In the well-established, interdisciplinary, and capacious field of partition studies, Deepti Misri's book Beyond Partition: Gender, Violence, and Representation in Postcolonial India is a fresh and important intervention. It contributes to ongoing conversations in the field about the 1947 partition of India, even while it argues that we must extend those conversations to a broader consideration of gendered violence in post-partition India. Taking gender difference as the thread that connects the diverse scenes of violence and resistance under study—from caste violence to “encounters,” honor killing, indigenous oppression, and ethnic conflict in Kashmir—the book instigates a recalibration of received approaches to violence and cultural representation that also resonates beyond India. In terms of both its archive and its methodology, Beyond Partition is an exciting and innovative project in cultural studies of gender in modern India. By drawing lines of connection between high literary texts, visual representation, activism, and performance—what she calls “non-elite memorializations of violence”—Misri skillfully foregrounds how the aesthetics and politics of representation shape, transmute, and critique the experience of gender and violence in the postcolonial state (p. 14).
Committed to feminist postcolonial studies, Beyond Partition is both thoroughly engaged in the scholarly debates of this field and an ambitious intervention in conversations about ethnic violence, gender, and postcolonial literature. The book's first two chapters focus on the 1947 partition and extend existing scholarship on gender and religion in Indian writing. These chapters pick up on new directions in the field that revisit the representation of masculinity and minority experience. For instance, Misri analyzes the relationship between Sikh masculinity and secularism in partition fiction by Saadat Hasan Manto in the first chapter, “Anatomy of a Riot.” The second chapter, “The Violence of Memory,” focuses on violence against women in writings by Krishna Mehta and Shauna Singh Baldwin.
In the third chapter, “Atrocious Encounters,” Misri enacts the call of her book's title and connects the discussion about partition's gendered violence with the continuing violence “beyond” partition—namely, the violence of caste and governmentality in late twentieth-century India. Calling attention to the genres of visual representation of particular “types” of violence designated by categories like “caste atrocity” and “encounter killing,” Misri beautifully interrogates the normative assumptions and representational strategies that underlie their appearance in newspapers and digital media.
In the fourth and fifth chapters, Misri sustains and builds this nuanced study of how gender violence is also marked by caste, ethnicity, indigeneity, and state practice, through a discussion of individual and collective events of embodied protest in late modern India. These include the naked protests against domestic violence that were reported in Indian news media and the protests of Kashmiri mothers whose sons have gone missing, through their organization the Association of Parents of Disappeared Persons. The diverse protests and activism she discusses, theorized through analytical frames emergent in the work of Judith Butler and others, powerfully bear out her argument that a study of violence must also ethically engage the aesthetics and politics of its critique as it appears in multiple forms—in literature, in media, and on the street. For me, these chapters were the most exciting for two reasons: First, because there is comparatively little scholarship on this material history of India, and especially on the conflict zones of Assam and Kashmir. Thus, Misri's work fills an important gap in the field. Second, because these chapters vividly articulate what appear to be radically different moments and acts of political protest by women, in places as different as Rajasthan in the west and Kashmir in the north, they depict a very different India from mainstream perspectives of “Shining India” as an economic growth story.
There are thus two important ways in which Beyond Partition intervenes in and contributes to the fields of transnational gender studies and modern Indian studies. First, Beyond Partition forges a unique, interdisciplinary archive and approach: well-engaged with influential theoretical and historical work on violence and gender, the book's representational archive includes fiction by leading South Asian writers like Saadat Hasan Manto, Shauna Singh Baldwin, and Arundhati Roy, juxtaposed with photographic images of women, governmentality, and violence that appear in Indian news media, and embodied activist practices of protest. This uncommon juxtaposition allows Misri to deftly map the complexity of the shape that the critical engagement with violence takes in India in different arenas, from art to political action. It is in this method that I see Misri's feminist commitment to the critique of gendered violence manifest most powerfully and persuasively in Beyond Partition. These vivid and at times startling juxtapositions allow Misri to illuminate both the role and the value of literature in bearing witness to violence against women and minorities, and the dominant photographic strategies in the media that often naturalize that violence. Simultaneously, her book demonstrates how different women engage in activism and public protest against domestic violence, ethnic discrimination, caste, and state violence in India. In the process, it shows how activism produces and mobilizes representations of gender and violence to challenge prevailing hierarchies of power. In a sense dismantling the divisions of high culture and low, Misri's book reminds us of the contingency of representations and their critical power from below. This is both innovative and very effective. For instance, her elegant and compelling analysis of Arundhati Roy's novel The God of Small Things sits alongside her recognition of the spheres literature does not reach. Recognizing that for so many subaltern subjects, from indigenous communities to Kashmiris under siege, the strategies for critique and protest remain embodied and nonliterary, Misri persuasively reminds us that in gender and minority struggles, resistant representations take many forms. In this, her project calls on us to engage and connect the critique of gender violence in art with the critical protests of individuals, community groups, and NGOs to better understand the forms and practices that constitute resistance.
This exciting and important book will be of interest to students and scholars interested in partition studies, Kashmir, women's studies, Indian literature, and, more generally, gender and sexuality in South Asia. Written in an accessible style without sacrificing complexity of analysis, Beyond Partition will be suitable for inclusion in undergraduate and graduate courses on modern Indian literature, media, women's and gender studies, and South Asia.
