This is not the first commentary on Book 7 of Lucan's Bellum Civile, but it is certainly the most detailed. Previous dedicated commentaries include Dilke's 1960 revision of Postgate's 1896 edition (85 pages of notes), and Gagliardi's 1975 edition (113 pages of text and notes). Dilke's elegant volume is a model of concision and economy; readers looking for such cannot do better than that diminutive work (though the pending appearance of a Cambridge ‘Green and Yellow’ by Paul Roche could change that). Lanzarone is striving for something different: a comprehensive and definitive reference for scholars and advanced students. He largely succeeds in that undertaking. The volume includes a brief introduction, a solid and unadventurous text (diverging from Housman's 1927 edition in just five places), a careful translation (following rather than facing the text), a rich and meticulous commentary, an extensive bibliography and usefully fulsome indices.
Given the overall dimensions of the volume, the introduction is modest in both size (1–17) and conceptual ‘bandwidth’. It is comprised of four sections: (i) structure of Book 7, (ii) themes, (iii) inversion of imperial ideology and the epic tradition; (iv) form of the contents. L.’s minimalist approach to the introduction repeatedly leads to him failing to encapsulate the state of scholarship. A mere handful of works are cited — nothing in German and just one article in English, despite the prominence of those linguistic groups in research on Lucan's poem. In (i) L. asserts a tripartite schema for Book 7, without so much as acknowledging alternate views: there are, as Roche has already pointed out (BMCR 2017.11.12), rival theories as well as disagreements on where to locate the divisions: at a minimum L. ought to have acknowledged the complexity of the critical debate. In (ii) L. touches on a number of important general issues, including the apparent contradictions in the poem, with a particular focus on those involving Pompey, and how they relate to Lucan's ‘apologia del Grande’. This is a matter of overriding importance for Book 7. Here it emerges that L.’s overall hermeneutics are indebted to Emanuele Narducci: like his renowned compatriot, L. sees Lucan's poem as a more-or-less coherent text that can be read ‘straight-up’. No need, in other words, for the kinds of ‘deconstructive’ and metaliterary approaches to the Bellum Civile that have often driven the critical agenda since the appearance of John Henderson's ground-breaking article ‘Lucan/The Word at War’, Ramus 16 (1988), 122–64, which is nowhere cited in the volume. Likewise excluded from mention is Shadi Bartsch's landmark monograph Ideology in Cold Blood (1997), which is particularly concerned with Lucan's discrepant treatment of Pompey.
The commentary proper is where the chief value of the volume resides. It is extensive and thorough, and, unlike the introduction, abounds in references to pertinent scholarship that enable the interested reader to pursue key issues touched on in the notes, whether they be philological, thematic, historical, philosophical or mythological. L.’s sense of Lucan's place in the literary tradition is lucidly conveyed in individual annotations and builds cumulatively as one proceeds through the commentary. L. exhibits an admirable sensitivity to sound, prosody and the poetic register; he also dutifully catalogues rhetorical and syntactic figures, poetic devices and the like. Points of syntax are likewise well covered, and meticulously documented with references to appropriate reference works. Scholarly disputes over sense are given a careful airing before L. weighs in — judiciously in nearly all cases. L.’s command of Lucan's text is also admirable: he scrupulously catalogues pertinent internal parallels — whether thematic, linguistic or metrical — for a given sequence.
Occasionally L. is off the mark, starting with 2 Titan (the note is misleading inasmuch as this poetic antonomasia for the sun is barely attested in Greek literature). The most eccentric assertion of the commentary is that at 159 erepta … pila liquavit Lucan is describing the phenomenon known as St Elmo's Fire: a plausible basis for this claim eludes the present reviewer. But the presence of scattered missteps is hardly surprising in such a densely annotated volume, and their comparatively scarcity suggests that L. has achieved a high level of precision. There would appear to be very few ‘typos’ — this reviewer found only one — but the volume does not seem to have been quite as thoroughly proof-read on the granular level, so that readers will occasionally encounter incorrect line numbers in passage references and the like.
In reviewing a commentary, it is hard not to take competence for granted and to dwell instead on shortcomings and points of disagreement, so it should be emphasised in conclusion that reading this volume was a rich and rewarding undertaking for the present reviewer. L. aims high, and for the most part hits the target: the result is a valuable reference that any serious Lucan scholar can profitably consult. In view of its rigour, depth and erudition, this volume seems likely to stand for some years to come as the definitive scholarly commentary on the important seventh book of Lucan's epic.
