As Fiona Palmer reminds us in her wide-ranging study, the four decades before the first World War saw the role of conductor, then barely half a century old, undergo a transformation. At a time of increasing specialization, it witnessed both the final decline – but not extinction – of the long tradition of composers doubling as conductors, and the replacement of ‘time-beating conducting’ by a new ‘personality-led, interpretive approach’ (p. 90). The modern age of orchestral performance had arrived, and recognition of this change can be seen in the expansion of the one-page entry ‘Conductor’ in the first edition of Grove’s A Dictionary of Music and Musicians (1878) into an eight-page article, ‘Conducting’, in the second edition (1904). As though to acknowledge that the role had come of age, several of Palmer’s subjects penned their thoughts on the topic. Dan Godfrey, conductor of the Bournemouth Municipal Orchestra, observed that ‘the British conductor … is a [comparatively] new factor in our musical life … [and] the interpreter conductor, is largely a product of the twentieth century’ (p. 262). Alongside this professionalization of the role went demands for the provision of training for would-be conductors. Frederic Cowen, who, like his colleagues, had acquired his skills ‘through experience and observation’ (p. 265), called for colleges to provide lessons at a time when only Trinity College of Music did so: not until after the First World War, by which time British conductors had finally achieved parity with their European counterparts, and their specialism recognized (to quote Cowen) as ‘perhaps the greatest, as it was the most subtle, of all the executive branches of music’ (p. 264), did this become the norm. It is on the emergence and acceptance of this new type of conductor that Palmer focuses.
Her method has been to select eight conductors born over an almost 70-year period – Julius Benedict (b. 1804), William Cusins (b. 1833), Joseph Barnby (b. 1838), Arthur Sullivan (b. 1842), Alexander Mackenzie (b. 1847), Frederic Cowen (b. 1852), Dan Godfrey (b. 1868) and Landon Ronald (b. 1873) – and to pair them chronologically, subjecting each pairing to a ‘compare and contrast’ treatment. One of the pairings is used to represent each of the book’s four decades, while her choice of subjects allows her to focus on different spheres of music-making, both in London and elsewhere. The Philharmonic Society in the capital features most prominently, in the hands of Cusins, Cowen, Mackenzie and, briefly, Sullivan, while orchestral music in the provinces is represented by Benedict (in Liverpool and Norwich), Godfrey (Bournemouth), and Ronald (Blackpool and Birmingham). Such an approach has allowed her to cast her net widely and draw in figures whose contemporary significance has since been eclipsed: the almost-forgotten Cusins, for example, or the renowned choral conductor Barnby rather than the better-known Stanford. That all eight subjects were also composers reminds us of how much change there has been since the early 1900s, when very few conductors did nothing else. To gain an idea of the type of varied ‘portfolio’ career they formerly enjoyed one only has to look at local or regional music-making, where a mixture of performing, conducting, teaching, and composing or arranging, provides a livelihood for many.
Palmer’s first chapter, ‘The Context’, provides a concise survey of conducting in England, from the first use of a baton by Spohr at the Philharmonic Society in 1820 to the mid-1860s. Although Spohr’s lead was followed by others, the existing practice, whereby control was shared by a ‘conductor’ (at the keyboard) and the leader (the first violinist), was slow to die out, with the first provincial performance of Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony, in Leeds in 1843, directed jointly J.D. Loder (the leader) and S.S. Wesley (at the piano). But as scores became more complex such dual control became no longer tenable and there were calls for one man to assume undivided command. The first to achieve this goal was Michael Costa, who exchanged the keyboard for the baton in 1833. On taking over the direction of the Philharmonic Society for the 1846 season he insisted on a similar arrangement, which allowed him to impose an unprecedented degree of control over his players, with impressive results. A decade later two conductors whose performances would become benchmarks for excellence, August Manns and Charles Hallé, began working at the Crystal Palace and in Manchester respectively, and their example would contribute to the development of a native school of conducting. Significantly, both were German-born, but by the end of the century native conductors would rival the skill and popularity of those from overseas.
In 1867 the Philharmonic Societies of London and Liverpool both had vacancies for a conductor. The former appointed William Cusins, the latter a man almost 30 years his senior, Julius Benedict. Both, as Palmer notes, were very much men of their time and generation – musical all-rounders, for whom conducting was but one of several activities (see pp. 48–56). Benedict is still remembered for his opera The Lily of Killarney, but his reputation as a conductor died with him. Similarly, for over a century Cusins’ 16 years at the helm of the Philharmonic Society seemed destined to remain in oblivion, but the publication in 1995 of Cyril Ehrlich’s First Philharmonic drew attention to what he described as ‘a long run of mediocre … seasons’ under Cusins’ baton. In reaching his verdict (as Palmer points out, pp. 76–8) he drew almost exclusively on the generally critical reviews in The Athenaeum, disregarding the more positive notices elsewhere. Palmer, who acknowledges his advice and encouragement, tactfully begs to differ, noting his over-reliance on critical reviews and refuting his claim that there was ‘no evidence that he [Cusins] had ever conducted a professional orchestra in public’ before his appointment (p. 53). He had done so regularly since 1860.
