In a doctoral exam shortly after the publication of Eric Foner's Reconstruction: America's Unfinished Revolution, 1863–1877, a professor asked, “What are the beginning and ending dates of Reconstruction?” The student, hoping to make a good impression, replied that the logical ending date seemed to be 1877, although that obviously could be debated, but that the process of Reconstruction really had begun at the moment the Union was no longer intact, during the secession winter. The query and response speak to an important issue of American history: naming and determining eras and periods. Slavery was, as Abraham Lincoln said, “somehow” the cause of the Civil War, whether on moral or political or economic or legal or sociocultural or racially ideological grounds, and the Thirteenth Amendment ended the institution as it was then known. But the issue, in all of its permutations, remained unresolved—and remains so now, if the racial components of opposition to President Barack Obama and the existence of the hashtag #blacklivesmatter are any indication.
Gregory Downs and Kate Masur have brought together a group of scholars to assess different ways of considering, as the book is entitled, The World the Civil War Made. The book is a set of fourteen essays rooted in a conference on new directions of Reconstruction at the George and Ann Richards Center at Penn State. It is a tribute to the editors, the authors, and the other organizers of the conference that perhaps the major point of their discussion was whether what they call “the period formerly known as Reconstruction” actually existed—or, more to the point, whether thinking of the Civil War as flowing into Reconstruction and of the era as ending in 1877 is intellectually useful or, in fact, constricting. The result is an often enthralling, always thought-provoking collection that scholars and students should and will reckon with for years to come.
Downs and Masur begin with an introduction that offers a new term for understanding the time: not Richard Franklin Bensel's “Yankee Leviathan” but, instead, a “Stockade State.” They define this as “a collection of outposts—both military and civilian—powerful within narrow geographic boundaries but limited in their reach, sometimes capable of enforcing their will, sometimes overpowered, and almost always beset by both competing power centers and individuals who sought to live beyond the reach of most authority. The authors' sensitivity to the government's enduring vulnerability represents a break from prevailing scholarship on Reconstruction, which has often assumed that the state could ultimately have asserted its will over society” (6–7).
All of the essays are well written, well researched, and well argued—some more than others, as is inevitable in any such collection. What readers will find most appealing will depend on their particular interests. Several essays focus on the West, part of the “Greater Reconstruction” that such scholars as Elliott West and Heather Cox Richardson have promoted. Stacey Smith's analysis of peonage and Chinese exclusion, Stephen Kantrowitz's discussion of Native American citizenship, C. Joseph Gentin-Pilawa's assessment of Senecan Ely Parker, and Barbara Krauthamer's probe of Indian Territory and treaties suggest broader perspectives on the perceptions and fate of freedpeople everywhere.
Others take different approaches to more traditional topics. How federal, state, and local governments functioned—and failed to function—receives attention in the chapter by Laura Edwards, who puts Reconstruction in the perspective of the history of governance; Amanda Claybaugh's examination of novels about Washington, D.C.; Crystal Feimster's analysis of African American women's quest for “sexual justice and citizenship”; and Amy Dru Stanley's commentary on how emancipation shaped the discourse on human rights. K. Stephen Prince's study of ruins in the South, Luke Harlow's explanation of the impact of proslavery religion, Kidada Williams's poignant look at the trauma left by violence against African Americans, and Andrew Zimmermann's explication of how Karl Marx and Communism reflected developments in the United States provide new or provocative ways of looking at subjects that historians sometimes have delved into in considerable depth, or have left ripe for the historiographical picking. Steven Hahn's afterword assesses the chapters that came before while offering alternative interpretations, including that the Civil War “and its specific outcome in my view dramatically reoriented the axes of power and the formation of social classes in the United States, redefined the nature and boundaries of governance, redirected the course of economic development, reconstituted the body politic, and extended the international revolutionary dynamic that appeared to have ended with the revolutions of 1848, reconfiguring the platform of international relations, especially as regards the Pacific (we make a mistake if we view the war and its impact chiefly as an Atlantic event)” (340).
No essay collection, much less history book, can do it all. Since this book leaves the reader wanting more of everything, what is also striking is what is missing. In focusing as much as they do on the South and the West, these contributions address the North's impact on those regions, but say comparatively little about their impact—and the war's—on the North. While several authors refer to continuity and change during and after the Civil War, they might have thought more about links—and broken chains—to the antebellum world than those mentioned. For example, amid parallels to European and Marxian revolutions before and after the war, the United States went through an Industrial Revolution and a wave of reforms ranging from abolitionism to women's rights and geographical expansion in the first half of the nineteenth century; how those movements related to the postbellum and revolutionary world, if they did, merits additional consideration, as does how the formation of this new or different American nation-state was similar to and different than the evolution of Italy and Germany, and post-emancipation Russia, in the same era.
But none of this is meant to dismiss the editors or authors. They packed a great deal of information and insight into this book, and anyone who reads it will profit from it, and welcome or possibly lament how it forces them to think and rethink so much. The World the Civil War Made will always look different, thanks to the book these historians have made.
