First excavated in 1862, the purpose-built brothel of Pompeii has become, as Sarah Levin-Richardson calls it, the ‘scholarly touchstone’ for all other potential brothels in the Greco-Roman world. Despite this, L.'s book is the first to offer a holistic study of the structure, presenting not only a wealth of evidence but also new interpretations of the brothel and prostitution more generally based explicitly on the finds, rather than preconceptions based on modern ideas of sex work. As she sets out clearly in the introduction, previous scholarship has ascribed many attributes to the keeping of brothels and practice of prostitution in antiquity that have no parallel in any other time or place in history, which in and of itself is problematic. What she does in the following pages is look at the entirety of the evidence with a critical eye, allowing the evidence to be viewed for what it actually is, without making assumptions based on the association with prostitution.
Her book is divided into two parts. The first examines the material evidence: the building, excavation and restoration events, artefacts, decoration and graffiti; the second focuses on the lived experience of the brothel for both female and male prostitutes and clients.
Ch. 1 focuses on the structure itself in terms of excavation, multiple and somewhat spurious attempts at restoration, and aspects of visual and physical access to the space. As an example of how this challenges previous ideas about the brothel, L. includes a comparison of the dimensions of the masonry beds with beds and triclinia in other buildings in the Vesuvian region, demonstrating that those in the brothel were, on average, larger in size than dining couches thought to seat three. This in and of itself goes a long way to dispelling the myth that the masonry beds were unusually small or uncomfortable, and further illustrates the point that the brothel's evidence should be analysed with similar material regardless of the context of findspot.
Ch. 2 addresses the material finds, highlighting the difficulties due to problematic excavation and recording techniques. The result is that it is unclear what form some items took, and due to subsequent loss/degradation they can no longer be examined. Nonetheless, the finds reveal aspects of food and drink consumption and grooming and bodily care, both of which were presumably available for a price. Additional items such as perfume/cosmetic vials may be indicative of gift exchange between clients and prostitutes. L. includes finds from the street in her analysis, which has not been done previously, as it is likely they fell from the upper floor when the roof collapsed during the eruption.
Ch. 3 covers the graffiti — the largest collection of scratched texts in a single context in Pompeii. Contrary to preconceptions that these are entirely erotic in nature, many are simply names and greetings, the interpretation of which has previously been eroticised because of the findspot. The messages on the walls vary in content and demonstrate an active writing culture among even those of lower class or servile origin. The wall paintings and decorative scheme are considered in ch. 4, which compares the erotic panel paintings with others in the city. By doing this, L. demonstrates that the images in the brothel depict relatively chaste normative heterosexual acts and are not as graphic as those found in public baths and private homes. The upper level of the structure is dealt with in ch. 5, outlining previous theories as well as the evidence that makes this level different from the ground floor, including access points, size of rooms, decorative scheme and evidence for doors that could be locked.
Part Two examines the lives, interactions, and agency of clients (ch. 6), female prostitutes (ch. 7), and male prostitutes (ch. 8). L. explores what the evidence demonstrates about bodily care, consumption of wine, interactions and relationships in the graffiti, and the type of clients and prostitutes that may have frequented the brothel. In addition, she examines aspects the evidence does not prove but which logic dictates — instances of self-care, the visibility of prostitutes in the urban landscape when fetching water, and the development of relationships in order to better one's situation. Using this analysis, L. concludes that the purpose-built brothel offered more than sex — a whole sexual experience that included drink, conversation, interaction with others and time to record the visit on the wall. For this reason, she theorises that this may have been a failed business model, and this may account for the lack of another example of this exact type of building in the Roman world.
The book is well illustrated with numerous useful plans that help the visualisation of the brothel through representations of sight lines for individual rooms, the erotic panel paintings, clusters of graffiti and visibility from the street. It also contains coloured plates of the wall paintings, graffiti and the building itself. Two appendices, of the daily excavation reports and finds and the graffiti, follow. The collection of both textual and figural graffiti, sequenced by location, is particularly useful. My only quibble is that the entries of the daily excavation logs are not translated from the Italian, which renders this section inaccessible to Anglophone undergraduate students.
Ultimately, this book is praiseworthy not just for its content and new interpretations, but even more so for the methods that L. employs by going back to the evidence, assessing each type of evidence in its place in the larger Pompeian (and more generally, Greco-Roman) context rather than being swayed by pre-existing interpretations. This is a model which we all should adopt, particularly those of us working in areas which have been subject to the moral and intellectual judgement of modern societies. Women, non-normative sex, eroticism, sex work and members of the servile and lower classes are all prone to preconceptions and moral judgements in the scholarship, and L.'s evidentiary, factual and comparative handling of the material heralds a new and very welcome approach.