One cannot escape, however, the suspicion that Cusins’ ‘advancement … was assisted by his particularly useful connections’ (p. 55). These included an uncle who was Master of The Queen’s Music, a position he would later ‘inherit’, and his ‘insider’ position as one of the Directors of the Philharmonic Society at the time of his appointment as conductor. The latter certainly was not handled as one would expect today. Although he did not vote, the vacancy was discussed at meetings at which he was present and, given the consensus that the appointment should be given to an Englishman, the decision to offer him the position was more or less a foregone conclusion. At Liverpool, in contrast, applications were invited, 21 names were considered, and a shortlist of three was drawn up. But there was one major difference between application processes then and now: it was not deemed necessary that candidates should demonstrate their expertise in front of an orchestra. Instead, the most pressing matters on the committee’s mind were two questions – whether residence in the town should be required, and whether the successful candidate should be responsible for both orchestra and chorus.
Discussing the appropriateness of the two men for their respective posts, Palmer observes that each ‘fitted their Philharmonic institutions as conductors partly because of their practical apprenticeships, combined musical experience as composers, educators, performers, administrators and conductors’ (pp. 91–2). In an age of ‘generalists’ the same could be said of her second pair, Joseph Barnby and Arthur Sullivan. While Sullivan needs little introduction, his work as a conductor is far less well-known. Yet he was much sought-after and held such desirable posts as conductor of the triennial music festival in Leeds, and, for two seasons, of the Philharmonic Society concerts in London. His fellow subject, Joseph Barnby, is little-known today, his name kept alive by the part-song ‘Sweet and low’ and a few Anglican chants and hymn tunes. As Palmer demonstrates, he deserves better.
Unlike the German-born Benedict and Cusins, Sullivan and Barnby shared a similar educational background: both studied at the Royal Academy of Music, where Barnby was runner-up when Sullivan won the Mendelssohn Scholarship in 1856. Appointed music adviser to Novello, Ewer & Co. in 1861, Barnby founded the Novello-sponsored ‘Mr. Barnby’s Choir’ which in 1872 merged with the Royal Albert Hall Choral Society; the combined choir was later re-named the Royal Choral Society, and it remained in Barnby’s hands until his death in 1896. His choice of repertoire was wide-ranging and included a number of new works, both British and foreign, as well as the first London performance of Bach’s St Matthew Passion (1871). Contemporary compositions included Verdi’s Requiem (1877) and Dvorak’s Stabat Mater (conducted by the composer in 1884) and Requiem (1890). But the most surprising was Parsifal, which received two concert performances in 1884, only two years after its premiere. That Wagner’s final opera should have been introduced to English audiences by a man remembered for a part-song is one of those paradoxes which illuminate the recesses of music history! Barnby, who was renowned for the care he took in rehearsing and for his ability to coax such fine results from his singers, had attended all ten performances at the previous year’s Bayreuth Festival and the hard work paid off. The Times declared that his name ‘will always be connected with one of the most memorable events [in] the history of English music (The Times, 17 November 1884, 10)’. Henry Wood was another fan: ‘I admired him intensely … he possessed in far greater degree than any other conductor I have ever met, the ability to obtain phrasing, expression, diction and tone-colour from his choirs’ (pp. 111–12).
Not the least valuable aspect of Palmer’s study is its wide-ranging remit, embracing reception history, and financial and economic matters. Among the economic discussions is a brief examination of the Royal Choral Society’s concert takings, which graphically demonstrates the level of cross subsidy necessary to support Barnby’s excursions into unfamiliar territory. The most-performed work and the best seat-filler was Messiah, heard over 60 times between 1873 and 1896. In eight out of the ten years listed it was responsible for the highest and second-highest takings for the season, while the widest disparity between highest and lowest receipts was in the 1889–90 season when two performances of Messiah brought in £1196-10-11 (i.e. £1196-55 in decimal currency) while the Belgian composer Pierre Benoit’s 1865 oratorio Lucifer yielded only £9-15-8 (£9-78).Footnote 1 It was not, however, Handel, but Sullivan’s The Golden Legend which attracted the largest audiences in the 1886–87 and 1887–88 seasons, when it brought in £1498-9-10 (£1498-49, for two performances) and £1197-1-5 (£1197-12) respectively.
