Islamist Mobilization in Turkey studies the political mobilization of the Islamist movement in urban Turkey during the past decade. In order to explain the success of the movement in the 1990s, Jenny White explores its microdynamics. In so doing, however, unlike the dominant approaches in the study of Islam in Turkey that often privilege elite and party-level practices and discourses, White focuses instead on the everyday experiences of ordinary Islamist activists with special emphasis on their family and class background. She thus contextualizes political mobilization within a cultural framework and investigates the link between political discourse and the deep cultural and religious currents in people's daily lives.
White bases this very well-written book on an extended ethnographic study she conducted between 1995 and 1998 in Ümraniye, one of the poor yet developing neighborhoods of Istanbul. She primarily employs data from her interviews and experiences with ordinary women and men as well as various political figures from different social strata. The introductory chapter lays out the main thesis of the study and discusses the implications of “vernacular politics.” The following chapters focus on several aspects of Islam and politics in Turkey, such as the historical background of the current Turkish politicocultural landscape, the convergence in the lives of ordinary citizens of the Islamic discourse with civic appropriations of democracy, the fragmented nature of Islam as a movement, and the debates on the question of women's headscarves. In understanding the contemporary deployments of Islamism in Turkey, White perceptively highlights the significance of the connection between Islamism and the Ottoman past and neo-Ottoman trends. It is this emphasis on the historical process of change that enables White to perceive, for instance, in relation to the question of women's covering (tesettur) that it “is part of an internal national dialogue between people who choose to emphasize one aspect of Turkish history and culture over another. One is Ottoman-inspired, the other Western-inspired, but both are Republican discourses. It is an intensely national conversation” (p. 53).
White argues that the Islamist movement in Turkey can best be approached within a new conceptual framework, that she terms “vernacular politics.” It is the failure of conventional approaches to grasp the way Islamism garners support simultaneously at the levels of local culture, civil society, and political party organizations that leads her to generate this framework. White argues that vernacular politics captures the discrete and even contradictory forms of organization and bases of solidarity that exist in the Islamist movement in Turkey today; this framework also illuminates the dynamics behind the puzzling practical gap between the relatively short life spans of Islamist political parties and the durability of their social movement bases. As White notes, “vernacular politics was a political process that linked the Islamist social movement with the Welfare Party in such a way that activists ultimately were independent of the party, although party and movement reinforced and strengthened one another” (p. 122).
As White formulates her argument on the nature of Islamist mobilization through the lens of vernacular politics, she notes that this mobilization “may not really be about religion, despite the high decibel rhetoric. Instead, Islamist mobilization may be part of a process of indigenous modernization that reshapes culturally distinct lifestyles and ideals, institutionalizing and commercializing them and linking their everyday practice to new forms of public life and political practice. Rather than a homogenous religious movement, Islamist mobilization can be a political process that brings together new coalitions of people with varied and often highly practical goals” (p. 271). Hence, according to White, it is the struggle with modernization that leads ordinary people to employ Islam as their conceptual tool; the ensuing Islamist movement is not, however, uniform in that, in spite of the projected unity of the ideological rhetoric, it incorporates many elements with different motivations and positions.
It should be noted that White's formulation of vernacular politics appears to be not much different from the Gramscian theory of hegemony and civil society. The book would have benefited from the articulation of this theoretical lineage, especially because White makes some allusions to the Marxian approaches to culture (for instance, in chap. 1, which is entitled “The Political Economy of Culture”) and rightfully highlights the significance in her analysis of social class. It is specifically White's emphasis on class that enables her to criticize the neglect in current scholarship of the differentiation between the roles and locations of educational and economic elites. She is also able to capture how the Islamist movement in Turkey has appropriated the discourse of the left to its own advantage. Furthermore, White manages to identify how the politics of Islamism is not a simple “politics of the poor,” but rather a vernacular politics that incorporates both the elites and the masses at different levels of autonomy.
While examining the vernacular politics of the Islamist movement in Ümraniye from the standpoint of the activists, White also compares the modus operandi of the Islamist activists to that of the Kemalists. The former emerge successful in achieving personalization (face to face contact) and popularization (embedding ideas within local norms and values) whereas the latter fail to situate their message in local cultural values and norms. This comparison is immensely useful in that it reveals how and why the Kemalists who initially attempted to lead the modernization of the populace eventually lost steam. Extending this Kemalist–Islamist comparison to the rest of the book would have greatly increased its analytical significance. Hopefully the author will further develop this comparative approach in her future work.
It should be noted that the book contains a few conceptual errors. In her overview of the Islamic movements and groups in Turkey, White mentions among current Islamic movements the Ticani along with the Nurcu. Yet, the Ticani presence in Turkey was always limited in scope and did not survive after the 1950s, whereas the Nurcu movement was and still is the most powerful civic movement in Turkey. One can also take issue with White's categorization of the Süleymancı and Nakşibendi groups as “fundamentalist” because, given their alliances with center-right political parties, these Islamist groups are generally characterized in the literature as “conservative and nationalist.”
There are several minor spelling errors as well. For instance, “Cahit Zaferoǧlu,” “Davit Dursun,” and “Fethullaçılar” that are mentioned in the text should be, respectively, “C. Zarifoǧlu,” “Davut Dursun” and “Fethullahçılar.” The author also refers to the Turkey Volunteer Organizations Foundation and the Journalists and Writers Foundation as examples of “Nurcu Fethullahçı” organizations. It should be noted, however, that the former is not a Fethullahçı organization but a platform for various Islamic and conservative nongovermental organizations.
In summary, this ethnographically rich work presents a powerful and meticulous examination of the Islamist “vernacular politics” in the 1990s that is able to provide a plausible explanation for the success of the Welfare Party. It approaches the complexities of the Islamic politicocultural currents in contemporary Turkey from the perspective of modernization and social class to argue that the Islamist success in Turkey was a consequence of the particular cultural strategy the ordinary people from different classes in Turkey employed in their struggles with modernization. Hence, in all, even though theoretical elements of the book could have been further articulated, it still makes a major contribution to the study of politics and Islam in contemporary Turkey.
