This slim volume addresses two important themes — imperialism and the concept of the barbarian — and attempts to relate the two, specifically in the context of the Western Roman Empire. The aim of the book — cogently stated in the introduction — is to examine Roman ethnography on the Western Empire, and by analysing the ways in which knowledge about these areas and their peoples was preserved and represented, to elucidate Roman views about these areas. Woolf explicitly links this with imperialism and the extension of Roman rule, as well as with the development of ideas about alterity.
The four chapters address discrete, although related, topics within this overall theme. Ch. 1 examines the various strategies which ancient authors used to define and represent peoples and places which they regarded as barbarian. Given the limitations of space, the treatment is necessarily episodic, discussing a number of individual case studies in which W. explores the bewildering diversity of ancient ethnography on the Celts, ancient Spain, and a number of other peoples, and the possible reasons for this. In particular, he relates this to theories of hybridity and the Middle Ground in relations between Romans and their non-Roman subjects.
Ch. 2 addresses, in some ways rather less successfully, the development (or rather the failure to develop) of ancient ethnography. W. reviews the strategies used by ancient authors for describing and categorizing other peoples — notably explaining their perceived cultural characteristics by reference to their natural surroundings, or their genealogical and mythological descent. He highlights, in particular, the absence of obvious ancient debate about the relative merits of these various strategies, which seem to be deployed as required and do not crystallize into distinct schools of thought. This is, slightly oddly, characterized as intellectual failure on the part of ancient writers, although W. himself acknowledges (51ff.) that it seems a little harsh to blame them for not developing a science of anthropology or geography. Although W. notes this disparity in development between ethnography and other sciences such as mathematics in the ancient world, he does not advance any particular explanations for it.
Ch. 3 explores the connections between Roman imperialism and the growth of ethnographic writing, but here also, the conclusions are oddly negative. W. makes a convincing case against a direct link between military expansion and growth of interest in — and knowledge of — the geography and ethnography of newly-conquered areas. He argues that Polybius, who accompanied Scipio on campaign, was the exception rather than the rule. The main contribution of empire to the development of ethnography was in providing the context for scholars to work and exchange views, citing the development of libraries, literary patronage of scholars by wealthy Romans, and the growth of a community of scholars in Rome.
Finally, ch. 4 examines the ways in which ethnic stereotypes did, and perhaps more significantly, did not change over time. This aspect, perhaps more than anything, highlights the divergence between the contemporary reality of, for example, Gaulish identity, and the ethnic stereotypes of wild warriors which are found in ancient literature. The identities ascribed to the peoples of the Western Empire become a palimpsest of stereotypical attributes, arising at different points in history and often self-contradictory, which have little connection with the realities of Gaulish (or Spanish, or British) identities. In doing so, W. skilfully demonstrates the ways in which ethnic categorization can be used to emphasize otherness and barbarism, even when educated Greeks and Romans must have been well aware that contemporary reality was very different.
This book presents a group of thought-provoking essays on aspects of the themes of barbarism and alterity, and of ancient ethnographic treatments of them, but some aspects are more successful than others, and the brevity of the volume necessarily limits discussion of some complex topics. For instance, W. posits a fundamental difference between the Latin-speaking West and the Greek world in the way in which cultures were perceived by both Romans and non-Romans, and in the preservation of cultural memories. He argues that the traditions, knowledge and cultural memories of the peoples of the West were discouraged and in some cases suppressed after the Roman conquest, in contrast to the Eastern Empire, where local cultural traditions flourished and were even actively revived during the first and second centuries b.c. However, this seems a suspiciously neat binary divide, and further discussion would have been welcome. Cultural history rarely falls into such coherent patterns, and it would be interesting to know where, for instance, W. regards Italy as falling in this scheme of things, or how he accounts for the experiences of Greeks in the Western Mediterranean under Roman rule. Similarly, the failure of ancient geography and ethnography to develop in the way that other areas of knowledge did is noted, but not really explained.
Structurally, the effectiveness of W.'s arguments is a little undermined by some lack of integration between the chapters. This is, no doubt, due to the book's origins as a series of free-standing lectures on Roman interpretations of new territories conquered in the late Republic and early Empire. The effect, however, is to somewhat undermine the overall coherence of the book. Each chapter offers fascinating insights into aspects of Roman ethnography and concepts of alterity, and represents important additions to the literature on the subject, but overall, the book is rather less than the sum of its parts.
