Mentions of the US territories tend to be few and far between in undergraduate-level classes (and textbooks) Footnote 1 on foreign policy. Yet, the history and politics of territorial acquisition can be a valuable lens for viewing important issues in US foreign relations, including the reality of who and what determines US actions abroad; the question of how the United States became a great power and later a superpower in world affairs; Footnote 2 questions of morality in international relations; and contemporary topics such as defense and environmental policies. Most importantly, however, America’s experience of acquiring and governing nonsovereign territories can enhance students’ understanding by focusing on the interrelated roles that race, racism, and imperial ambition played (and continue to play) in driving US foreign policy. This equips students with new analytic tools with which to make sense of historical and contemporary events. In particular, I argue that race and empire Footnote 3 are essential to the US experience in two main respects: (1) because racial prejudice has shaped which territories the United States has targeted for annexation, when, and why; and (2) because race has been a sorting mechanism by which US leaders have decided which territories to admit into the union and which to treat as imperial possessions. The pattern has been for white territories to be made states of the union more quickly and easily than territories with nonwhite populations, which tend to be kept as dependencies of the federal government with far-reaching implications.
THE ANALYTIC COSTS OF IGNORING RACE AND EMPIRE
A core purpose of any course on foreign policy is to ascertain what makes nations act as they do on the world stage. Typically, students are introduced to basic International Relations (IR) theories—especially realism, liberalism, constructivism, Footnote 4 and domestic politics Footnote 5 —each of which offers a distinctive perspective on what causes foreign policy. However, none of these major theoretical approaches foregrounds race and imperial ambition in its explanation of what causes foreign policy. Either the United States is modeled as a featureless and amoral “billiard ball” (or “black box”) as in the realist tradition, or there is a tendency to focus on other aspects of US domestic politics to the exclusion of race, racism, and imperial thinking. Footnote 6
There are compelling reasons for why teachers should strive to not ignore issues of race and empire in US foreign policy. First, drawing on postcolonial IR theory, it is morally wrong for political scientists to erase histories of racism and imperialism because doing so marginalizes the experiences of the downtrodden (the “subaltern”), inexcusably whitewashing some of the most shameful episodes in US and world history. Footnote 7 Second, it is simply factually incorrect to ignore race and empire as features of US foreign relations, given the prominent role of racial prejudice and imperial thinking in the nation’s history. Footnote 8 Whether for normative reasons or simply out of a desire for basic descriptive accuracy, then, race and empire deserve a place on undergraduate syllabi. For teachers of US foreign policy, there is no better way to address this racial–imperial blind spot than with an investigation of the territories.
ENTER THE TERRITORIES
The decision to annex territory is one of the most significant foreign-policy decisions that a country can make—even weightier, perhaps, than decisions of war and peace, given that territorial annexations alter the very makeup of the national polity. For this reason, moments of decision about territorial expansion are particularly well suited for shedding light on the twin questions of who makes foreign policy and why. More than any other issue, annexation should expose national cleavages over the purpose of foreign policy. In the American experience, the history of territorial acquisition shows that ideas of race, racism, and imperialism have been of demonstrable salience since the earliest days of the republic—especially when annexing populated territories or territories intended for settlement. Footnote 9
Indeed, some historians date the origins of the American Revolution itself to 1763, the year that King George III issued a Royal Proclamation to prohibit settlement of much of the area west of the Appalachian Mountains (i.e., the region that later became known as the Northwest Territory). The king’s edict angered many white settlers, who viewed territorial acquisition as a natural right and an economic necessity (Schmidt Reference Schmidt2014, 24; Slaughter Reference Slaughter2014, 198, 311). These settlers and their supporters formed a powerful faction in the Atlantic colonies; the interest in westward expansion ran deep and, in time, influenced colonists toward supporting independence from Britain. Thus, the United States was founded with a foreign policy of territorial enlargement hardwired into its government and politics, the new nation’s leaders and much of its citizenry intent on displacing and dispossessing the Native American tribes whose protection under the Royal Proclamation of 1763 so many colonists had found intolerable. From its earliest beginnings, the federal government planned to sell Native lands to pay off debts from the Revolutionary War, albeit ultimately with mixed success (Cayton Reference Cayton1986, 2). Footnote 10
In the American experience, the history of territorial acquisition shows that ideas of race, racism, and imperialism have been of demonstrable salience since the earliest days of the republic—at least when annexing populated territories or territories intended for settlement.
