Ciudad Juárez, the Mexican border city across from El Paso, Texas, has long had the sad distinction of holding the world's attention exclusively as the murder capital of North America. The association of the city with the inhuman torture and murder of young girls has made its name a shorthand for violent rape-murders: since 1993 there have been 470 young women and girls killed in and around the city, their bodies often mutilated and discarded in the nearby desert. Thus Ciudad Juárez has sparked world awareness of the issue of domestic violence and feminicide. In the last year, these gruesome murders have almost shifted backstage, as the astonishingly high death rate among young men has reminded us all of the high cost of the war on drugs: in 2008 alone there were 1,650 drug-related murders, and a 2009 report shows preliminary statistics citing a murder rate three times higher than the previous year's horrific total.
Kathleen Staudt is a feminist political scientist who has lived and worked in this volatile border area for over 30 years, and has a particular professional interest, shown in her distinguished publishing history, of concern with the status of women and particularly with political activism and public policy around women's issues. More and more over the last years, her research has led her to focus on the border area and to collaborate with NGOs on the analysis of risk factors associated with domestic violence against women. Thus, her new book stands as a long-awaited companion to previous work she has published on the region, including Free Trade? Informal Economies at the U.S.–Mexico Border (1998), Fronteras No Más: Toward Social Justice at the U.S.–Mexico Border (with Irasema Coronado, 2002), and Pledging Allegiance: Learning Nationalism in El Paso-Juárez (with Susan Rippberger, also 2002), along with her edited study, Human Rights Along the U.S.–Mexico Border: Gendered Violence and Insecurity (which will be released by the University of Arizona Press before this review sees print). In her new book, Staudt takes on an almost impossible task: to offer an even-handed analysis of a place and a series of circumstances that are almost always and inevitably framed in heightened language, and to do so from a compassionate, committed interdisciplinary feminist perspective.
‘How does one come to “know” truths and realities?’ (p. xii), asks Staudt in the opening pages of this book. In context, this is a provocative question. While there have been many studies in recent years on feminicide in Ciudad Juárez, they have tended to be journalistic overviews, cultural analyses, (docu)fictions, exposés, political statements or polemical arguments, with varying degrees of academic validity. Staudt's goal, in this book, is to offer her readers the first truly methodical research project on domestic violence in the city, a project hampered by the stridency of the existing debates and the lack of disaggregation of official Mexican statistics. This means that Staudt is dedicated to a structured and sober construction of knowledge, including a review of literature, and utilisation of qualitative and quantitative research instruments including surveys, interviews, and participant observation – in her case with support from the venerable Juárez NGO Federación Mexicana de Asociaciones Privadas (FEMAP) and its El Paso counterpart. And she wants her study to be useful to the general reader, while advancing real public policy proposals. Unsurprisingly, the book is a mixed bag.
This book has six short chapters and four intercalated appendices. In the first chapter, ‘Framing Perspectives’, Staudt provides an overview of the local US–Mexico borderlands context along with a discussion of her research methodology, a comparative politics framework that makes very brief (from the perspective of cultural analysis, excessively brief) allusions to other potentially useful theoretical tools, including Judith Butler's philosophical perspective on gender performativity. Her second chapter, the least successful and least necessary one in the book, offers a broadly interdisciplinary ‘review of existing knowledge’. Perhaps because she is striving for readability across disciplines, scholars from any individual field are likely to come away dissatisfied. Thus, for example, she succumbs to the unnecessary and wholly unconvincing temptation to define Mexican national character (a very outmoded concept) through a cursory reading of poet Octavio Paz's long-discredited meditations on the topic, along with brief references to thinkers such as Roger Bartra, Samuel Ramos and Oscar Lewis. Analogously, very brief references to Franz Fanon and Hannah Arendt are meant to suggest applicability to gender inequities in Juárez, but the level of generality prevents any real insight.
The heart of the book and its most important chapters include the discussion of the NGO-hosted workshops and survey findings in Chapter 3 and the early hints of government responses to the issue of domestic violence summarised in Chapter 5. While the sample of women interviewed does not pretend to randomness, the summary of the women's own sense of their powerlessness or empowerment is important and suggestive for future research on cultural context and the potential for activist responses. The form these responses might take is still in flux, as suggested by the awkwardness of Chapter 4, where Staudt slips into an unreflective reportorial mode, describing specific marches, reactions to Eve Ensler's Vagina Monologues, responses from participants in a UCLA conference, and alluding to a scattershot selection of fictions that mention border violence. With Chapter 5, on government policy, Staudt is on firmer and more familiar disciplinary ground. However, the material she has to work with is still very thin, often compiled from newspaper reports. Surely I am not alone in hoping that Staudt and her collaborators will be continuing their work in this important area of study, which is certainly worthy of its own book-length analysis.
In sum, Violence and Activism at the Border is a somewhat uneven book, prematurely rushed into print, by a distinguished and highly respected senior scholar whose commitment to continuing work on this topic will certainly bring forth more mature fruit in the near future.
