A professor emeritus of history at Baruch College and the Graduate Center of the City University of New York, Stanley Buder has published a comprehensive history of American business from colonial times to the present day. “Capitalizing on change is America’s genius,” Buder writes; and his volume stresses how U. S. firms have both shaped and been shaped by national and international economic, political, and social changes (p. ix). “The unifying theme of this study,” Buder declares, “is the interactive roles of business and government in advancing and occasionally blocking changes” (p. x). Perhaps. But, Buder repeatedly favors the importance of entrepreneurship over developmental and regulatory actions of the government in his account of the shaping the business system of the United States.
Buder divides his work into three parts, each about the same in length. Part One, “Foundations of a Modern Economy,” consisting of seven chapters, provides a survey of the evolution of American business from colonial times through the nineteenth century. Setting the growth of colonial and early national businesses in the context of global expansion of trade, Buder generally dismisses American exceptionalism but concludes, nonetheless, that “America from the start offered the seeds of capitalism a uniquely fertile soil” (p. 50). Chapters examining the onset of industrialization and the rise of big business follow. Buder generally follows historian Alfred D. Chandler, Jr. in stressing the importance of technological innovations (such as the railroad) and the development of a large interior national market as leading to the growth of large vertically integrated firms; but he also emphasizes the importance of entrepreneurship, devoting a chapter to Andrew Carnegie, John D. Rockefeller, and J. P. Morgan. Part Two, “From Theodore Roosevelt to Reagan,” made up of five chapters, places more emphasis on the varied roles government played in business development. Two chapters examine the Progressive Era, with Buder concluding, “A decisive shift to a mixed system of public and private controls over the American economy occurred in the years 1901 to 1914” (p. 220). Chapters on the 1920s and 1930s examine the growth of consumerism and the importance of consumer durables to the American economy, along with a heightened importance of the government during the New Deal. The significance of government continued, Buder shows, into the early 1970s. Part Three, “The Turn of the Millennium,” composed of three narrative and three thematic chapters—one on small business, another on globalization, and a third on the social responsibility of business—brings the story of the strengths and weaknesses of American business into the early twenty-first century. In perhaps the most original section of his work, Buder capably dissects such topics as corporate restructuring, downsizing, outsourcing, and deregulation.
Capitalizing on Change has important strengths and several weaknesses. Buder is at his best in relating changes in businesses to social and cultural alterations in the United States and abroad. Buder almost always places American developments in their appropriate global contexts. In his description of early industrialization in the United States, for example, he makes valuable references to developments in Great Britain and other countries. Readers of this journal may find Buder’s cogent discussions of mercantilism, classical liberalism (as espoused by Adam Smith), Keynesianism, monetarism, and other versions of economic thought to be of particular value. Useful end notes guide readers to additional sources of information. On the more negative side of the ledger, Buder’s stress on interactions between business and society leads him to shortchange how companies actually operated in different time periods. How did colonial merchants conduct business? What were counting houses? Precisely how did owners and mangers of the new large nineteenth-century firms organize and run their businesses? Buder’s decision to relegate, for the most part, the history of small business to a topical chapter near the end of his work is unfortunate, for it deprives readers of a sense of the evolving complexity of business developments over time. No maps, figures, or diagrams, and only a few illustrations, grace this volume. While most business and economic historians will find little that is startlingly new in Capitalizing on Change, those entering those fields may find this volume a useful introduction.
