No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
Itamar Levin, an Israeli journalist who has devoted past efforts to reporting on the lost assets of Holocaust victims, focuses his energy in this book on the fate of property left behind in the Arab world by emigrating Mizrahi Jews (Jews from North Africa, the Middle East, and Central Asia). The result, a detailed and at times impassioned examination based on archival documents, clearly is designed as a primer for those who Levin hopes will raise compensation claims for Mizrahi property in future Arab–Israeli peace negotiations—most notably, the Israeli government.
From the beginning, Levin admits this agenda: “[t]he timing of this book [completed in April 2001] is no accident.…This book presents decision makers and public opinion shapers with information on Israel's counterdemands [to Palestinian claims for compensation for abandoned refugee property], as regards property belonging to Jews from the Arab states” (p. xv). Indeed, his research and publication were supported by some of these same “decision makers” who promoted the cause of Israeli counter-claims in the past. The book under review is a translation of Levin's original Hebrew-language work, Sheki‘ah be-Mizrah: Hisul ha-Kehilot ha-Yehudiyot be-Medinot ‘Arav ve Shod Rekhushan (Sunset in the East: The Liquidation of the Jewish Communities in Arab States and the Robbery of their Property), which was published by two such interested parties, the Israeli Ministry of Defense and the Jewish Agency for Israel. In 2000, Levin wrote a shorter work for the World Jewish Congress, long a champion of Israeli counter-claims for lost Jewish property, titled Confiscated Wealth: The Fate of Jewish Property in Arab Lands.
The author delves deeply into valuable archival material, much of it never before published. His research took him to the Public Records Office in Britain as well as to four archives in Israel: the Central Zionist Archives, the Israeli State Archives, the Haganah Archives, and the American Joint Distribution Committee Archive. Levin also consulted secondary sources, many of them in Hebrew. His research focuses on the loss of Jewish property in four Arab countries: Iraq, Egypt, Syria, and Lebanon. The choice of these four also serves the author's diplomatic goal, for these four contained the wealthiest Jewish communities in the Arab world, where future Israeli compensation claims would be the highest. They also represent, in his opinion, the cases where future negotiations might actually result in compensation.
The result is the only English-language book to date on this under-studied topic. It contains many valuable details on the seizure of Jewish property, the attitudes of the various Arab states, anti–Jewish sentiment in the Arab world, as well as how the Israeli government and Jewish nongovernmental organizations have championed, or demurred from championing, the cause of Mizrahi compensation. In the latter case, Levin waxes critical of Israel's reticence to press the issue on certain occasions despite its stated policy of linking the Mizrahi property question with any future compensation it pays for Palestinian refugee property.
There are several problems with this book, however. One deals with Levin's polemics. For example, he states in his Introduction that the “Arab countries stole Jewish property, cruelly, illegally, and unjustifiably. I do not pretend to be objective on this issue” (p. xvi). Fair enough, but Levin's emotions sometimes get in the way, such as when he compares Syrian and other Arab states’ treatment of their Jewish citizens to the policies of the Nazis. The Syrian record is indeed shameful, but comparisons to the Nazis are so overused in the Arab–Israeli arena that they only work against the book's credibility. Such moral indignation can also become a double-edged sword. Levin ignores the fact that Israel has sometimes carried out the same actions as the Arab states he demonizes, including confiscating the property of refugees and minority groups and listing religious identity in passports and identification cards. He also eschews any discussion of Israel's seizure of Palestinian refugee property, as he concedes in his Introduction. A truly in-depth study of the Mizrahi property question—particularly a study that openly seeks to serve diplomats and policy-makers—cannot avoid discussing this intertwined topic at least to some extent. One also notes that much of the book deals with the persecution of Jews in Arab countries generally and less with the specific question of property seizures that constitutes the book's putative subject.
The book also suffers from some errors and omissions. Levin does not always cite his sources. Despite his admirable archival research, the author sometimes relies on flawed secondary sources when discussing topics of major importance and is thereby led astray (see his inaccurate discussion of the activities of the United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine on p. 227). His translator has transliterated certain proper names quite poorly, such as “Ghamal Abd al-Nasser” (p. 101) and “Husni Mubaraq” (p. 150). At times, Levin is simply incorrect, such as when he asserts (on p. xvi) that, in contrast to the four countries he discusses, North African Jewry was able to emigrate with its property. Libya certainly sequestered Jewish property, especially in the wake of laws in 1961 and 1970. Finally, it is a pity that Levin did not write about the lost assets of other Mizrahi Jews, especially the under-studied case of Yemenite Jewish property.
Despite its flaws, Levin's book is essential reading for those interested in Mizrahi property confiscation. When read critically and in conjunction with sound work on the topic by scholars such as Yehouda Shenhav, Locked Doors can provide invaluable information about the unfortunate plight of Mizrahi Jewry.