The Politics of Commercial Treaties examines the role of commercial treaties as instruments of both trade and peace in Europe. Commercial treaties are employed as a “direct point of access” (p. 15) into the history of the political economic order of the eighteenth century. The book challenges the existing literature that claims “commercial treaties were practically absent from the eighteenth century” (p. 3). Instead, it establishes that the eighteenth century was a period of transformation in the role and origins of commercial treaties; they were converted from simple agreements on trade terms to instruments for the creation of an international order and as elements of a political will or vision. All of the chapters focus on commercial treaties. However, individual authors differ in their approach: the majority focus on a particular country; others, upon a specific treaty; and the remaining authors choose an alternative focus including a historical figure, a revolution, or the effects of war. The result is a medley of informative, yet distinct, chapters each underpinned by the central theme of the changing role of commercial treaties during the eighteenth century.
Most of the authors have structured their contribution by focusing upon a particular country or set of countries. These chapters offer a detailed historical analysis of both the attitude towards, and the ratification of, commercial treaties within the chosen countries.
By analyzing the British political aftermath to the Treaty of Utrecht (1713), Doohwan Ahn offers a novel angle on the Tory–Whig divide over British foreign policy from 1710 to 1713. The division over Utrecht is summarized as one of two opposing world views: “that of rivalry and that of alliance” (p. 129). By studying a series of criminal charges made against Tory leaders, by the Whigs, for their role in the ratification of Utrecht, Ahn enlightens the reader on this political divide. The Treaty of Utrecht also plays a central role in Koen Stapelbroek’s study of the Dutch role in the interstate trading system. The Peace of Utrecht (1713) is identified as a key turning point in the formation of Dutch treaties: pre-1713, the Dutch Republic was commercially independent, and post-1713, they became dependent upon relations with France. Stapelbroek’s analysis of this change, and the succeeding Dutch policies and actions, provides detail and nuance to the “familiar narrative of Dutch decline after 1700” (p. 196).
Antonella Alimento outlines French commercial treaties and solutions to international competition from 1736 to 1770. The changing nature of, and attitude toward, commercial treaties in eighteenth-century France is summarized by their transformation into “an instrument to harmonize … the interests of European nations” (p. 265), an economically successful instrument that continued to be employed by successive French leaders. In contrast to France, as Christopher Storrs demonstrates, the economic success of the Savoyard State was not due to the conclusion of commercial treaties, as the small state had an aversion towards long-term economic and political commitments. Instead, their success was underpinned by a number of narrower agreements with states that did not limit “its freedom of political manoeuvre” (p. 322). Christine Lebeau establishes the differences in the negotiation of commercial treaties in the imperial context of the Habsburg Monarchy. A multitude of actors, with differing interests, meant that commercial negotiations were a complicated, protracted process of communication from both the centre and periphery (and vice versa), and also between various levels of administration.
Olga Volosyuk analyzes Russian–Spanish relations in the early eighteenth century, and tracks the ebb and flow of Russian–Spanish treaty negotiations. Despite initial optimism surrounding Russian–Spanish commercial relations, underpinned by their military and political aims, which “dovetailed harmoniously” (p. 179), the 1730s marked the end of “the protracted enterprise of concluding a Russian–Spanish commercial treaty” (p. 193). This failure for commercial treaties to generate change is further demonstrated by Paul Cheney, who illustrates that despite Haiti’s independence in 1804, its commercial treaties with the imperial powers continued to regulate its entire system of accumulation. These commercial relations led to the maintenance of the plantation and servile labor of the old regime, in spite of Haiti’s revolution that was underpinned by the “self-determination of free slaves” (p. 402).
A number of authors center their chapters upon a specific treaty. By delimiting their focus, the authors provide profound analysis that in many ways contradicts mainstream interpretations.
