Isa Blumi's dense book examines local political economies in order to contextualize the 19th-century transformations of the Ottoman Empire. His focus is mostly on the western Balkans, with added sections on Egypt, Yemen, and Kuwait. Blumi's “fundamental agenda is to argue that there are different ways to interpreting events before Modernity” (p. xvi). This is because “western domination” in histories of Modernity “is a discursive phenomenon, an ideological project, a myth,” and such a “pernicious mythology” needs to be disassembled (p. 1). The “totalizing concept” of Modernity “(a.k.a. ‘the West’)” is “a transcended truth, one that interweaves patterns of domination and exploitation with forms of presenting our past, present, and future” (p. 2). Modernity, as such, is a “mega-History” (p. 11) articulated primarily after World War II and needs to be undone by revealing “the reciprocal relationship between state institutions and subject populations” (p. 5). According to Blumi, “there were a plethora of experiences scattered throughout the Ottoman frontiers that neither reflect other events, happenings, and experiences taking place at the same time (often even within the same geographic space) nor permit absorption in the teleology of Modernity. Highlighting such experiences helps deny the inevitability of Modernity” (p. 13).
The first chapter is what one might call a “middle-up” history of 19th-century Ottoman governance as a “multi-layered dynamic” in a period when “the Red Sea, Persian/Arab Gulf, and Western Balkans developed a new significance to the larger world” (p. 45). Criticizing careless use of the word “Empire,” Blumi suggests a dissection of local histories so as to reveal the “many disparate sets of experiences” that are blurred in “conventional scholarship to conjoin eventually with the twentieth century as a cumulative story” (p. 15). He emphasizes the middle men: the eminent ayan (ʿAli Pasha of Tepelena), governors (Mehmet ʿAli of Kavala), and local notability; his intention is “to analyze how local intermediaries often proved to be the actual engines of change rather than being the servants of greater historical processes” (p. 20). Blumi argues throughout the book that economic vitality in the Balkans and Arabia during the 19th century created a potential for local agents and that “in these moments of opportunity, state and/or company officials sometimes proved adept enough to develop strategies that more effectively influenced local and regional events” (p. 33). The argument is clear, even if the discussion is not evenly detailed. We learn, for example, that ʿAli Pasha was “the primary power broker in the southwest Balkans in 1810s” (p. 25) and that Saʿid ibn Sultan of Oman “played a vital role in balancing regional political and economic conditions off the aspiring hegemonic Indian Ocean commercial power” (p. 33). Blumi does not discuss the role of these agents in as much detail as, for example, that of Shaykh Muhammad ibn Khalifa in Bahrain.
International boundaries, the chaos they created, and the resilience of the people divided by them, are a significant political–economic complex for this book. Focusing on borders, refugees, and exiles in three consecutive chapters, Blumi reveals complex layers of agency often blurred by “the teleological meta-narrative of modernity.” Economic transformations of the 19th century, he argues, impacted local agents who shaped their strategies as they aptly responded to the political maneuvers of what are conventionally considered authorities (Ottoman Empire/European powers). This power dialogue combines population control with economic interests; Ottoman/foreign intervention into local political economy and the resilience of the latter make for a vivid story.
Blumi argues that demarcating imperial boundaries was a charged process of negotiation plotting local interests against those of the financial oligarchy: “[b]orders . . . were ultimately the response to local polities creating contingencies that threatened to get out of hand” and potentially posed a threat to the interests of foreign powers (p. 75). He relates his discussion of boundaries to the drastic impact of the 1858 land code, noting that “upwards of 80 percent of land had been transferred from the state to private hands . . . Much of that land became collateral that was de facto owned by the financial oligarchy based in London and in Paris” (p. 50). (However, to emphasize local resistance, he adds later: “the peoples of the world in the late nineteenth/early twentieth centuries were nowhere near becoming subordinates to the whims of finance capital” [p. 142]). Increased economic activity and Ottoman/foreign imperial attempts to assert influence in the Balkans and Arabia created “a reconfigured matrix of regional possibilities for local actors as well as innovative Ottoman officials” (p. 65). In this context, border conflicts and smuggling/piracy become part of local and imperial strategies.
