Kathleen Crowther's fascinating work is the fruit of nearly twenty years of interest in portrayals of Adam and Eve in the context of the Protestant – or, more specifically, the Lutheran – Reformation. In it she explores the way that (mostly) Lutheran writers drew on and developed understandings of Adam and Eve to present and undergird the changes in culture and the balance of gender relationships which came about as a result of the shifts in teaching and practice in the course of the Reformation. Crowther is particularly interested in exploring how discourses about marriage, gender relations, childbirth, anatomy, natural philosophy and the correct political order drew on texts based on, and images drawn from, the Creation narrative.
Crowther's study opens with a discussion of two medieval accounts of the Creation story, a poem by the Austrian Lutwin (c.1300), one of a series of Adam legends, and the anonymous Mirror of the Human Soul (variously dated by Crowther to c.1400 and the late thirteenth/early fourteenth century), which go far beyond the biblical account in depicting not only the events that led to the Fall but also Adam and Eve's subsequent lives. Crowther demonstrates that these accounts offer a very particular view of human nature, of the situation of human beings after the Fall, of the relationship between men and women and of proper piety; this view is rather different from that presented in Lutheran retellings of the same story, whether in academic lectures, popular writing or plays.
In her second chapter, Crowther explores the ways in which early modern understandings of the body and of the relationship between body and soul were mediated through accounts of the Creation and Fall. This included a strong emphasis on the corruption and decay which were part of fallen human existence, and shifts in understanding of what it meant to have a good death. Somewhat less convincing, given Philip Melanchthon's fascination with God as geometer, is Crowther's suggestion of a shift from an understanding of God as an architect or designer to God as a craftsman ‘shaping raw material into the perfect form of the human body’ (p. 98). Both images of God – as geometer or architect and as craftsman – surely existed side by side throughout this period.
In the section of the book that will probably be of most interest to historians of science, Crowther in her third chapter explores how Lutheran writers used depictions of the relationship between Adam and Eve, and more specifically of Eve, to present their views on marriage, sexuality and proper gender relations. Eve became on the one hand a pious wife and mother, a model for good Lutheran women, whilst on the other remaining in some accounts ‘wicked, sensual and seductive’ in ways which illustrated not only the position of women, but also the state of all people after the Fall (p. 136). Crowther then moves to a discussion of ‘gender and generation’, which looks at understandings of procreation and childbirth, considering the language used to describe the unborn child (often called the ‘fruit’) and presenting anatomical discussions of the male and female bodies which run counter to the suggestion of Schiebinger, Laqueur and others that the male was always normative. Strikingly, much of this discussion is based on the Anatomy and New Albert Magnus of Walther Hermann Ryff, whom Crowther describes as a ‘Catholic apothecary’; the focus on his work seems a little odd in a study of Lutheran attitudes, although Ryff was a native of Strasbourg (born c.1500), studied at Basel (p. 197) and published most of his works in Frankfurt-am-Main and must presumably have had some Protestant links. Crowther admits that these positive views of the reproductive capacity of the female body were neither specifically Lutheran nor ‘the’ Lutheran view. The belief that women were able to share in the sufferings of Christ through pain and danger of death in childbirth, expounded by Luther, was probably more characteristically Lutheran.
Crowther moves on to a consideration of the ‘book of nature’, and in particular the multifaceted vernacular literature on the natural world. She observes that in seeing the natural world as ‘suffused with natural power’, Lutherans shared a view of nature with Catholics; however, some Lutherans read the book of nature as ‘a Protestant book … affirming their own doctrines and disproving those of Catholics’ (p. 193). It would have been interesting here to explore whether this is in fact a Lutheran perception, or whether Calvinists and other Reformed also took this view, as the growth of natural philosophy in England would suggest.
A final chapter considers the use of the Adam and Eve legends in presenting Lutheran understandings of proper catechetical education – together with the responsibilities of parents, and particularly mothers, in the education of children – and the relationship between church and state.
Crowther's final chapter in many ways offers the best claim to a specifically Lutheran interpretation of Adam and Eve. Whether she has identified a specifically Lutheran culture in questions of anatomy, gender relations and understandings of the natural world is a question which could not be answered without recourse to similar bodies of Catholic, Calvinist and other Reformed writings. Nonetheless, Crowther presents some fascinating insights into the way in which theological ideas interacted with and shaped popular understandings of the human person and the natural world.
