Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T04:53:47.826Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Wave- and drag-driven subharmonic responses of a floating wind turbine

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 October 2021

Jana Orszaghova*
Affiliation:
Oceans Graduate School and Wave Energy Research Centre, University of Western Australia,WA 6009, Australia
Paul H. Taylor
Affiliation:
Oceans Graduate School and Wave Energy Research Centre, University of Western Australia,WA 6009, Australia
Hugh A. Wolgamot
Affiliation:
Oceans Graduate School and Wave Energy Research Centre, University of Western Australia,WA 6009, Australia
Freddy J. Madsen
Affiliation:
Department of Wind Energy, Technical University of Denmark, Kgs. Lyngby, DK-2800, Denmark
Antonio M. Pegalajar-Jurado
Affiliation:
Department of Wind Energy, Technical University of Denmark, Kgs. Lyngby, DK-2800, Denmark
Henrik Bredmose
Affiliation:
Department of Wind Energy, Technical University of Denmark, Kgs. Lyngby, DK-2800, Denmark
*
†Email address for correspondence: jana.orszaghova@uwa.edu.au

Abstract

The nonlinear hydrodynamic responses of a novel spar-type soft-moored floating offshore wind turbine are investigated via analysis of motion measurements from a wave-basin campaign. A prototype of the TetraSpar floater, supporting a $1:60$ scale model of the DTU 10 MW reference wind turbine, was subjected to irregular wave forcing (with no wind) and shown to exhibit subharmonic resonant motions, which greatly exceeded the wave-frequency motions. These slow-drift responses are excited nonlinearly, since the rigid-body natural frequencies of the system lie below the incident-wave frequency range. Pitch motion is examined in detail, allowing for identification of different hydrodynamic forcing mechanisms. The resonant response is found to contain odd-harmonic components, in addition to the even harmonics expected a priori and excited by second-order difference-frequency hydrodynamic interactions. Data analysis utilising harmonic separation and signal conditioning suggests that Morison drag excitation or third-order subharmonic potential flow forcing could be at play. In the extreme survival-conditions sea state, the odd resonant responses are identified to be drag-driven. Their importance for the tested floater is appreciable, as their magnitude is comparable to the second-order potential flow effects. Under such severe conditions, the turbine would not be operating, and as such neglecting aerodynamic forcing and motion damping is likely to be reasonable. Additionally, other possible drivers of the resonant pitch response are explored. Both Mathieu-type parametric excitation and wavemaker-driven second-order error waves are found to have negligible influence. However, we note slight contamination of the measurements arising from wave-basin sloshing.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.(a) Diagram of the wave basin, with wave gauges (blue) and the model (yellow). (b)  Diagram of the model and (c)  photograph of the experimental set-up. Note that in the spar configuration tested the buoyancy tanks are fully submerged. (d)  Target (solid) and measured (dashed) free-surface variance density spectra $S(\eta )$, together with the floating-system rigid-body natural frequencies $f_{ni}$ (details in tables 1 and 2). Note that the measured spectra are from a wave gauge located at $[x,y]=[5~\text {m},~10~\text {m}]$.

Figure 1

Table 1.Environmental conditions used in the experimental campaign. Sea states are given in terms of significant wave height $H_s$ and peak period $T_p$, with Pierson–Moskowitz spectral shape. Model-scale values are shown in parentheses.

Figure 2

Table 2.Natural periods of the tested system $T_{ni}$, where $i=1, \ldots, 6$ denotes the floater rigid-body motion modes of surge, sway, heave, roll, pitch and yaw, respectively. Values of the natural frequencies $f_{ni} = {1}/{T_{ni}}$ are also given for convenience. Model-scale values are shown in parentheses.

Figure 3

Figure 2.Measured free surface $\eta$ and floater pitch motion $\theta$ time series. (a,b)  Total undisturbed free surface. (c,d)  Total pitch. (e,f) High-pass-filtered (HPF) odd-harmonics signal representing linear wave-frequency pitch motion. (g,h)  Even-harmonics signal (red) and low-pass-filtered (LPF) odd-harmonics signal (blue) both representing subharmonic pitch motion.

Figure 4

Figure 3.Theoretical free-surface variance density spectra $S(\eta )$: (a) Pierson–Moskowitz input spectrum EC5, with linear wavemaking up to 2.5 Hz; and (b) top-hat input spectrum with frequency range $(f_{{min}}, f_{{max}}) = (0.5,~2.5~\text {Hz})$ and $H_s = 0.069~\text {m}$ (same as EC5). Curves shown are: linear free wave spectrum $S^{(1)}$ (black); second-order difference-frequency bound wave spectrum $S^{(2-)}$ (red); second-order sum-frequency bound wave spectrum $S^{(2+)}$ (purple); third-order difference-frequency bound wave spectrum $S^{(3-)}$ (blue); and third-order sum-frequency bound wave spectrum $S^{(3+)}$ (green). Note that only the low- and high-frequency tails of the third-order difference-frequency spectrum $S^{(3-)}$ are shown. The solid green vertical line denotes the pitch natural frequency $f_{n5}$.

