An extremely popular entertainer during his life, in the decades since his death Bert Williams has become an almost totemic figure for both historians and artists. In Introducing Bert Williams: Burnt Cork, Broadway, and the Story of America's First Black Star, Camille F. Forbes revisits the life of this fascinating genius of the American stage. Discussions frequently center on what he represented for African Americans (though he was West Indian by birth), for the white public, to himself, and so on. A lyric interpretation of his career is almost begged for, considering his life's work: he performed in blackface starting in the 1890s; helped create a back-to-Africa musical called In Dahomey; became synonymous with a comedic song entitled “Nobody”; and wrote magazine and newspaper articles that indicate at the very least a self-awareness of his unique doubleness—and possibly a troubled conscience.
Williams has received attention by different generations of scholars and artists, with two other books about him being published in the past few years: Louis Chude-Sokei's The Last “Darky”: Bert Williams, Black-on-Black Minstrelsy, and the African Diaspora (2006) and Caryl Phillips's fictionalization of Williams in Dancing in the Dark (2005). Each of these three looks at the entertainer from a different perspective, with Forbes taking something of a middle ground between Phillips's deeply psychological novel and Chude-Sokei's broadly theoretical examination. She presents a chronological biography that tracks his road to prominence and his work to the end of his life. One of the book's greatest strengths is how it places Williams within the larger context of American performance and black performers, and shows how the headliner struggled against immense limitations—primarily, of course, the tradition of performed racial impersonation.
As Forbes states in her introduction, “I search for Bert Williams both within and behind the mask of blackface” (xii), as anyone discussing or thinking about Bert Williams must. Forbes links Williams's blackface to the existing performance tradition of minstrelsy that supported and expected it. “Blackface stood in for a black body presumed to exist beneath—or even instead of—the performative mask,” Forbes writes. “The mask thus became the means by which the character, through the songs the comedian sang or the darky dialect in which he sang them, could be thought realistic” (25). The contradictions and divisions between the performer and the mask are recurrent tropes in Introducing Bert Williams.
One of the book's most interesting threads is the way fame and prominence were complicated and sometimes double-edged goals for Williams and his partner George Walker. The famous duo met on the streets of San Francisco, where one of their earliest gigs together was on a fairground as fake Africans living in a simulated African village (an experience that became an inspiration for their later musicals). The indignities and difficulties they faced as unknown entertainers, billed early on as “Two Real Coons,” became even more intense as they achieved national and international stardom.
Forbes tracks the rapid rise of the duo during the first decade of the twentieth century and carefully notes the ways they tried to excel as artists. Each new show had to exceed their own standards and at the same time meet the expectations of their publics—both the large white audience and the diverse black one. Walker was always a vociferous believer in racial uplift, and he thought (as did many) that the Williams and Walker productions could embolden others. As Forbes notes, “Onstage became merely one location of the actors' performances on behalf of the race … . Yet, as minstrelsy's incorporation of blacks had shown, mere visibility did not counter the weight of history” (117). This constant visibility made the duo de facto emissaries for blacks—a mantle that rested easier on the shoulders of Walker than of Williams.
After his partner's death in 1911, Williams spent much of the next decade working for Florenz Ziegfeld's different Follies shows. In analyzing these later solo years, Forbes's meticulous research and compelling writing illuminate a phase in Williams's career that may otherwise have seemed monolithic. Forbes details specific skits on which Williams worked, ones that were both topical (the building of Grand Central Station and the Jack Johnson–Jim Jeffries boxing match) and traditional (Williams still wore blackface and sang “Nobody”). The racism Williams experienced during these years is made all the more painful because of how straightforwardly he handled and discussed it.
Forbes comes closest to a weary poeticism when writing about the end of Williams's life, when he was struggling as the headlining black performer (the only one in the cast, and the only one in blackface) in a new musical called Under the Bamboo Tree. The strain of its pre–New York tryout hastened his death. The show is contrasted with Emperor Jones and Shuffle Along, two notable productions from the early 1920s that highlighted how out of touch Williams was from the current trends for blacks on the American stage: by 1921, he was an anachronism. It's not hard to think of Williams's life as tragic, considering that his talent was unable to be fully recognized in his time; nor is it hard to think of his life as ironic, considering his uneasy balance of personal notoriety and blackfaced anonymity. Fortunately, Forbes resists such facile readings in this worthwhile biography.
