In The Wreckage of Intentions, David Alff presents a literary analysis of projects in late Stuart Britain. ‘Projects’ had two connotations. The word project ‘could be used to praise the usefulness of inventions … or condemn untoward schemes contrived to aggrandize their authors at the public's expense’ (p. 3). These dual meanings meant that authors simultaneously disavowed the genre of proposals and the projects of others, while attempting to persuade their audience of their own projects’ merits. To investigate these projects, he studies an array of proposals, uncovering ‘the strategies of rhetorical persuasion, publication, and embodied action that made projection a unique and controversial practice’, and revealing ‘how writers sought to make proposed endeavor seem plausible in the context of the future, and how such argumentation was (and remains) vital to the functions of statecraft, commerce, science, religion, and literature’ (p. 7).
To begin, Alff demonstrates how projectors used specific patterns of rhetoric to persuade readers of the merits of their schemes in either making money or improving society. Engineer Andrew Yarranton, writing during the Restoration, often found that his history as a prominent Roundhead hampered his aspirations. His pamphlet, England's Improvement by Sea and Land, reveals the experiences of a man trying both to participate in a society that rejects him and to rework said society into a place that could better ‘accommodate his ambition’ (p. 17). Project proposals flattered and attempted to engage potential patrons. They used the passive voice, which ‘enable[d] the projector to talk about improvement without hazarding to assign it a grammatical agent or human face’ (p. 46). Critics were framed as enemies of improvement, rather than as critics of Yarranton specifically. While nothing came of his plans, his text provides a window onto the ‘type of writing that tried to realize itself through action’ (p. 58).
To examine the circulation of proposals, Alff uses Aaron Hill's petition for beech oil to become a cheap substitute for olive oil imports. Using this project, Alff traces proposals through the world of print, moving from a patent, to a formal announcement, to a pamphlet, and finally to a book: the manifestation of a project which legitimized it compared to other, more ethereal ones. This chapter is really about the material culture of print, and includes my favourite detail: pamphlets included beech seeds within and ‘offer[ed] directions for breaking the nuts and releasing their oil’ (p. 71), so that the readers of his proposal could see the value of the seeds for themselves. But while ideas could become legitimized through print, they could also be derailed in the same way, a fate that lay in store for Hill's Beech Oil Company, when his opponents took to print to criticize Hill's ambitions. Stock in Hill's business declined and never recovered.
After dealing with two projects that never got off the ground, Alff invites the reader to imagine a project that left ‘the realm of perspective language to remake the actual world’ (p. 90), describing what he calls ‘early modern Britain's most costly, controversial, and transformative [project]: the drainage of the Great Fen’ (p. 93). He chose this project because ‘unlike so many other schemes from the period, it eventually worked’ (p. 93). But, even though it was afterwards heralded as a remarkable achievement, Alff shows that the undertaking was actually tenuous and fraught with many troubles, connected to factors ranging from engineering difficulties, to labour issues, to widespread printed criticism, to sabotage. Yet once it was completed, ‘Drainage [was] poeticized: stripped of its routines, technology, methods, and conflict, and returned to the pristine vision articulated by its earliest exponents’ (p. 113).
Alff moves in a different direction in the final chapters, addressing the influence of projection on ‘capital-L Literature’ (p. 114). He starts with the popular georgic poetry of the early eighteenth century, arguing that ‘projection was a crucial precondition of georgic poetry, its staging and resolution of discord, its conception of a quarriable past and pliant future, and its imagination of rural land as wealth in potential’ (p. 117). Through pairing the poetry of John Philips, Alexander Pope, and James Thomson with agricultural proposals developed in the same time, Alff shows that georgic poems ‘undertook projection in the general sense that they superimposed on reality idealized visions of Britain's heartland’ (p. 118). While they did not necessarily glorify projection, these poems often approved of agricultural production and culture.
This ‘constructive attitude’ towards projection was not universal in British literature, as indicated by the harsher treatment of projectors by satirists. Jonathan Swift in particular offered a memorable critic of projectors in Gulliver's Travels, mocking not only the projects themselves, but the rhetorical language used by projectors. While not the first to critique the rise of projectors, Swift created a protagonist who acts as a projector himself in the context of his journey. While visiting Lagado, Gulliver encounters the Academy of Projectors, whose members were occupied with a number of ‘ridiculous experiments’. Swift's fictional projectors, just like their real-life counterparts, ‘were virtually unanimous in pledging that their enterprises would further the common good’ (p. 159). Anti-project sentiment routinely manifested itself in other works as ‘stock caricatures guilty of professing ambitions beyond their moral ambit and material means’ (p. 165).
While a literary study, The Wreckage of Intentions has much to offer historians. First, through a close study of proposals, Alff shows the specific types of rhetoric used to convince audiences about the legitimacy of projects. Evoking actor-network theory, he demonstrates that the success of a project depended on a number of interrelated factors, which often had little to do with its potential value. Through examining poetry and attire, he shows the cultural impacts of these projects on greater British society. The end result is a rich account of social, economic and agricultural improvement ventures, giving the reader a peek into the era that Daniel Defoe called the ‘Projecting Age’.
