by Sotheby's on the same topic in London and Vienna, some 90 provenance researchers, art historians, government representatives, lawyers, and academics met in Amsterdam to discuss the Dutch restitution regime in particular and, in general, the progress made since the passing of the Washington Principles on Nazi-looted art in December 1998.
The morning session focused on achievements and the near future of restitution within the Netherlands. Notably, provenance researchers and lawyers from countries such as Israel, Germany, and Austria praised the work of the Dutch Restitution Committee and the achievements of the Origins Unknown provenance research project for their transparency and efforts, in particular in actively tracing potential claimants. Rudi Ekkart spoke about the two different regimes in researching Dutch collections: The work of the publicly funded Origins Unknown project—chaired by Ekkart—on the so-called NK collection, consisting of works of art recuperated after the war but never returned to their former owners—has essentially been finalized. According to Ekkart and confirmed by the audience, the research went to great lengths, so the chances of unveiling further groundbreaking material generating further claims are rather slim. As far as other museum collections that knowingly or unknowingly acquired looted objects during and after the Nazi regime are concerned, the Dutch Museum Association has decided to extend its earlier research on acquisitions during 1940 to 1948 to the year preceding the Dutch occupation and to acquisitions after 1948. The Dutch government has agreed to support this initiative with funding.
As for the Dutch Restitution Committee, which was established in 2001 to advise the government on claims for objects from the NK collection as well as the national collection, Inge van der Vlies, professor of constitutional law at the University of Amsterdam and member of the committee, reflected on one particular category within the 90 cases that have been filed with the committee (51 recommendations have already been issued, 16 in 2007 alone): the sale of artworks by dealers. Although the committee's guidelines contain a presumption of coercion for any sale of a persecuted person during the Nazi regime, this is not the case for objects from art dealers' trading stocks. With reference to two cases (Recommendation 1.37 concerning art objects from art dealership Mogrobi and RC 1.33 concerning a painting from art dealership Morpurgo), van der Vlies showed how the committee establishes whether a sale from an art dealer's stock must be considered involuntary and hence give rise to restitution.
The subsequent two speakers were Sarah Jackson, historic claims director of the Art Loss Register, and Amy Walsh, curator of European paintings and sculpture of the Los Angeles County Museum of Art; they discussed cases of artworks looted from the Netherlands that proved again the complexity of artwork routes and to what lengths provenance researcher (must) go to discover the “whereabouts and whenabouts” of looted objects. The discussion following their presentations addressed how provenance research could be facilitated in the future. Both speakers and experts in the audience emphasized the need for less stringent privacy laws for better access to archives, in particular of art dealers, as well as public archives. Also expressed was the wish for an even better exploitation of the Internet through finding aids that amass all existing sources, including online publications of sales and exhibition catalogs. In respect of privacy protection, provenance researcher Clemens Toussaint criticized the auction houses' stringent policies in not giving away buyer and seller names. Although loosening privacy rules regarding contemporary sales was rejected for fear of alienating clients, the suggestion of loosening rules regarding sales that occurred more than 50 years ago was not immediately dismissed. The last point of the discussion, which foreshadowed the presentation of the first speaker in the afternoon session, concerned the relevance of a sincere exchange of information between the parties in a dispute to reach settlements. Although there was general agreement by the audience on this point, it became clear that provenance researchers representing claimants on the one hand and museum curators on the other often feel that the other party is not entirely forthcoming, which is counterproductive to good-faith negotiations and doubles research efforts.
As first speaker of the afternoon session on the achievements made since the 1998 Washington Principles, Sophie Lillie, Vienna restitution researcher and author of Was Einmal War, commented that provenance research has been too interest based and is lacking a clear methodology and scholarly basis. Lillie argued for the need to professionalize provenance research and make it more objective by agreeing on a methodology with set standards. On top of that she criticized the Austrian Restitution Act from 1998 as too restrictive in its failure to apply to public collections that are lower than state level and foundations. Thus the act does not apply to the landmark case of Schiele's painting Portrait of Wally, which was loaned from the collection of the Leopold Museum to the Museum of Modern Art in 1997 and claimed by the Bondi-heirs.
Anna B. Rubin, director of the Holocaust Claims Processing Office, explained how her office, as governmental agency and part of the New York State Banking Department helps individual claimants recover works of art and other assets. In reaction to her presentation and against the background of American museums filing preemptive lawsuits to establish a claim to disputed artworks, an interesting discussion emerged as to why there were no political boards in the United States comparable to the Dutch Restitution Committee. Given the estimation that most looted art can be found in U.S. museums and given the long and costly legal battles in U.S. courts, the introduction of a political committee was considered a constructive but unrealistic solution to the problem. In particular, the private nature of collections would stand in the way of such an approach in the United States.
Gert-Jan van den Bergh, partner of Leidsegracht 3 Advocaten, was less sympathetic of one such political body and shared his frustrations over the Austrian Restitution Committee's recovery of a Munch painting for the Alma Mahler family. Although the painting was returned to the family in 2007, the process was flawed. In particular he criticized the denial of an active role in the process for Mahler's granddaughter, the unfair burden of proof on the claimant, and the all but balanced composition of the restitution committee. In addition to Lillie's point on the 1998 Austrian Restitution Act, van den Bergh pointed out that despite being private foundations, nevertheless many museums receive public funding. The last round of discussions addressed the legal basis of restitutions by governments. It was pointed out that although the Austrian regime, flawed as it may be, was based on federal law, no such basis exists for the returns by the Dutch government and that the democratic legitimacy of these returns might be missing.
The symposium was rounded off by the two moderators of the day, Richard Aronowitz-Mercer and Lucian Simmons, European and global directors, respectively, of Sotheby's restitution department. They reflected on their first encounter with the problem of Nazi looted art in 1997, when the Boston Globe ran a story on Sotheby's selling looted art, clearly establishing the need for the auction house to take measures to prevent further exposure. Although some further reflections on the roles and interests of auction houses regarding the restitution of Nazi-looted art over the last decade would have been interesting, as one of the first conferences commemorating the 10-year anniversary of the Washington Principles, the symposium succeeded in evaluating the last decade's achievements while setting out markers for the near future of restitution of Nazi-looted art.