After Independence, the question of territorial expansion frequently divided political opinion in the United States. In particular, debates about expansion were intimately entwined with domestic race relations—especially the issue of slavery. Footnote 11 At first, Southern slavers believed that exporting slavery across the continent—and expanding the United States into Caribbean islands where slavery already existed—would fortify slavery’s place in the US political system. Southern enthusiasm for enlargement helps to explain (among other foreign policies) the Mexican–American War (1846–1848), Gadsden Purchase (1853), Northern queasiness about the annexation of Texas, and intrigues within the United States to acquire Cuba.
Once slavery had been abolished by the Thirteenth Amendment, however, the Southern interest in territorial acquisition mostly evaporated. Instead, representatives of the South in the postbellum era became frequent opponents of US expansionism. Not least of all, Southerners feared that the incorporation of nonwhite territories would jeopardize white supremacy in the United States if those territories ever became states. Why in 1870 did the US Senate reject a treaty negotiated by President Grant to annex Santa Domingo (now the Dominican Republic)? Why was Cuba not annexed after the War of 1898, despite a long history of US interest in the island? Why did Hawaii have to wait from 1898 until 1959 to become a state? The answers—although partly related to economic considerations, geopolitics, and international diplomacy—unquestionably demand attention to sectional conflict within the United States and especially racist attitudes toward nonwhite populations (Fuchs Reference Fuchs1990, 234; Horsman Reference Horsman1981; Kagan Reference Kagan2006, 276–9; Trubowitz Reference Trubowitz1998, 73–4). Teaching this history of US territorial expansion (and nonexpansion) is therefore a powerful way to introduce students to the conceptual possibility and the empirical reality of racism and empire being prominent drivers of landmark US foreign policies—indeed, the very policies that propelled the nation to great-power status (Kagan Reference Kagan2006; Sparrow Reference Sparrow2006), and which are difficult to explain if classroom instruction is reliant on mainstream approaches to the study of foreign policy.
IN THE CLASSROOM
These insights that ideas of race and empire historically shaped US foreign relations can be expanded upon to reframe several topics of contemporary relevance. Consider, for example, the traditional debate over “might and right” in world politics. Often, foreign-policy syllabi pitch the question of morality in foreign policy as a disagreement between liberals (i.e., moralists driven by a desire to do what is right) and realists (i.e., pragmatists driven to do what is expedient). However, this stylized juxtaposition of liberals and realists is insufficient for understanding US territorial expansion, an issue of enormous moral importance. That is, the United States has not always expanded when it has been powerful and poised to do so, as realism would predict (Zakaria Reference Zakaria1998), whereas so-called liberal ideas have been instrumental in influencing the United States to acquire new territories and deny them self-rule (Kagan Reference Kagan2006, 71–103). If US expansionism is part of the country’s liberal heritage, does this mean that territorial aggrandizement is good or that liberalism has a dark side? Is it right that US leaders have treated nonwhite people so differently than white populations? How might these legacies affect contemporary US government, politics, and foreign policy? The truth is that students will have difficulty even beginning to answer these questions without prior introduction to an analytic lens that acknowledges the reality of US foreign policy sometimes being a function of racial prejudice and imperial attitudes—and that this is actually quite normal behavior (even if unsavory, uncomfortable, and regrettable) in the context of international relations.
