In 1923 the young and iconoclastic theatre actor-director Jasper Deeter, who had achieved some measure of fame as a member of the recently disbanded Provincetown Players, founded a repertory theatre in Rose Valley, Pennsylvania. In his 1982 history of the Provincetown Players and its spiritus rector, Jig Cook, Robert K. Sarlós identifies Deeter as Cook's heir apparent, an individual equally committed to the artistic experimentation, communal creation, and progressive social activism that had distinguished the Players. In fact, the fierce and uncompromising Deeter revealed in Barry Witham's A Sustainable Theatre proved perhaps truer to those ideals, turning his back on the fame and financial awards that threatened to pollute Provincetown's unfettered artistic experimentation following Eugene O'Neill's Broadway triumphs. Rather than assuming control of the Players following Cook's departure for Greece, Deeter poured his body, heart, and soul into developing a self-sustaining, repertory theatre in rural Pennsylvania, dedicated to the proposition that the theatrical profession should be fulfilling as “a way of life and not as a tool to accumulate wealth and material possessions” (2). Deeter and his community of like-minded artists renovated an abandoned gristmill into a 144-seat theatre and set up housekeeping in a converted farmhouse. The utopian experiment thrived for three decades under Deeter's leadership, remaining steadfast to the community's repertory system as well as their artistic and social goals. The artists produced hundreds of plays (199 in rep by 1956), including nearly fifty world premieres. Following Deeter's retirement, the organization continued, surviving several reorganizations but never entirely losing its connection to Deeter and his legacy.
Neither a comprehensive, chronologically organized history nor a biography in the conventional sense, Barry Witham's A Sustainable Theatre: Jasper Deeter at Hedgerow is a strikingly original, meticulously researched and engagingly written narrative that vividly supports the author's claim that Hedgerow is “one of the most provocative experiments of the twentieth century” (10). Drawing on extensive archival collections at Boston University and Hedgerow House, telephone interviews and correspondence with twelve former and current company members, and eighteen hours of tape recordings of company meetings and rehearsals produced in the 1960s, Witham has, thankfully, rescued this fascinating story and its remarkable central character from historical oblivion.
Sustainability has emerged as a newly meaningful concept in contemporary discourse, implying sustained achievement in economic, social, and environmental spheres, and, although not a term in popular use during Hedgerow's heyday, its use in this context seems apt. Deeter's dream of a repertory theatre was ineluctably tied to a vision of a fuller life in “harmony with a natural world unblighted by urban progress” (7). In this respect, Witham reveals the important influence of America's Arts and Crafts movement, particularly sculptor and designer Wharton Esherick, on the artistic and social nature of the theatre.
Witham's effective organizational scheme includes seven chapters focusing on representative works within Hedgerow's repertory, each work embodying particular ideas relevant to the theatre's artistic and/or social aims. Chapter 1 is devoted to Susan Glaspell's Inheritors, Hedgerow's “signature piece” (13) produced every Memorial and Independence Day for nearly thirty years. Witham explores the connection between the ideals expressed in the play (a critique of the suppression of free speech and other civil liberties during the post–World War I “Red Scare” era) and Hedgerow's “commitment to civil rights, nonviolence, participatory democracy, and conscientious objections to war” (22). Chapter 2 centers on The Emperor Jones, Hedgerow's most performed play, in which Deeter portrayed the role of Jones's cockney subordinate, Smithers. Although O'Neill's portrayal of race has always been controversial, for Deeter it seemed bound up with greater artistic opportunities for black artists (he had become especially close to Charles Gilpin during the play's initial run and tour) and a more inclusive society. This chapter examines Hedgerow's commitment to racial equality, as manifest in its integrated casts and auditorium; its creation of a Negro company featuring actors Rose McClendon, Abbie Mitchell, and Jules Bledsoe; and the world premiere of Countee Cullen's One Way to Heaven. Other chapters focus on class-consciousness and sexual mores in Sherwood Anderson's Winesburg, Ohio and Theodore Dreiser's An American Tragedy, and Native American and intercultural identity in Lynn Riggs's The Cherokee Night, which premiered at Hedgerow.
Two European works merit individual chapters: Anton Chekhov's Uncle Vanya, which provides Witham an opportunity to explore Deeter's somewhat Stanislavskian approach to acting through “rigorous analysis of ‘behaviors' and an exploration of relationships” (107), and George Bernard Shaw's Too True to Be Good. According to Witham, Deeter admired Shaw, Hedgerow's most produced playwright, as the “ultimate iconoclast, the master of the smashed idol” (87). Deeter was especially drawn to Shaw's critique of war, and this chapter includes Deeter's controversial efforts to gain conscientious objector status for Hedgerow company members during World War II.
Following Chapter 8, which discusses a never-released short film made about the company in the 1940s and the premiere of Eric Bentley's translation of Brecht's Caucasian Chalk Circle, the book offers a brief “Aftermath” and “Epilogue” that trace the company's post-Deeter existence, from 1956 to the present. Interestingly, Deeter's mantle seems to have been inherited by women, and a secondary contribution of this book is the introduction of several heretofore unheralded women administrators and artistic directors who have led the company since the 1960s: Rose Schulman, Dolores Tanner, June Prager, Janet Kelsey, and its current artistic director, Penelope Reed, who wrote the preface to A Sustainable Theatre. The historical record is filled out with the inclusion of three appendixes listing the company's production record during 1923–56, the schedule of one of their Shaw festivals in 1937, and sample repertory calendars from 1938 and 1947.
Witham packs a lot into a book shy of two hundred pages, although the remarkable longevity and productivity of the company suggests that there is probably more to discover about the Hedgerow experiment and its intriguing, quintessentially American visionary leader, who looked a tad like Abraham Lincoln. Witham's foundational study is sure to inspire further research.