Figure 5

Figure 4.Measured floater pitch motion variance density spectra $S(\theta )$: total, odd and even components, respectively, are shown in dotted black, solid blue and solid red lines. The dash-dotted blue curve represents the reconstructed linear pitch motion via application of the linear transfer function to the linearised free surface. The solid green and the dashed black vertical lines denote the pitch natural frequency $f_{n5}$ and the input peak wave frequency $f_p$, respectively.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Theoretical variance density spectra $S$. Linear free wave spectrum for sea state EC5 denoted by $S^{(1)}$ (black). Difference- and sum-frequency spectral content of $\eta _L^{2}$ denoted by $S^{-}(\eta _L^{2})$ (red) and $S^{+}(\eta _L^{2})$ (purple), respectively. Difference- and sum-frequency spectral content of $\eta _L^{3}$ denoted by $S^{-}(\eta _L^{3})$ (blue) and $S^{+}(\eta _L^{3})$ (green), respectively. Spectrum of $u_L|u_L|$ denoted by $S(u_L|u_L|)$ (light blue). Note that the curves are scaled and as such the vertical axis range is omitted. The solid green vertical line denotes the pitch natural frequency $f_{n5}$.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Third-order potential flow forcing $\eta _L^{3}$ and Morison drag forcing $u_L|u_L|$ proxy signals for sea state EC11 calculated using the experimental linearised free-surface signal $\eta _L$: (a)  raw signals and (b) bandpass-filtered (BPF) signals.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Conditioned signal analysis for sea states EC5 (a–c) and EC6 (d–f). Local average profiles of bandpass-filtered (BPF) even-harmonics and odd-harmonics pitch motion (second and third rows, respectively, in each panel, for each sea state) conditioned on extrema in the BPF $\eta _L^{2}$, $\eta _L^{3}$ and $u_L|u_L|$ time series (first row in each panel, for each sea state). The grey shading represents $95\,\%$ confidence intervals on the estimation of the mean signals. Reciprocity is shown by the dash-dotted curves, which correspond to the scaled and time-reversed conditioned forcing signals. In the label, the symbol $|$ represents ‘conditioned on’.

Figure 9

Figure 8.As in figure 7, but for sea states EC11 (a–c) and EC64 (d–f).

Figure 10

Figure 9.Amplitude dependence investigation for sea state EC11. (a,d,g)  Representative response and forcing amplitudes derived from multiple groups of events using conditioning on forcing. (b,e,h)  Representative response and forcing amplitudes derived from multiple groups of events using conditioning on response.(c,f,i)  Ordered forcing peaks versus ordered response peaks. The solid lines represent best-fit straight lines through the origin. The dotted lines represent best-fit power curves through the origin, with the power coefficient given in the legend.

Figure 11

Figure 10.(a,c,e,g) Free-surface variance density spectra: total measured free surface from two wave gauges shown by bold black solid and dotted lines, theoretical linear waves shown in blue, and theoretical second-order subharmonic waves shown in red (solid, dashed and dash-dotted red lines denote the total, bound and error components, respectively). The solid green and the grey vertical lines denote the pitch natural frequency $f_{n5}$ and the first three basin longitudinal sloshing frequencies $f_{b1,\ldots,3}$, respectively. (b,d,f,h)  Pitch motion variance density spectra: total, even and odd measured motions shown by solid black, red and blue lines, respectively, calculated pitch via application of the LTF to the second-order subharmonic error waves shown by the dash-dotted red line, and calculated pitch via application of the LTF to the measured free-surface bandpass-filtered around the second basin sloshing frequency $f_{b2}$ shown by the dashed black line.

Figure 12

Table 3.Longitudinal basin sloshing modes: the first five sloshing modes, for basin length $L$, characterised by wavelengths ${2 L}/{i}$ and wave frequencies $f_{bi}$ for $i=1,\ldots,5$ with the corresponding sloshing periods $T_{bi} = {1}/{f_{bi}}$.

Figure 13

Figure 11.Experimental pitch motion linear transfer functions (LTFs) derived from the four different sea states considered. Note that only the absolute value is shown. The theoretical LTF from Pegalajar-Jurado et al. (2018) with linearised pitch damping estimates from Pegalajar-Jurado et al. (2019) is also shown.

Figure 14

Figure 12.Free-surface variance density spectra for linear (black), second-order difference-frequency (red), second-order sum-frequency (purple), third-order difference-frequency (blue) and third-order sum-frequency (green) interactions. Note that only the low- and high-frequency tails of the third-order spectrum $S^{(3-)}$ are shown. The solid lines show the calculated spectra using linear spectral components $S^{(1)}$ and the absolute values of the transfer functions from (B5), (B6), (B9), (B10) and (B11). The dashed lines and the faint lines show the corresponding smoothed and raw spectra calculated from a random-phase realisation.