In a 2004 review essay on transnational history published in the pages of this journal, Akira Iriye discussed the ‘internationalisation of scholarship’ and concluded that ‘historians easily cross oceans and traverse national boundaries’.Footnote 1 The books under review here offer a striking example of this internationalisation, not only in their geographical remit but equally in the transnational interests and collaboration of their authors.Footnote 2 Three of them are edited volumes – which, in their showcasing of different approaches, methodologies and topics, are particularly suited to addressing the hybrid nature of cultural diplomacy. Their rich variety of case studies reveals the interplay of micro and macro history, as well as the complex relations between local, national and transnational, as well as between governmental and non-governmental historical actors.Footnote 3 The fourth volume is a jointly authored work by François Chaubet and Laurent Martin that presents a synthetic approach to cultural exchange, the relations between culture and policy and cultural globalisation. Together these recent books represent the evolution of a cultural approach to diplomatic history and international relations, epitomised by an interest in ‘soft power’ and closely shaped by the development of transnational history, entangled history (histoire croisée) and the study of cultural transfers. As such, they allow a more cumulative consideration of the roles and meanings of cultural diplomacy in twentieth-century Europe.
Following a brief historiographical overview of the concept of cultural diplomacy, I will discuss the definitions that scholars have adopted in the four books under review, tracing their intellectual and methodological links in relation to wider historiographical shifts such as the cultural turn or transnational history. I will then analyse the contribution of the books under review to the study of culture, cultural exchange and acculturation, cultural institutions and the Cold War. In conclusion, I will suggest some potential paths for future research and for collaboration between academics and policy makers.
The Challenges of Definition
Surprisingly, none of the books under review chooses to explore either the origins or the first usage of the term ‘cultural diplomacy’. It is important therefore to remember both that the use of arts and culture to serve politics is a well established phenomenon (dating back in some countries to the seventeenth century),Footnote 4 although scholars have begun to prefer the term cultural diplomacy only since the 1990s, previously referring to ‘cultural action’, ‘public diplomacy, ‘propaganda’, ‘external cultural relations’ or ‘external cultural policies’.
The meanings and understandings of cultural diplomacy have been shaped by the evolution of the practices it describes, as well as by national traditions and contexts. In the mid-twentieth century, the field of international relations which had previously mainly focused on economic, military and political issues started to integrate culture; this change had taken place earlier in American historiography, which had initially focused on propaganda and highlighted the pioneering position of France within the field of cultural expansion.Footnote 5 As governmental external cultural politics in European governments became more important after the Second World War, many diplomats penned their own analysis of their experience in the 1970s and 1980s.Footnote 6 These men and women distinguished between government policy and the external cultural relations promoted by nations, groups or individuals, and did not use the term ‘cultural diplomacy’ in their work. Within French historiography the distinction between state intervention and non-governmental cultural action remains strong, as demonstrated for example in Chaubet and Martin's Histoire des Relations Culturelles, where cultural diplomacy is specifically defined as intervention by the state (pouvoirs publics) (6).
One of the key turning points in the historiographical treatment of culture and international relations, which helped historians to move away from the disputed and perhaps less sophisticated term ‘propaganda’, has been the development of a concept of ‘soft power’ defined by Joseph Nye in 1990 as a change in the sources of power from military force to economic growth, education or technology.Footnote 7 Nye considered this ‘indirect way to exercise power’, or ‘co-optive power’ as a means of controlling the behaviour of others and the ability to shape what people want.Footnote 8 In 2004, he developed the concept further:
What is soft power? It is the ability to get what you want through attraction rather than coercion or payments. It arises from the attractiveness of a country's culture, political ideas, and policies. When our policies are seen as legitimate in the eyes of others, our soft power is enhanced.Footnote 9
Soft power differs according to nation and can be exercised within a country as well as through foreign policy. The United States's attractiveness for international students and scholars is, for instance, an important source of soft power. Other sources of attraction can be found in the values of a country, such as human rights and democracy.Footnote 10
