With the developed world well into the demographic transition, and some of the developing world rapidly catching up, population aging is a relevant topic for both researchers and policy makers. While the volume reviewed here aims to provide insights to both groups, it will be of more interest to researchers. It is a collection of conference papers that cover, as the title suggests, a wide range of topics related to the demographic transition. The papers vary widely not only in the topics covered but also in the methodologies employed and the persuasiveness achieved. The editors group them into three sections: “Population Aging and Labor Markets”, “Saving and Wealth”, and “Policy”.
The first section on population aging and labor markets contains three empirical papers. The first is a descriptive study on Japan that estimates compensation profiles; the authors conclude that changes in Japanese companies' employment and compensation policies have shifted the earnings peak to a later point in life. The second paper follows a similar line of investigation in Austria but focuses on age-productivity profiles rather than age-earnings profiles: the authors find that the share of older workers in a firm is negatively correlated to productivity in small firms but they do not find a significant effect for large firms. The final paper in this first section estimates the effect of subjective survival probabilities on both retirement age and wealth, finding that an increase in the subjective survival probability leads to increased household wealth among couples but has no effect on retirement age.
The second section on saving and wealth contains both theory and empirics. The first study offers a continuous-time overlapping-generations model to examine the steady-state relationship between fertility, and both youth and old-age dependency. It then uses a separate model and data from Japan and the United States to find that consumption-maximizing fertility rates in both countries are considerably higher than the actual fertility rates. The second paper also develops a model and uses simulation in order to examine how the first and second demographic dividendsFootnote 1 relate to each other and to different policies, finding that asset accumulation and limited transfers are the key to achieving a permanently higher standard of living. The third paper is an empirical investigation of the effect of demographic change on saving and investment with the authors concluding that a changing age structure affects saving and investment differently. The last paper in this section empirically examines the change in public and private health care expenditure in Japan in relation to policy changes and finds that a strict fee schedule has helped to keep total health spending under control.
The book's final section includes three chapters that examine policy responses to population aging. Without offering any thoughts on the desirability of such schemes, the first paper proposes hypothetical tradable-quota schemes to allow policy-makers to steer procreation and migration. The second paper evaluates the social welfare effect of Australia's future fund using a simulation approach and finds small positive effects. The final paper summarizes the social insurance schemes of a number of Asian countries and evaluates how well prepared these countries are to deal with an aging population.
The volume is intended for an audience of researchers as well as policymakers, yet the latter will find less of interest in this volume than the former. While some of the papers provide interesting insights that may be relevant to policy makers, none of the papers offer direct policy advice. The papers that policy makers might find interesting are not all in the “Policy” section of the volume. In fact the paper on tradable quotas for procreation and migration, which is in the “Policy” section, does not seem at all useful for policymakers. On the other hand, the paper on the effect of subjective survival probabilities on retirement age and wealth appearing in the first section on population aging and labor markets, should encourage policymakers to think about how to improve the accuracy of people's subjective survival probabilities.
A substantial shortcoming of the volume for policymakers is that most of the papers do not offer very convincing evidence for their conclusions. There is room for improvement in the empirical strategies and there are also extensions to the models one might want to consider. Some of the results could furthermore be strengthened by using better data. Yet, this drawback to policy makers is likely to be a main appeal of the book to researchers: there is ample room for extending and refining the studies. For researchers, the volume therefore provides an overview over the current state of research as well as a starting point for further work. All in all, this volume contains a set of interesting papers dealing with the demographic transition. Both researchers and, to a lesser extent, policymakers may take away new ideas for their work.
