Dennis Merrill has written an informative account of the United States' relationships within its ‘hemisphere of influence’, Latin America, in which he inserts into the historical record of its ‘hard power’ – gunboat diplomacy, empire building and hegemonic penetrations – the role(s) and ‘reach’ of tourism's ‘soft power’ in the form of successive waves of tourists and their ‘facilitators’ – that is, hoteliers, travel agencies and such. This focus on the unusual marriage of these very different influential ‘penetrations’ of ‘Americans’ in their southern-hemisphere extension of Latin America is not only refreshing but illuminating. Undertaking both a cultural and historical examination of international tourism and international relations, Merrill's contribution to Latin American scholarship is his enthusiastic and unabashed promotion of mass tourism as ‘soft power’ to address ‘challenging issues in the history of U.S. foreign relations, [and] to bridge the chasm that typically separates scholars of culture from those who study empire and international relations, and to stimulate debate on both fields’. In his own words, he ‘does so by examining international relations from the bottom up and at times from the outside in, frequently emphasising the agency of the “other” within the U.S.-led empire’. Equally informative and engaging, Merrill liberally sprinkles his stories with anecdotal vignettes of everyday-life encounters and tensions between tourists and hosts, and balances these bottom-up negotiations with accounts of presidents, hotel moguls and political figures and their influential engagements, national agendas and tourist ‘presences’. This mix of perspectives works, in part because tourism is such a messy international theatre, and in part because US–Latin American exchanges of both hard and soft varieties were invariably unequal, difficult to interpret and culturally challenging to all parties involved.
The introductory chapter ‘Mass Tourism, Empire and Soft Power’ first provides a succinct itinerary of the chronological order of chapters that trace the march of the US tourist presence in the more proximate venues of Latin America and the Caribbean – first into Mexico, then into Cuba and on into Puerto Rico, and eventually back to southern Mexico (the Yucatán) and Central America (Costa Rica). Then, it more substantially presents the case for considering US tourism's soft power as a perpetual bedfellow of this hegemon's diplomacy, arguing that it ‘heightened international awareness at home, invented identities for others and themselves, helped forge and dissolve strategic alliances, [and] contributed to the coming of revolutions’.
The remainder of the ‘story’ is then organised, or ‘culturally situated’, into six chapters in which US tourists play a much more central role in negotiations and activities than other more conventional ‘international relations’ explanations of the US ‘empire’ in Latin America would have it. Chap. 1, ‘Lone Eagles and Revolutionaries’, opens the saga with an examination of the opening up of Mexico to US tourists in the 1920s, many of whom the author characterises as ‘Prohibition-Era escapists’: drunken cowboys, adventurers, poets, artists, college students. A tourism infrastructure for this ‘cross-border’ travel emerged and tensions between tourists and hosts were palpable, but exchanges and negotiations softened relations between post-revolutionary Mexico and pre-Depression, Prohibition-era Americans.
Starting before the age of aviation-driven mass tourism, chap. 2, ‘Containment and Good Neighbors’, then chronicles the growth of the Mexican tourist industry during the 1930s and 1940s, and probes its impact on the everyday life of ‘empire’. It examines how conflicting constructions of class, race and gender produced cultural clashes between visiting consumers and hosts, but also spurred negotiations. This struggle reached its turning point when President Cárdenas (1934–40), a populist best known for nationalising the nation's oil industry, intervened in tourism's unregulated expansion and prohibited casino gambling while allocating state funds to Mexican-owned hotels and restaurants to improve their competitive position with US-financed hoteliers.
Chap. 3, ‘The Safe Bet’, then moves to the Cold War era, from the age of train travel to that of aviation (I am curious as to why the author almost passes over maritime travel). The geographical ‘story’ also shifts from post-revolutionary Mexico to the pre-revolutionary Cuba of President Batista's repressive dictatorial regime and its offshore embracing of ‘crony capitalism’, in which US mobsters, city bosses and racketeers, as well as Washington's political elites, featured prominently in Havana's heightened presence as a major US metropole. Thus chap. 4, ‘Paradise Lost’, stays in Cuba, to document the process by which this particular North American offshore playground came to be declared ‘off-limits’. The story starts during the final days of the Batista dictatorship, on through the early days of Fidel Castro's succession and his fledgling government's vain attempt to continue tourism. Eventually (within 18 months) and inevitably, because of the deterioration of US–Cuban diplomatic relations and the failed military adventurism that culminated in the Bay of Pigs fiasco, there is an associated collapse of tourist ties. This ushers in an unwavering and often harsh US hegemony, so that there will be no rapprochement between the two administrations for the next 50 years or so – and no tourist soft power either.
Chap. 5, ‘Bootstraps, Beaches, and Cobblestone’, describes and analyses Puerto Rico's ‘strange odyssey’ from colony to commonwealth, its clumsy attempt to forge an industrial modernisation programme in Operation Bootstrap, and the origins of its ‘planned postwar travel industry’ in which successive administrations have struggled with the identity of its heritage-tourism offerings. Modernisation, migration and industrialisation tensions also characterise this period of change for Puerto Rico, but the author's attempt to attribute this island's all-too-rapid transformation to the failure of the wider Alliance for Progress that the United States attempted to build more broadly in Latin America is not very convincing. Puerto Rico had its destiny in its own hands both as a US-tourist alternative to Cuba and in regard to its own internal political turmoil over the choice of independence and dependency, with Riqueños choosing the latter time and time again.
Chap. 6, ‘A Cold War Mirage’, follows this Caribbean case further by charting Puerto Rico's ‘rising stock as a reformist Cold War oasis’, starting in the 1930s and continuing through the 1970s, and interweaving the growth of a US-dominated tourism ensemble in Puerto Rico with the United States' failed Alliance for Progress model for the remainder of Latin America. Here the cultural clashes of tourist and host are painted in high relief, as they were in Mexico, whereas similar situations and confrontations in Cuba had not appeared to matter as much.
Then follows a modest conclusion of only 14 pages, in which the author considers how the Mexican, Cuban and Puerto Rican stories fit together. This last chapter provides a brief survey of post-1970s contemporary trends in US–Latin American tourism – from Mexico's Cancún to Costa Rica's ecotourism, to revolutionary Cuba's recent re-embracing of European, Canadian and ‘errant-American’ tourists – but attempts to cover too many decades and too many dramatic changes of circumstances. Nor does it effectively ‘connect the dots’, because the depth of detail and the dovetailing of tourism's twists and turns with US–Latin America political manoeuvring that has made each chapter so pleasantly readable and informative is missing in this concluding ‘brief’.
Despite this last minor criticism, Negotiating Paradise more than accomplishes its task by providing readers with an extremely interesting and informative historiography of the United States' neo-colonial designs on Latin America through its ‘hard-diplomacy’ and ‘soft-tourism’ influences. These two hemispheric ‘penetrations’ sometimes coincide and collaborate while at other times the latter ameliorates the former's ‘big-stick’, militaristic approach. Merrill shows us successfully how much tourism's influences and soft-power interventions were implicated and involved in the geopolitical manoeuvring that took place between the United States and Latin America between the 1920s and 1970s. The quality of scholarship is high, the co-organisation of the cultural and political material is always thoughtful and insightful, and the structural and ‘agency’ perspectives and insights offered are convincing and powerful. I am glad I have this on my shelf, and recommend it to other Latin American social scientists and historiographers.