Despite Nye's theoretical contributions, the definition of cultural diplomacy remains problematic, and the books under review in this essay offer an opportunity to analyse this issue and to explore potential ways by which scholars and politicians can comprehend such concept. Searching for a Cultural Diplomacy addresses the problem directly, and as such provides a particularly fruitful starting point. As Jessica Gienow-Hecht underlines in her introduction, ‘what complicates the definition of cultural diplomacy is the fact that unlike in other areas of diplomacy, the state cannot do much without the support of nongovernmental actors such as artists, curators, teachers, lecturers and students’ (10). Notwithstanding this challenge, Gienow-Hecht offers not only a valuable historiographical overview of the study of international cultural relations but also a delineation of three schools of thought within the eight contributions to the volume. The first approach she suggests is a traditional one in which culture is defined as ‘an instrument of state policy’ (9), and cultural diplomacy is situated between propaganda and diplomacy. By contrast, the second definition ‘accentuates the use of cultural diplomacy as an instrument to work at the exclusion of politics’ (10). With this perspective, Jennifer Dueck's excellent chapter on Syria and Lebanon under the French Mandate from 1920 until 1945 highlights the paradoxical coexistence of ‘insecurity about the status of French cultural influence’ – which, as she demonstrates, was threatened by local culture as well as by foreign (namely British and American) influence – and ‘an enduring confidence in French cultural superiority’ (138).Footnote 11 Exploring the crossroads between imperialism and non-colonial contexts, Dueck not only emphasises the complex interplay between culture and politics but also the multiple ways in which ‘the Syrian and Lebanese Mandates fell somewhere in between the respective paradigms of cultural diplomacy and the colonial civilizing mission’ (140). The early 1920s was a turning point for many European countries, including Britain and France. At the end of the First World War both nations sought to reduce the use of propaganda within and outside the countries.Footnote 12 In France, proposals emerged which illustrated contemporary concerns with strengthening the efficiency of France's external cultural policies. The new importance given to a more subtle form of cultural expansion impacted on the conduct of cultural policies abroad and formed the basis of the creation of the Service des Oeuvres Françaises à l'Etranger,Footnote 13 France's agency in charge of external cultural policies within the Foreign Office.
The third approach to cultural diplomacy presented in this volume defines it as entirely disconnected from government policies and decisions, and thus as the domain of non-state actors. Here, Annika Frieberg's contribution on non-state diplomacy in the 1960s and 1970s offers the widest interpretation of this definition, tracing the development of a ‘transnational advocacy network’ and emphasising the influence of non-state actors in shaping foreign cultural relations. More specifically, she demonstrates how ‘West German politicians had to take into consideration their own domestic constituencies in developing foreign policy’ (110), particularly the Catholic networks that played prominent roles in furthering German-Polish cultural relations across borders. Frieberg argues convincingly that the relative absence of the state and of strong policies created space for activities led by non-state actors – activities that ultimately shaped cultural relations and policies.
Jennifer Dueck rightly highlights the complex relationship between diplomacy and imperialism, which receives further investigation in the 2012 volume on Cultural Diplomacy and Cultural Imperialism – European Perspective(s). The editors Martina Topić and Siniša Rodin successfully connect two closely related although distinct concepts so as to broaden and refine the definition of cultural diplomacy, and their dense though richly historiographical introduction establishes the framework for subsequent contributions. In the introduction, the editors mostly focus on the definitions of propaganda, nation branding, soft power and public diplomacy. They define cultural imperialism, the other main topic of the volume, as:
the sum of the process by which a society is brought into the modern world system and how its dominating stratum is attracted, pressured, forced, and sometimes bribed into shaping social institutions to correspond to, or even promote, the values and structures of the dominating centre of the system.Footnote 14
Cultural imperialism, as demonstrated by one of the contributors, Margarita Kefalaki, can be experienced within national frameworks such as the métropole (mainland France) in relation to the periphery (in her case Corsica). In her article Kefalaki reflects on the imposition of French language and practices on Corsican populations. Several other chapters also engage with the definition of cultural diplomacy. Atsuko Ichijo argues powerfully that the British Council, by advertising British culture and language, develops public diplomacy on the one hand and cultural diplomacy on the other but refrains from identifying Britain with European culture. She shows that Britain's current policies rely on universal values, freedom and justice. By contrast, the Croatian government has endeavoured to showcase the idea that Croatian national culture and identity are closely linked to European culture, and, as Martina Topić demonstrates, Europeanism has been used to strengthen national Croatian traditions and nation branding. Her contention is that branding Croatia as a deeply European country plays a key role in its marketing, especially to tourists. Overall, this volume is in line with the three schools of thought outlined in Searching for a Cultural Diplomacy and adds to the ongoing reflexion on cultural diplomacy elements borrowed from bordering concepts such as public diplomacy and cultural imperialism. On the one hand, this approach mirrors the difficulty of delineating cultural diplomacy; on the other hand, it is evidence of the editors’ ambition to offer a broad understanding of a concept whose success within twentieth century European politics has relied heavily on its ambiguities and its loose definition. However, by focusing on actors and policies, Gienow-Hecht, Donfried, Topić and Rodin run the risk of losing sight of the principle objective of cultural diplomacy: impacting on a more or less defined audience which is conspicuously absent from many contributions.