Consider, also, one of the most pressing international challenges currently facing the United States: the rise of China and the future of East Asian security. It is conventional wisdom that the United States and China have conflicting interests in East Asia and that their evolving bilateral relationship will be central to future international security. Partly, this is because the United States has made security commitments to several East Asian nations. However, the United States is only a bona fide “Pacific power” because of its maritime territorial acquisitions, especially Alaska, Hawaii, the Philippines (which few students realize was a US territory from 1898 until 1946), Guam, American Samoa, the Northern Mariana Islands, and a host of unpopulated minor islands and atolls in the Central Pacific. Historically, US leaders sought these territories as an outgrowth of mercantilist trade policies and to facilitate “blue-water” naval operations (Harris Reference Harris2014, 378–84). Today, however, America’s Pacific territories—especially Guam, which houses thousands of US troops and is a key air base—are integral to the US military presence in Asia, without which the United States would be wholly reliant on its allies for the provision of military bases and support facilities. Footnote 12
However, the United States is only a bona fide “Pacific power” because of its maritime territorial acquisitions, especially Alaska, Hawaii, the Philippines (which few students realize was a US territory from 1898 until 1946), Guam, American Samoa, the Northern Mariana Islands, and a host of unpopulated minor islands and atolls in the Central Pacific.
Beyond defense policy, the territories are intimately connected to contemporary US efforts at marine conservation, which, in turn, are part of the US government’s high-profile efforts to combat climate change. In recent decades, the Executive Branch designated several large marine-protected areas (also known as Marine National Monuments [MNMs]) in US–controlled portions of the Pacific, all of which envelop US territories: the Papahānaumokuākea MNM surrounds the Northwestern Hawaiian Islands and Midway Atoll (an unorganized, unincorporated US territory); the Rose Atoll MNM includes American Samoa; the Pacific Remote Islands MNM encompasses a collection of unorganized, unincorporated US territories including Wake Island and the Johnston Atoll; and the Marianas Trench MNM includes the Northern Marianas Islands. In addition, the federal government has turned several of its island territories into National Wildlife Refuges (NWRs). All of Wake Island is covered by an NWR, for example, as well as 23,000 acres of Guam. The Guam NWR is particularly controversial because 95% of it is controlled by the US Department of Defense (DOD) and is off-limits to tourism. Only the remaining 5% was transferred to the US Department of the Interior in 1993 and thereby opened to tourists, albeit with strenuous local objections that the land should have been placed under the jurisdiction of Guamanian authorities instead of passed from one federal department to another. Footnote 13
Thus, the US island territories are essential to both US hard power (i.e., military power-projection) in the Asia–Pacific and its soft power (i.e., as a custodian of the marine environment). They are versatile political units, capable of being transformed from logistical hub to military stronghold to environmental safe haven. This flexibility of purpose stems from the historical process by which the territories were distinguished from other annexations and judged unsuitable for statehood. As nonsovereign dependencies of the United States, the territories continue to be outposts of empire. The federal government’s almost total jurisdiction over them—whether because of federal ownership of land within the territory in question (e.g., the DOD owns approximately 40% of Guam) or simply via direct rule (as in the case of Wake Island and the Johnston Atoll)—means that US decision makers have enormous leeway to deploy the territories in service of national goals. The territories and their inhabitants, therefore, are objects of US foreign policy rather than participants in the setting of that policy.
CONCLUSION
A thorough examination of the territories—and especially the racial and imperial aspects of their incorporation into US politics—is an effective way to impress on undergraduate students that the United States is not an exceptional nation but rather thoroughly normal in the sense that its historical development and even its contemporary foreign relations are nested inside a world history of imperialism. The empirical reality is that the United States has spent its entire history governing nonsovereign spaces. It is a country that, like others, has made important foreign-policy decisions on the basis of racial attitudes and prejudices—and likely continues to do so in myriad ways that mainstream IR theories do not account for. Why teach the territories? Because doing so can serve as a window into this difficult set of historical facts and contemporary analytic puzzles. Moreover, because of the centrality of territorial expansion to the story of America as a global power, it is a window that can be seamlessly blended into a syllabus on US foreign relations. Indeed, a truly comprehensive account of US power-projection abroad should find the territories a difficult subject to ignore.