The Methuen Treaty (1703) is the focus of José Luís Cardoso’s chapter. He challenges the orthodox understanding of the treaty as “as clear-cut evidence of the dominance of English economic interests over Portuguese ones” (p. 106) by analyzing initial Portuguese and English reactions to it and subsequent ideas regarding its merits and shortcomings. Cardoso explains that the ‘historical myths’ surrounding the Methuen Treaty have led to its unfair equivalence with the damaging and imbalanced Anglo–Portuguese Treaties of Friendship and Commerce (1810). Authors Virginia Sanz and Niccolò Guasti focus on the Hispano–Anglo Treaty of Asiento (1713). They outline the origins of the treaty and the various political and economic elements that led to its maintenance until 1750. The authors then focus upon the ‘legacy’ of this agreement and the published Spanish sentiments in the years following its ratification. Pascal Dupuy offers a novel account of the 1786 Franco–British Treaty of Eden by centering upon French representations and imagery of the treaty. To illustrate the perceived impact of the treaty within France, Dupuy draws from three sources: pamphlets in the immediate aftermath of its ratification; legislative debates that depict the sentiments of the elite; and graphic representations of the treaty itself. Dupuy concludes that many of the representations were based on national oppositions and sought to demonstrate the British as deceitful.
The remaining chapters provide a more general overview of commercial treaties in the eighteenth century, using the lens of specific historical figures, wartime trade, the French Revolution, and the role of trading companies.
Moritz Isenmann writes on Jean-Baptiste Colbert and the role of commercial treaties in his economic policy. Orthodox opinion on Colbert concludes that his economic policy was protectionist, misguided, and merely a reiteration of his predecessors. Isenmann’s systematic overview of Colbert’s policies illustrates their originality and intellect: essentially they followed a “middle path between open market rivalry … and outright protectionism” (p.102), based on the fundamental principles of reciprocity and most favored nation. Marco Cavarzere reconsiders the political and economic strategies and objectives of Frederick II, who is usually understood “according to the categories of nineteenth-century Machtpolitik” (p. 295). First, Cavarzere demonstrates that the idea of a balance of power based on trade, outlined by Frederick in the essay “Anti-Machiavel,” underpinned his rule from the 1740s to mid-1750s. In a second step, Cavarzere uses the 1753 Franco–Prussian trade agreement to illustrate the transformation in Prussian attitudes towards commercial treaties: from an instrument of subordination to a symbol of equality.
In his chapter on the conditions of trade in wartime, Éric Schnakenbourg illustrates that the accumulation and repetition of maritime commercial treaties produced a broad set of general principles that contributed to the creation of the law of nations. Schnakenbourg demonstrates that commercial treaties are not simply bilateral agreements but instead are, and should be studied as, integral elements of larger legal, economic, and political frames of reference. John Shovlin’s analysis of the negotiations between the French and English East India companies in the years 1753 to 1755 is an example of commercial treaty negotiations as an element of a wider political landscape. These negotiations illustrate the integral role played by company directors, and not just political parties, in the debates about the pacification and stabilization of trade specifically during wartime.
The substantial influence of the French Revolution features throughout the book. However, Marc Belissa directly addresses the role of the revolution in the context of the wider interstate trade system. Belissa demonstrates the disorder caused by the revolution on the European balance of power in trade by outlining the debate about a new republican trade system, including the implementation of a Navigation Act, among the economists, merchants, and politicians of the time.
In conclusion, Alimento and Stapelbroek have edited a detailed and novel examination of the role of commercial treaties in the creation of a political and economic European order during the eighteenth century. The expertise of numerous academics from across Europe has enabled such an examination; however, it has also led to the use of non-English phrases throughout the book. In these instances there are no English translations provided and this results in a disruption to the understanding of certain passages. The edited format of the book, however, also constitutes one of its key strengths. The same treaties, wars, and historical figures feature in numerous different chapters, and thus the reader is exposed to each of these historical elements from the perspective of different countries and through the analysis of different authors. Ultimately, the reader is left with a wide-ranging, comprehensive understanding of commercial treaties in eighteenth-century Europe and the political and economic order they played a central role in creating.
