Daniel Sack's After Live opens with Donald Rumsfeld's 2002 pronouncement regarding “known knowns,” “known unknowns,” and “unknown unknowns,” an apt starting point for Sack's exploration of the future of performance (1–2; emphasis in original). It is through the “known unknowns” and “unknown unknowns” that Sack frames his central argument regarding the possibility and potentiality of performance. In his introductory chapter, “The Futures of Performance,” Sack offers these two concepts as the theoretical framework for his exploration of performance at the beginning of the twenty-first century. Possibility, which is the focus of the book's second chapter, “projects into the future an event or entity that resembles an already known actuality, a future designated by the terms and conventions of the past and used in the present” (6). Potentiality, on which Sack focuses in Chapters 3–5, “refers to a withheld realization, a possession of the capacity to do or develop” (9). Throughout After Live, Sack investigates what the potential of performance can be and how performance can move beyond the known terms and conventions of the past to become the “unknown unknown” of the future of performance.
As Sack notes in his introduction, After Live theorizes possibility and potentiality through the lenses of Western stage performance, dance, sculpture, literature, and performance art, among other cases. Chapter 2, “Dramatic Possibility,” emphasizes the role temporality plays within the entire project, detailing how possibility in performance is defined by the practices and histories that have preceded it. The chapter details how possibility operates in performances of pieces such as Caryl Churchill's Heart's Desire and Will Eno's Tragedy: a tragedy, as well as in the writings of Konstantin Stanislavsky and Alice Rayner, among others. “Dramatic Possibility” establishes how performance is often shaped by the constraints of the dramatic form, and the chapter works in tandem with the introduction to set up the rest of the book by presenting examples of possibility in performance in both theory and praxis. In Chapter 3, “Withholding Potentiality,” Sack shifts his focus to potentiality in performance, considering how characters and performers can exhibit potentiality. He first turns to Melville's character of Bartleby the Scrivener as an exemplar. The chapter addresses both the literary tradition around Melville's character and Didier Théron's 2006 dance adaptation Bartleby to show how language (Bartleby's “I would prefer not to”) and stillness function as representations of potentiality. In the last part of the chapter, Sack analyzes examples of potentiality as represented by arrested language, often in the form of stutters or gags, in Douglas Gordon's 10ms-1, Samuel Beckett's Waiting for Godot, Faith Wilding's Waiting, and Witold Gombrowicz's Princess Ivona.
After discussing how potentiality is presented onstage, Sack in Chapter 4, “Beholding Potentiality,” turns his attention to the role of the audience. Throughout the chapter, Sack works through the experience of the audience when confronted by potentiality in performance. At first returning to Bartleby, the chapter engages with the concepts of antitheatricality and literalism through Michael Fried's essay “Art and Objecthood” and Stanley Cavell's “The Avoidance of Love: A Reading of King Lear.” As the beholders confronting potentiality, “We are put onstage, not the object, and it is our experience of living in a present in which, in Fried's words, ‘the situation itself belongs to the beholder’—to the potential—that constitutes the uncomfortable (non)revelation of the literalist object” (127; emphasis in original). The final main chapter of the book, “Actualizing Potentiality,” theorizes how the beholder and the event can come together to realize potentiality through what Sack calls “apocalyptic potentiality” (134; emphasis in original). Starting the chapter with a brief discussion of Edward Gordon Craig's Scene, the majority of the chapter investigates the work of the Italian experimental theatre company Socìetas Raffaello Sanzio (SRS) and its director, Romeo Castellucci. Sack uses particular SRS performances, such as Crescita XII Avignone, the Tragedia Endogonidia, Purgatorio, and The Four Seasons Restaurant, to theorize how these experimental performances actualize “the sensible body of the spectator as a chaos of difference in motion” (143).
Sack concludes the book with a short chapter that evokes Bartleby one last time with its title, “Preferring Not to End.” Emulating the performances he has analyzed in the preceding chapters, Sack imbues the closing chapter with the potentiality he has discussed throughout the book. The final chapter moves briefly through discussions of the Theatre of the Emerging American Moment's musical Mission Drift and Franz Kafka's Amerika: The Missing Person before concluding with Francis Alÿs's video documentary Tornado, a suitable representation of potentiality for ending the book. In Tornado, Alÿs chases small tornadoes and attempts to enter their center; but even when he is successful, the experience in the center is still unknown to us, obscured by dust and noise, ever elusive. Much like Alÿs chasing tornadoes, Sack ends with his attention on the future and the unknown—he creates another beginning, challenging himself and the reader to continue exploring the potentiality of performance by starting “again, the same but differently” (200). Over the course of its individual chapters, After Live presents a strong theoretical framework for thinking about performance as we continue to move further into the twenty-first century, one worthy of consideration for those interested in performance studies and theory, for those interrogating issues of liveness or the ontology of performance, and for those who can build on Sack's framework and continue to seek out the “unknown unknowns” of performance's future potentialities.
