Published online by Cambridge University Press: 26 February 2004
This essay focuses attention on some specific issues related to medicalization versus demedicalization of women's health care.
The intersection of cultural norms, politics, economics, and demographics is especially apparent in the broad area of women's reproductive health care. Included within this rubric are concerns with puberty, pregnancy and childbearing, and menopause. All of these states are normal; no one of these life cycle stages is an illness as illness is usually defined. The Webster-Merriam Dictionary defines illness as “an unhealthy condition of body or mind.” It also relates illness to sickness. Sickness is “ill health,” “a disordered, weakened, or unsound condition,” or “a specific disease.” Puberty, pregnancy and childbearing, as well as menopause, are not unhealthy conditions nor are they specific diseases. Quite to the contrary, these are normal and healthy conditions.
Whereas women's reproductive health cycles have been medicalized, there are several health-related problems women confront that are seen as politically explosive and have, in effect, been demedicalized. In particular, a woman's right to terminate a pregnancy, violence against women, and rape have health care implications and have been excluded from the women's health agenda. There are political reasons that must be understood as one ponders the reasons for such demedicalization.
The question then arises as to why some conditions have been medicalized whereas others have been demedicalized. Also, has the medicalization of women's life cycle stages produced a positive or negative situation for women, or is the answer someplace in the middle? This essay focuses on one specific case of medicalization, pregnancy and child birth, and one case of demedicalization, abortion rights.