The focus on historical actors – governmental or non-governmental, political or cultural – has clearly been central to the debate on definition. Just as important in the study of cultural diplomacy is a focus on processes. This is particularly emphasised by Pascal Ory, one of France's leading cultural historians, in his introduction to International Cultural Relations in the Twentieth Century (Les Relations Culturelles Internationales au XXème Siècle). Offering a synthesis of the methodological challenges faced by scholars in the field of international cultural relations, Ory offers a triple typology that identifies cultural diplomacy with ‘visibility, institutionalisation, and voluntarism’ (18), with cultural exchanges and acculturation, and that also seeks to uncover the actors, processes and consequences of cultural relations. Moving away from the dichotomy between politics and culture, his third approach suggests that time and space (geographical but also socio-economic, as well as cultural) can help historians to describe and explore the multiple facets of cultural relations. This frame of reference has the advantage of including elements which do not play an important role in the definitions elaborated by Gienow-Hecht, Donfried, Topić and Rodin. Notably, Ory's understanding of the field includes an analysis the audience who is targeted by cultural policies and activities as well as, overall, the outcomes (achievements, successes and failures) of cultural diplomacy.
Recent Research: A Thematic Analysis
A cumulative consideration of these four recent volumes – with their extremely wide range of contributions and case studies – makes it possible not only to identify some of the key themes in contemporary research in this area but also to trace their developing trajectories. One of the most important of these themes is the definition of culture itself. In the books under review, all editors, authors and contributors have chosen to adopt a broad definition of culture, which includes not only classical, elite and mass culture, but also cultural production and culture in the anthropological sense of forming the common ground for a community. The importance of expanding the definition of culture is indeed particularly emphasised by Chaubet and Martin in their edited volume History of Cultural Relations in the Contemporary World (Histoire des Relations Culturelles dans le Monde Contemporain).Footnote 15 They claim, for example, that the study of artistic exchanges should not be confined to histories of art or education studies but instead fully integrated into research on international relations, given that these exchanges offer important insights into the multi-layered structures within which the historical actors operate. This approach is part of a larger, recent trend within French historiography which seeks to bridge the gap between cultural studies – which have long been Franco-French centred – and the historiography of international relations – which has been slow to integrate culture within its scope.Footnote 16 What is particularly valuable in Chaubet and Martin's volume is the attention given to the role of mass media and the rise of mass culture industries, which Chaubet discusses in the context of public diplomacy, nation branding and imperialism. In a post-modern theoretical and historiographical analysis, Martin addresses the rise of a global culture or culture-monde, suggesting a twofold shift, ‘the culturalisation of commerce and the commercialisation of culture’,Footnote 17 (197) which relies on the universalisation of norms.Footnote 18 The final shift he suggests is related to time and space. This allows Martin to offer a geographical and chronological differentiation between mondialisation and globalisation, the former described as a longue durée process that started with the humanisation (hominisation) of earth, and the latter characterised as a late twentieth-century phenomenon. He proposes a sharp and interesting typology of four paradigms to encompass cultural globalisation and culture-monde: cultural convergence, new and alternative modernity such as subaltern studies and two theories – cultural imperialism and cultural fragmentation. Furthermore, he also demonstrates how these theories can help establish a dialogue between macro and micro representations and so ensure a more complex and comprehensive understanding of global culture. This notion is further developed in the penultimate chapter of the book through the study of migration, tourism, culture and languages. In short, Chaubet and Martin offer not only a thorough overview of the secondary literature and their own research but also a new definition of culture. Rather than focusing on the traditional humanist and anthropological definitions of the concept, they understand it as a ‘process of interaction’ that can encompass new and hybrid situations.