The Golden Legend had been premiered in 1886 at Leeds, where Sullivan conducted the triennial Festivals from 1880 to 1898. Unlike Barnby, whose work with the Royal Choral Society continued uninterrupted season after season, Sullivan conducted less regularly and was more typical of the type of composer-conductor of the 1860s or 70s. Certainly by the 1880s his habit of directing (as Hanslick wrote) ‘from a deep armchair, using his right hand to mark the time, resting his left-hand, gazing only at the score’ (p. 121) appeared anachronistic and contributed to the sense that his conducting lacked animation. The 1898 festival would be his last, and even had death not intervened, it is unlikely that he would have returned in 1901. The other major conducting appointment he held was at the Philharmonic Society (1885–87), where his resignation was followed by a debate about who should replace him, and whether a successor should be sought from abroad.
For some years the spectre of German-speaking conductors had been hovering in the background. Widely considered to be the masters of their art, they included Hans von Bülow and Hans Richter, both of whom first visited the British Isles in the 1870s. After the former had conducted in Glasgow in 1877 it was reported that ‘From the opening to the closing bar he made everybody feel what it was to have a real conductor at the head of affairs’ (p. 29). Richter created a similar impression. Two years later, after his first London concert, The Examiner informed its readers that the ‘universal verdict … is that Herr Richter is by a long way the greatest of living instrumental conductors’ (p. 31, my italics). Who was considered the greatest choral conductor? Barnby? It was against such a background of a growing foreign presence that British conductors had increasingly to compete. Following Sullivan’s unexpected resignation Richter, Brahms, von Bülow, Rubinstein and Joachim were all approached, but declined. Only then was the position offered to Cowen. Eleven years younger than Sullivan, he sought greater autonomy and more rehearsal time, and he argued against the established practice of inviting composers to conduct their own work. His relationship with the society was not always easy, and headstrong behaviour forced his resignation after five years. Palmer pairs Cowen with Mackenzie, another active composer, but one whose creative instincts pulled in the opposite direction: whereas Cowen sought recognition as a conductor, for Mackenzie (who had recently been appointed Principal of the RAM) composition was paramount, and lack of time for this was a factor in his own resignation in 1899. Cowen, surprisingly, took up the reins again but, although considered to be ‘among the comparatively few masters of a difficult craft’ (p. 184), his perceived status as a part-time ‘composer-conductor’ left him unable to compete with visiting (foreign) conductors who had greater box office appeal. Nonetheless, as Palmer notes, his attempts to improve standards, to raise ‘awareness of the value of technical training’, and to achieve ‘clearer authority in his roles’ were ‘perhaps more significant than historiographical understandings have suggested (p. 196)’.
Although Mackenzie and Cowen both lived long after World War I, their conducting careers were by then over. Not so the final pair, Godfrey and Ronald, who worked well into the mid-twentieth century. Limitations of space preclude more than a passing reference to such topics as Ronald’s early involvement with the Gramophone Company, or his work in Birmingham – ‘Ronald and the Birmingham Promenade Concerts (1905–1914)’ – which makes for an interesting comparison with Godfrey’s work in Bournemouth, home of the only municipally supported orchestra in the country.
As the copious and detailed footnotes and references demonstrate, Palmer has drawn upon a vast quantity of source material, including the archives of the various organizations discussed and scrapbooks relating to Barnby, Godfrey and Ronald, and she has skilfully used it to give substance and add detail to her narrative. The result is a masterly survey of the 40-year evolution of the role of conductor from that of a ‘time-beating’ part-timer (often with his head in the score) to that of a specialist, able to conduct from memory and to ‘interpret’ the music for the benefit of the audience. En route she not only provides valuable reassessments of her eight subjects, with Barnby and Cowen being particular beneficiaries, but also incorporates details of the musical-sociological background against which the story unfolds, thereby adding much to the book’s interest and value. One feels, too, that as a former orchestral musician she brings an insider’s knowledge to her task. Whilst the concept of devoting each chapter to two subjects carries a risk of frequent criss-crossing from one to the other, this is handled well. Slightly more problematic is the manner in which certain topics – notably the Philharmonic Society – are divided between several chapters. But given that Palmer’s focus is the conductors, not the institutions for which they worked, this is inevitable and no great drawback. Handsomely produced (though my copy would not stay open), well indexed and remarkably accurate – I only noted three mistakes: two quotations attributed to twentieth century issues of the Musical World (which ceased publication in 1891), and receipts from Messiah in January 1893 (p. 114) recorded as £640-18-12 (pre-decimal accounts would not show a figure of 12d). Stanford wrote that ‘The best judgement of a conductor is formed by sitting in front of him, not at his back’ (p. 267) and one suspects that Palmer’s years as a performer have contributed to the success of this warmly recommended book.
