In From Resilience to Revolution, Sean L. Yom uses comparative historical analysis in order to understand the role of foreign interventions in Middle Eastern state-building. He examines three specific states: Kuwait, Iran, and Jordan to draw conclusions about geopolitical mediation in state-building exercises. Yom connects foreign intervention to the ways in which domestic leaders subsequently build coalitions amongst their own people. His main argument is that international hegemonic patrons shield domestic leaders from domestic opposition, and the unconditional support of these patrons discourages local rulers from mobilizing the mass support needed to ensure long-term stability. His thesis, revisited on page 209, states that “the depth of external penetration shaped the breadth of regime coalitions which in turn explains the durability of political order,” a conclusion that was supported and explored in the preceding chapters of his three-state case study. Yom believes Kuwait, Iran, and Jordan are comparable because they each possess historically matching initial conditions—early conflict, closed autocracy, late development, and major crises. In the face of social opposition and geopolitical mediation, however, each state followed a different track. Kuwait's seclusion and lack of total international intervention led to a state of regime compromise with its own population. Iran's shah accepted substantial U.S. assistance and aid, destroyed opposition movements, and denied grievances; these policies led ultimately to a national insurrection that overwhelmed the regime because the shah had substituted U.S support for old alliances internal to the country. Finally, the U.S. subsidized Jordan, which ultimately exacerbated questions of Palestinian and Jordanian identity and notions of citizenship. Jordan's resulting ethnocracy tenuously survives with constant communal tensions. Yom concludes that Kuwait's lack of sustained geopolitical mediation results in a more durable and stable regime, while Iran and Jordan's international intervention has made each state's domestic affairs precarious.
No CrossRef data available.