Although Chaubet and Martin are the most innovative of the authors discussed here in their definition of culture, others have employed their concept of a ‘process of interaction’ – as well as drawing on trends in transnational history and entangled history – as a means to explore cultural exchange and acculturation. The second section of Les Relations Culturelles Internationales au XXème Siècle largely follows this line and looks at cultural exchange – loosely defined as the cultural relationships between individuals and peoples. It is subdivided into two further sections on the internalisation of culture on the one hand and on transfers and acculturation on the other. Themes such as cinema, music and literature offer obvious pathways for considering cultural exchange between nations and are all addressed in this section. Lampros Flitouris, for example, contributes an original and wide-ranging chapter on the changing concepts and processes of cultural diplomacy in post-war Greece, highlighting a loss of prestige for the traditional model of French cultural diplomacy against the backdrop of the Americanisation of European societies. This phenomenon, he argues, represented a new and more efficient means of furthering influence, both socially and culturally, and one which partly relied on the power of the English language, a key challenger of French cultural domination. Given that Anglo-Saxon culture offered a more accessible and possibly more democratised culture, perhaps some of the recent methodological reflections on cultural democratisation proposed by French cultural historians,Footnote 19 and seldom used by historians of international cultural relations, could have helped Flitouris to take his discussion further. The concept of cultural democratisation would, moreover, have presented a valuable approach to the next section on acculturation,Footnote 20 defined by Didier Francfort in the introduction to the section on ‘Transfer and Acculturations’ as ‘the long-lasting adoption of behaviour and ideas from other societies, a phenomenon which becomes invisible over time’.Footnote 21 A focus on cultural democratisation allows historians to reconsider the scale of the phenomena they study in both geographical and social terms – and one could also argue that cultural productions and practices that are available to all offer a favourable background for acculturation.
Studies on cultural exchange and acculturation continue to accord considerable space to national cultural institutions abroad, financed or supported by the states in question, which remain valuable entry points for the analysis of cultural diplomacy. Chaubet, who has written extensively on the Alliance Française, a non-governmental association created in 1883 and aimed at promoting French language around the world, analyses the roles and aims of these institutions in chapter four of Histoire des Relations Culturelles dans le Monde Contemporain. Recently, as Chaubet shows, historians have focused on international cultural organisations, the origins of which he dates back to Leonard Woolf's International Government (1916), followed by the creation in 1922 of the International Commission for Intellectual Cooperation. Novel projects on international organisations and its most emblematic embodiment, the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation (UNESCO), have also been conducted in recent years.Footnote 22
Many of the most powerful recent studies on the role of states and institutions in the field of cultural diplomacy have focused on central Europe and the Soviet Union. In Searching for a Cultural Diplomacy Jean-Francois Fayet and Rósa Magnúsdóttir consider Soviet external cultural policy – which, as they emphasise, was extremely close to propaganda. Both focus (albeit within different periods) on the All-Union Society for Cultural Relations with Foreign Countries (VOKS), once described by E.H Carr as ‘the third dimension of Soviet foreign policy’.Footnote 23 Fayet's particular concern is to reveal how the association promoted both political and cultural soviet propaganda during the interwar period with the aim of infiltrating non-communist communities outside of the Soviet Union. The success of this depended greatly on the ‘host’ country's attitude to communism, the 1917 revolutions and the Russian language, as well as on the nature of diplomatic relations between the Soviet Union and the targeted country. Using the example of the Soviet Red Cross, which was the first institution to be able to work in countries that did not recognised the Soviet Union, Fayet complicates his argument further. He convincingly demonstrates that the Soviet Union intertwined humanitarian diplomacy with a more cultural approach (38). This novel approach to cultural diplomacy should encourage scholars of the two expanding fields of cultural international relations and humanitarianism to reflect on the parallels and dialogues between their areas of study. Fayet also briefly discusses the presence and activities of women within the VOKS, explaining that they became valued for their language skills. The role of women within international cultural relations is one which will hopefully receive further attention within the next decade, following on from recent publication on gender and diplomacy.Footnote 24 Overall, Fayet underlines that the VOKS conveyed increasingly apolitical – and thus more widely acceptable – messages outside of the Soviet Union. Thus, the institution remained a great tool for the Soviet Union precisely because it adopted a slightly more neutral tone. Rósa Magnúsdóttir takes this argument further and shows that Soviet external cultural policies were progressively modernised and reshaped from propaganda into a modern, more neutral form of cultural diplomacy, from 1955 onwards. Magnúsdóttir's article examines the gathering of intelligence and the rebuilding of Soviet-American relations, which, she argues, relied on a necessary familiarisation with American lives on the part of Soviet officials. The article focuses on a Soviet agricultural delegation who travelled to the United States with the aim of improving the outdated knowledge that many Soviets had of the country. The sources used in the article lead the author to present a homogenous analysis of the Soviet delegates’ perspective on their trip to the United States and on their successes in establishing contact with Americans from all social groups. However, the self-congratulatory attitude of Soviet officials towards this trip leaves the reader wondering how American journalists and politicians perceived this tour, and, more generally the Soviet Union's changing attitude towards their country. The second part of the article convincingly reflects on the post-1955 cooperation between Soviet and American officials who came together to rethink the relations between both countries. Overall, the article suggests that in the case of Soviet-American diplomatic relations during the Cold War, culture could offer a surrogate for damaged, blocked political dialogue.
