A Faithful Sea is a welcome contribution to the growing list of recent publications exploring the notion of the Mediterranean as a region and a historical space (see, e.g., Peregrine Horden and Nicholas Purcell, The Corrupting Sea: A Study of Mediterranean History, David Abulafia, ed., The Mediterranean in History, and W. V. Harris, ed., Rethinking the Mediterranean). By focusing on cross-religious and cross-cultural encounters in the medieval and early modern Mediterranean, this collection goes further than any other recent work in demonstrating how these encounters defined the Mediterranean and affected the involved parties. It also integrates religion into the study of Mediterranean history in a novel and refreshing way.
In his thought-provoking introduction to the volume, coeditor Adnan Husain sets up the theoretical framework of the collection and lays out an ambitious research agenda for the coming generations of scholars. Husain embraces Braudel's notion of the “Mediterranean of the historian” as a space that extends beyond the sea's immediate shores. He argues that scholars' tendencies to view the Mediterranean exclusively either as a space of encounter and interaction or in terms of its geographic and environmental features do not do justice to its role as a historical space. Rather, these approaches need to be integrated into a historical perspective that appreciates the shared dimensions of recognizably distinct cultures and religions as well as interaction among “their changing expressions, identities and traditions” (p. 5). This new scholarship, according to Husain, has to meaningfully engage the notion of “religious culture,” which he defines as the “living, historical experience and diverse practices of Muslims, Christians, and Jews” (p. 6).
The author suggests that “what renders the Mediterranean zone unique might be [the] long durée of interreligious contact, interchange, and even competition” among constantly evolving Muslim, Jewish, and Christian traditions throughout the medieval and early modern eras (p. 6). However, in order to study the Mediterranean in this way, it is not sufficient simply to diagnose and celebrate the encounters or settle for studying isolated moments and spaces of interaction through anthropological typologies of religious practice (such as shrine visitation) or economic contact. Rather, it is necessary to explore how historically specific contacts across religious boundaries changed the religious cultures in question.
Husain makes a particularly strong plea for a more consistent effort to integrate Islam, and especially the Ottoman Empire, into the study of the medieval and early modern Mediterranean. However, it is in this mission that this volume most notably falters. Although the Ottoman Empire is addressed in valuable contributions by K. E. Fleming, Molly Greene, and Ariel Salzmann, it functions mostly as a backdrop for case studies told from the vantage point of Jewish, Greek Orthodox, and Catholic historical actors, respectively. None of the essays in the book directly explore Muslim experiences of religious interaction or the changes these interactions prompted within Muslim communities in either the medieval or early modern eras. In addition to the Ottoman Empire, particularly noticeable is the absence of essays on the Iberian peninsula. Given the centrality of these regions to the scholarship on long-term interreligious contact, their omission seems strange in a collected volume dedicated to this issue.
That being said, we are still left with an engaging, erudite, and reader-friendly collection of essays that will undoubtedly become a staple reading for courses in Mediterranean history and beyond. One of the leitmotifs of the book, which successfully captures some of the desiderata highlighted by Husain, is how trade and commerce affected religious cultures as they came into contact. John Tolan explores the impact of the Christian–Muslim trade in arms and foodstuffs on the Latin community in Tunis in the 1230s, demonstrating how the commercial interests of the Italian and Catalan merchants in some cases influenced the legal decisions of the papacy and the designation of what constituted sins worthy of excommunication. Ann McClanan shows that the trade in relics between Siena and Byzantine Constantinople in the 1350s affected the choice of and depiction of religious motifs by Siennese artists. Margaret A. Pappano suggests that Florentine–Ottoman commercial relations in the 15th century accounted for some interesting ambiguities in the representation of the “Turk” in a contemporary version of a popular romance. Finally, Molly Greene demonstrates how the competition for Greek labor and commercial services in the Ottoman–Venetian contact zone in the 16th century caused a sort of “Ottomanization” of Catholic Venice as it granted the Orthodox Greeks communal autonomy similar to the dhimma pact they had in the Ottoman Empire.
Another recurring theme of the volume is the role of Mediterranean islands and the related notion of insularity. In her essay on literary history of Lucera, the city in south Italy where Fredrick II resettled the Muslim population of Sicily in the 1220s, Karla Mallette argues that this population transfer gave the Sicilian Muslims cohesiveness that they would have otherwise lost and isolated them from the surrounding Christian population, thus preventing coexistence and the possibility of cultural understanding. Kate E. Fleming highlights 16th-century Venetian Crete, where Venetian colonial politics, Orthodox Christian eschatological traditions and sacred Jewish history led a local Romaniote rabbi to embrace the Ottoman sultan as the messiah—a view starkly different from that of a Sephardic rabbi from Ottoman Selanik. In her essay, Molly Greene also explores the role of Crete as a Venetian colony and of the local Greek community in cultural mediation and commercial competition between the Ottomans and Venetians in the 16th-century Mediterranean. Ariel Salzmann, in contrast, shows how the Catholic ecclesiastical administrators on the islands of Malta and Cyprus complicated the political geography of the Mediterranean by acting as sort of immigration checkpoints and halfway houses for confessional projects directed from the mainland. By following the itinerary of a Maltese priest turned Muslim in Ottoman Egypt in the late 17th century, Salzmann shows the intimate relation between travel and conversion in the Mediterranean.
The final essay in the book, Steven M. Wasserstrom's “Apology for S. D. Goitein,” stands out from the rest of the contributions by its historiographical nature. It emphasizes the fact that Goitein, although indisputably an Orientalist, was a great admirer of Islamic humanism and believed that Islam was fundamentally informed by Hellenism. This insight dovetails on the theoretical framework of other essays that seem to endorse Richard Bulliet's “case for an Islamo-Christian civilization.” Through a close study of Goitein's work on the Cairo Geniza records and experiences of the Jews in the Islamic world, Wasserstrom's essay also contributes to another leitmotif of the collection, namely, the experience of religious minorities in the religious cultures of medieval and early modern Mediterranean.
