This edited collection by Prabhakar Singh (Jindal Global Law School, India) and Benoît Mayer (Institute of International Law, Wuhan University), two young critical legal scholars, seeks to contribute to the already burgeoning scholarship on critical approaches to international law specifically from a post-modern trajectory. Their approach focuses on how international law is an historically conditioned discourse that projects onto the international legal arena the basic precepts of a positivist system of universal international law that reflects a consensus amongst states. The critical impulse that guides this collection is an examination of the heterogeneous, disparate, and conflicting accounts of international law. These have been famously revealed in Anthony Anghie’s argument that difference, and engagement with the “Other” has been partly constitutive of the basic doctrines of international law.Footnote 1 The collection sustains the challenge posed by critical legal scholars that international law contains a fictional account of universality and masks more than it reveals.
This collection is stitched together by a very loose thread—a challenge to state-centric accounts of international law. The contributors re-vision international law as a more complex account of three areas largely neglected by mainstream international law: post-realism, post-colonialism, and transnationalism. The intention is to complicate understandings of international law, and bring out the vibrancy of contemporary critical debates within these three substreams. Post-realism addresses the tensions that exist between international law and international politics. It takes account of the power relations that operate at intimate levels in international law. The articles in this section analyze the dispersed role of power that flows unevenly in multiple directions that cannot be accounted for through a state-centric focus. The segment on post-colonialism demonstrates how international law has been complicit with the processes of Empire and colonial rule. It examines how international law as well as human rights, far from promoting freedom, have a dark side that is revealed through their encounters with difference. In the final segment of the collection, transnationalism through international investment law is presented as a central form of global governance where collective expertise is depended upon to protect the interests of investors from the failings of local laws through prior investment awards.
This brief review focuses on the postcolonial segment of the book that presents some intellectually engaging and provocative contributions. International law’s encounters with the “Other” manifested in terms of violence whether in the context of slavery, cultural genocide, as well as dispossession of the colonial subject. These “practices” were all managed and facilitated through treaties, concepts of limited sovereignty, terra nullius, and conquest, as well as through a civilizational discourse (Anghie, pp. 127–128).Footnote 2 As Anghie argues, the exporting of violence to the colonies through international law does not find reference in positivist accounts of international law. He argues that European states denied sovereignty to non-European states through a civilizational discourse, through which “the Other” was denied sovereign status. Similarly, Mark Toufayan presents a critical account of Upendra Baxi’s work on human rights, where he has argued that these were not gifts from the West, but emerged from below, from people in struggle, and that the dominant historical narratives have silenced or excluded these alternate histories.Footnote 3 As Toufayan points out, while Baxi does not explain how human suffering can be made legible and grieveable in human rights or whether grassroots are always constituted by progressive voices, his work is a major contribution to the development of Third World Approaches to International Law (TWAIL). The dark side of human rights finds little space in dominant accounts, where the injustices produced by the global war on terror, Guantanomo or Bagram, do not call for accountability but are justified through a security discourse that projects the West as defending “civilization” and liberal values.
While the essays are at times a bit unwieldy and could have been improved through more rigorous editing, the collection makes an important contribution to the relevance of critical international law, especially within an Asian context where the relationship between markets, non-state actors, and post-colonial states has been a feature of global governance for the past five hundred years. State-centric notions of international law do not capture how former colonialized nations understood or engaged with international law. Its formative features were crafted on the anvil of a civilizational divide, where the non-European was deliberately and effectively excluded from international law and the family of nations. Not only was civilizational achievement a primary criterion for colonial nations to secure freedom, but the European powers refused to take on board how this divide was constitutive of international law as a discipline and practice as well as integral to global governance.