The period of the Cold War continues to attract the attention of cultural historians and historians of cultural diplomacy (defined as state control).Footnote 25 The study of the competing use of propaganda between the Eastern and Western Blocs was given a central position within the historiography of cultural diplomacy and benefited from the widening of the historiographies on diplomatic and Cold War studies.Footnote 26 Today, it is still of great interest for historians – as some chapters in the books under review attest – yet authors tend to nuance the domination of propaganda in the relations between the two blocs. Giles Scott-Smith's contribution to Les Relations Culturelles Internationales au XXème Siècle analyses, for instance, the academic and information programme offered to French US-friendly leaders (politicians and journalists) at a time when the French communist party was seen as a threat in the United States. He shows that contrary to other public policy ventures, the foreign leader project never clashed with propaganda as it ‘allowed visitors to see both the good and the bad sides of the American Dream, trusting that such openness would pay greater dividends, which it generally did.’ In Searching for a Cultural Diplomacy, Anikó Macher – also a contributor to Les Relations Culturelles Internationales – uses her chapter on Hungarian cultural diplomacy in the years following the 1956 revolution to offer a different picture of cultural relations during the Cold War. In particular, she demonstrates that while Hungary had developed its cultural diplomacy prior to the war, propaganda was almost totally excluded from post-1956 practices. After the revolution, cultural diplomacy relied on informal networks, which became progressively more structured after 1959–60. The government, despite Hungary's position as a Soviet satellite state within the wider context of the Cold War, continued to keep its French and Italian cultural institutes open, whereas the French institute in Prague ceased its activities during the Cold War and reopened only after the Velvet Revolution.Footnote 27
Pathways for Future Research and Collaboration
Acculturation is – as we have seen – one of the newest concepts developed by historians of cultural relations and can be richly revealing of the social impact of cultural diplomacy, an aspect undeniably absent from most studies. Both acculturation and imperialism are notions encompassing the cultural changes at work within a nation or a group of people. And, yet, to identify and analyse with appropriate precision those social groups most influenced by cultural policies or exchanges requires further conceptual sophistication, and it is here that the development of a sociological approach to cultural diplomacy would be of particular benefit. Much of the research on cultural diplomacy remains closely linked to institutional history and does not go beyond diplomatic circles or groups formally or informally in charge of carrying cultural activities. Although writing the history of institutions and individuals whose activities have shaped and promoted external cultural policies is a necessary step towards a better understanding of the history of cultural diplomacy, historians needs to look at the receiving ends of these policies. This approach is privileged by too few historians in the books under review; one exception is Olivier Forlin (Les Relations Culturelles Internationales au XXème Siècle), who assesses the success of Italian cinema in France between 1960 and 1980 and who adopts a socio-political approach to analyse the audience of these films. Similarly, articles in the subsection ‘transfers and acculturation’ offer a reflexion on the receiving end of cultural diplomacy. Pierre Bourdieu has revealed the usefulness of such sociological approach in his 2002 article on the social conditions of the circulation of international ideas. Emphasising the social processes at work in the procedures of book exportation – the selections of authors and works, together with translations, marketing, editing and publishing – he argues that these choices reveal many of the specific ambitions of editors regarding the international target audience and its sociology.Footnote 28
Despite a broadening definition of culture, the traditional focus on states and institutions also continues to prevail. This approach dominates the articles in the first part of Les Relations Culturelles Internationales au XXème Siècle and the contributions to Searching for a Cultural Diplomacy. There are, however, a few exceptions, such as Frieberg's article (mentioned above) on non-state actors and the last part of Searching for a Cultural Diplomacy, which is devoted to the role of translators and ‘citizen diplomats’ in Japanese cultural diplomacy. Historians of cultural diplomacy could usefully benefit from a wider use of source material and approaches. In particular, the use of oral history within case studies could valuably expand the history of cultural diplomacy and develop our understanding of how people perceive cultural policies and foreign cultural centres and of how far these impact on communities. It is time for diplomatic historians, as well as scholars of cultural diplomacy, to use their recorders and start listening to and analysing how people on the other side of the spectrum lived and perceived the process of cultural exchange. There are, however, examples of the value of oral history for studies in international relations but these are mostly contained within diplomatic circles. In Britain, the British Diplomatic Oral History Programme (BDOHP) that was created in 1995 by Malcolm McBain, a retired Diplomatic Service officer, certainly throws useful light on the making of diplomacy at government level,Footnote 29 and, more recently, Helen McCarthy's book on women diplomats extensively employs interviews conducted with former female employees working in the diplomatic service.Footnote 30
