In this short volume the Portuguese historian João Pedro Marques takes on past and present-day authors who have made slaves the principal agents in the abolition of American slavery. These authors, who remain unnamed until the book’s concluding chapter but include the likes of Frederick Douglass, Herbert Aptheker and Richard Hart, have allegedly created a number of serious misunderstandings about slave revolts. The proposition that slaves were by definition rebellious and that slave revolts were fundamentally about the abolition of slavery, as well as the idea that Western governments abolished slavery in fearful reaction to violent acts of resistance, are the most powerful among these so-called mystifications.
Against this view of the African slave as the successful rebel, Marques contends that slave uprisings did not generally facilitate the cause of slave emancipation. He explains that resistance was hardly ever about the abolition of slavery, but normally the result of struggles to improve living conditions or redress local grievances. To better their conditions slaves did often not revolt at all, but instead negotiated peacefully with their masters. On quite a few occasions slaves actually collaborated with their masters or with colonial governments in the repression of revolts. Most nineteenth-century slave revolts, moreover, caused setbacks to the era’s abolitionist campaigns rather than helping them. Therefore Marques denies the existence of any direct causal relationship between slave rebellions and emancipation laws.
In the first of the book’s three main chapters, the author discusses various forms of ‘resistance’ and ‘collaboration’ that have surfaced in the history of New World slave societies, with particular attention to flight and maroonage. The other core chapters focus on the relatively well-known slave revolts in Saint-Domingue (1791), Barbados (1816), Demerara (1823) and Jamaica (1831) and on the nineteenth-century slave emancipations in North and South America and the Caribbean region. The point repeated throughout the book is that by and large slaves were not responsible for their own emancipation. Marques builds his argument on a reading of secondary literature, largely works from Anglophone historians. The writing is admirably clear and uncomplicated.
This essay could therefore serve as an introduction to the study of slave revolts for Portuguese language readers, except that its theoretical scope is rather limited. Although there may still be scholars who argue that rebellion was the underlying cause of the abolition of slavery, this is not one of the most interesting issues to tackle in relation to slave revolts. One fundamental question about American slave resistance concerns the role of slaves in the history of emancipation; just saying what slaves did not accomplish is far from a serious answer. More challenging than asking whether or not slave revolts stimulated the fall of African slavery in the Americas would be an inquiry into the impact of such revolts on the condition of slavery in the Americas. Furthermore, pointing out that slaves rarely revolted to obtain better work and living conditions, or even their liberty, but more commonly preferred to negotiate with their masters about labour rewards, rights to land and the like (p. 113) begs the question – not dealt with by Marques – why slaves sometimes resorted to violence instead of peaceful bargaining.
The limits of Marques’s theoretical parameters – or of his interest in the significance of slave agency – become obvious when he says that, similar to land-based revolts, slave uprisings on board slaving vessels did not have a significant impact on the continuity of slavery and the slave trade as viable socio-economic institutions (p. 32). This is of course true, but as David Eltis first pointed out in The rise of African slavery in the Americas, by increasing the costs of transporting slaves, shipboard revolts had an impact on the volume and directions of the Atlantic slave trade in Africa. Furthermore, while Marques borrows heavily from the work of David Brion Davis, he curiously does not pick up the point Davis has made in Inhuman bondage and elsewhere about the profound impact of the Haitian revolution on slave societies around the Atlantic world. Black people in the Americas, both free and slave, felt stimulated by the accomplishments of the Saint-Domingue rebels to fight for equality, while Whites began perceiving any form of rebellion as potentially destructive of slavery. Haiti opened up a new dimension to racial conflict and helped to put emancipation on the political agenda in a large number of slave-holding societies. Marques, however, sees the case of Saint-Domingue first of all as an anomaly, it being the single slave uprising in history that successfully undermined a regional system of slavery (p. 45), and does not seriously consider the wider ramifications of the revolt.
The book sometimes offers interesting insights – even though these are never Marques’s own – and then the reader gets a glimpse of the more complex nature of the relation between resistance and emancipation. For example, at the end of his discussion of the major revolts in the British Caribbean (Barbados, Demerara, and Jamaica), Marques admits that there was a positive connection between these revolts and abolitionism, as British abolitionists made slave revolts a central theme of their discourse in order to demonstrate the inherent brutality of the slave system. But Marques is quick to stress that this relationship between rebellion and emancipation was historically unique in that it depended on the extraordinary emergence of abolitionism as a dominant political factor in nineteenth-century Britain (pp. 47, 64–5, 115). Against this, one could argue that if it were not for the British abolitionists, slavery in the Americas might have continued far beyond the nineteenth century. Similarly, in Chapter 3, despite his general argument that slave emancipations in various European colonies were not brought about under the pressure of resistance, Marques mentions a number of cases from Martinique, Saint-Croix, São Tomé and Cuba where slave agency did in fact lead to freedom (pp. 90–3, 96–9).
In an introductory note to the volume Marques engages with a recent judicial case in France involving the historian Olivier Pétré-Grenouilleau, who had been accused by French activists of African descent of downplaying the historical significance of the Atlantic slave trade. His point here is that academic scholars should not be forced to be politically correct when examining socially hot topics such as slavery and abolition. Marques knows, of course, that denying slaves a fundamental role in emancipation narratives is politically incorrect. But in his case it also brings little imaginative analysis.