In his third chapter, Blumi focuses on the agency of refugees and their impact on “the matrix of regional possibilities” in Kuwait and (to a larger extent) the Balkans. Similar to Ussama Makdisi and Ryan Gingeras, Blumi argues that 19th-century demographic movements—stimulated with Ottoman/foreign involvement—led to local tensions and to the “rise of sectarianism” (p. 102). Blumi discusses (briefly) the land disputes in Prizren and the “interventionist spirit introduced by the Mürzsteg commission” (p. 106) in Kosova and Manastir; however, we do not get a clear sense of the size of refugee communities in the Balkans (particularly vis-à-vis “locals”). Without numbers, it is difficult to understand the extent to which politics in these regions “was predicated on the stable settlement of the flow of migrants” (p. 84). Likewise, how “the resettlement of hundreds of thousands of people . . . stimulated the growth of small-scale textile and cereal production and industries” (p. 95) remains vague. One also needs to consider how the reactions to the refugees were shaped by the influx of other groups earlier in the century. Given the forced Adyge resettlements of the 1860s and early 1870s, it is difficult to conceive that the “realities on the ground after Berlin 1878 . . . [represented an] entirely new territory for these societies adapting to both the new borders and influx of refugees” (p. 88).
A detailed study of exiles in the next—and arguably one of the stronger—chapters adds to Blumi's focus on local agency. Tracing debates among South Albanian exiles in Romania, Bulgaria, and Egypt, Blumi challenges essentialist categories based on “national” identities. The exiles’ complex self-identification processes explicate the “counter-intuitive dynamics at work among the displaced inhabitants of the Ottoman realm” (p. 140). He focuses mostly on Albanian exiles, with a brief, interesting discussion of “a recently discovered library of an exiled Hudaydah scholar of the Khatmiyya Sufi order” (p. 138), who had arrived in Eritrea from Yemen. Blumi elaborately reveals the heterogeneity of the exiled communities and how different agents in these groups successfully challenged imperial power.
In the final chapter, Blumi tackles a topic that weaves through all of the previous chapters: “the political economy of reform.” Far from a top-down process, fiscal reform, he argues, should be “analyzed as one of many reactionary modifications of various local and state attempts at managing different forms of commercial activity” (p. 143). His examples include illegal markets in Yemen and railroads in the Balkans. According to Blumi, local agents’ currency exchange dealings in Yemen not only created opportunities for foreign powers but also forced the Ottoman state to respond with reforms. However, such reforms that “would serve imperial and global economic interests [. . .] also contributed to the emergence of a set of opportunities for locals to engage with the larger world” (p. 154). Similar to Beshara Doumani, Blumi suggests that the progression of European capital (which here represents imperial and global economic interests) was “at best staggered and obviously contingent upon many local factors” (p. 167). Blumi's argument in this chapter could have benefitted from a more nuanced approach. In discussing how “the railroads in the Balkans appear to have been built to service specific entrepreneurial interests that were based in Istanbul or outside the empire rather than serving any local economic needs” (p. 152), he focuses mostly on one commodity: grain. The railroads’ lack of impact on local grain production serves as evidence for the failure of “entrepreneurial interests.” A more detailed analysis of production and capital accumulation before and after the railroads would have served Blumi's argument better.
This is a welcome addition to scholarship on Ottoman administration and political economy in the 19th century. Blumi's critique of top-down studies of reform echoes successful works by Beshara Doumani, Dina Rizk Khoury, and Michael Meeker—only the last one is listed in his rich bibliography—as well as newer contributions by Christine Philliou, Giancarlo Cassale, and Ryan Gingeras—who point out how local agents shaped imperial politics in different periods. Blumi's focus on different regions/settings and his wide array of primary sources make this study stand out. His theoretical discussion and review of the literature present a dense but mostly clear and comparative framework influenced by a variety of anthropologists, philosophers, and historians. While Blumi's discussion of the diversity among the relevant agents is nuanced, his conceptualization of the “Ottoman state” could have used more detail. The imperial administration is too often considered a monoblock entity. Works on legal reform in the Ottoman Empire, such as Avi Rubin's recent volume (Ottoman Nizamiye Courts: Law and Modernity [New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2011]), contribute to a more dynamic understanding of the Ottoman imperial administration. It would be interesting to see how that level of dynamism interacts with the compelling local dynamism analyzed in this work. This is a dense study that can be used to encourage discussion in graduate courses.