If a broader range of source material and a greater receptiveness to interdisciplinary approaches would benefit the history of cultural diplomacy, so too would an expanded chronological perspective and a closer attention to the interplay between cultural diplomacy and propaganda. Enlarging twentieth-century studies on European cultural diplomacy to the long nineteenth century would, for example, enable historians to take into account the origins of the institutionalisation of cultural diplomacy, often closely related to both propaganda and imperialism. The study of propaganda itself includes interesting lacunae – for the historiography has consistently neglected French governmental propaganda abroad, whereas German or Soviet propaganda, especially during the Second World War and the Cold War, have been well studied. This may be explained in part by the scale of propaganda within the latter two countries, but as John Horne has shown in State Society and Mobilization in Europe during the First World War, propaganda was used by all Western countries during this period and targeted soldiers, politicians and civilians at both national and international levels, in allied and enemy countries alike.Footnote 31 How can one account for the fact that historians of France have overlooked governmental use of propaganda outside of the country? For whereas the existence of the Maison de la Presse (the Foreign Office body, established in 1916 to gather intelligence, organise and produce propaganda) is acknowledged,Footnote 32 the external actions of this body are not discussed. Perhaps propaganda, a term judged too negative and too closely associated with authoritarian states, is simply not deemed appropriate for the story of cultural diplomacy? The example of Charles Corbin, the French ambassador in London who obtained funding from the Popular Front government to open what he described as the Central Propaganda Service (Service Central de Propagande), is telling. This was to be only a modest project compared to that of Goebbels in Britain.Footnote 33 Strikingly, however, when Corbin's service opened in 1937 its name had been changed to the French Documentation Centre (Centre de Documentation Française) – a title deemed more suitable and deliberately avoiding the term propaganda.Footnote 34 Propaganda, it seems, was to be hidden from contemporaries, and historians of France are clearly reproducing this pattern. But as Dueck reminds us in her chapter on French rule in Syria and Lebanon, propaganda can either be informative or forceful (141). It is therefore essential for future studies to reconsider the concept of French propaganda in allied countries during the two World Wars in order to broaden our understanding of cultural diplomacy, which should not merely be understood only in terms of mutual exchanges and reciprocity between countries.
Cultural diplomacy remains hugely relevant to contemporary politics and society. European countries are constantly reshaping their institutions of cultural diplomacy at both national and European levels, as evident in the key meeting in Brussels in March 2014 on ‘maximizing the impact of cultural diplomacy in European Union (EU) foreign policy’ that was chaired by Androulla Vassiliou, Commissioner for Education, Culture, Multilingualism and Youth. The project proposed at this meeting is to involve EU member states as well as sixteen neighbouring countries and ten ‘strategic partners’, and aims to:
promote better cooperation between Member States and to maximize the added value of European cultural diplomacy. Increased cooperation between cultural institutes and civil society, partnerships between cities and the creation of European ‘creative hubs’ in countries such as China and Brazil . . . to help artists, producers and companies to break into new markets outside the EU.Footnote 35
Transnational cooperation, a concept highlighted in some of the chapters under review, has become the obvious objective for European policy makers. In contemporary analyses of cultural diplomacy scholars could surely play a key role, drawing on their methodological and historical skills to assess the implementation of cultural policies and their impact on international audiences. Clear evidence of this fruitful cooperation has already been offered in the British context with Christopher Hill and Sarah Beadle's March 2014 report on ‘The Art of Attraction: Soft Power and the UK's Role in the World’, and it is to be hoped that this British Academy report will have significant impact on British policy making.Footnote 36 This is obviously an area for further development, where the historian's ability to ‘cross oceans and traverse national boundaries’ can be put to valuable use.
