Much continues to be claimed about the destructions and politico-military and economic upheavals of the third century a.d. While emphasis has long been placed on the sometimes aggressive but ultimately successful reorganizing efforts of the Tetrarchy, with scholars viewing this as the start of renewal and building activities in cities, forts and villas, recent works have attempted to identify buds of recovery — or at least attempts to encourage such buds — already in the preceding decades, especially in the reign of Aurelian.
The ‘Crisis’ period is one that can and should be addressed more coherently by archaeologists, and in the volume under review here we see a highly useful synthetic analysis of evidence relating to building works during this ‘Military Anarchy’ period (a.d. 235–284), seeking to identify recorded levels of public construction across the whole Empire. Core to Rambaldi's publication (which is nicely produced, with good indexes and bibliography, and clear images — although it was a shame that none of the described inscriptions were illustrated) is a catalogue (ch. 6, 139–284) comprising 334 entries, organized by provinces from west to east (if in slightly odd order, going in the West, for example, from ‘western’ Africa to Gaul, the German areas, Britain, Italy, to Spain): entries relate to epigraphic, historical, architectural, numismatic and archaeological evidence relating to new works, restorations, etc. (The nature and also problems of the source material are considered in ch. 2.) So far, 198 interventions are attested for the Western provinces and 136 for the Eastern; perhaps unsurprisingly Italy (79) and western North Africa (Proconsularis, Numidia, Mauretanias) (61) are best represented — Africa being largely cushioned from the Anarchy's worst upheavals (and seeing notable input under the Gordians in their short imperial burst), and Rome and Ostia (43 entries combined) understandably remained centres of imperial and senatorial input and maintenance. Perhaps oddly, equally cushioned Spain has only four relevant works (two being town wall repairs), while the Pannonias, much more in the firing line of the internal and external troubles, feature just three works (repairs to temples and baths, not walls). R. recognizes that not all ‘interventions’ are securely set in the Anarchy period — e.g. three refuges in Raetia (entries 96–98) are dated ‘from/around 280’ on the basis of one coin, pottery and analogy; and city wall repairs at Caerwent, Canterbury and elsewhere are set chiefly by ceramic guides and through reference to the context of documented Saxon piracy (105, 113–14, 120).
Ch. 5 provides a clear breakdown (via pie-charts and tables) of the types of building work attested by region, showing a focus on three main units: town walls (98 instances), temples (70), and baths (53); of these, restoration works, i.e. not new constructions, comprised 57, 48 and 33 instances respectively. More is made of these figures by analysing works by emperor and period (this is done in ch. 3, which thus also provides an overview of the numerous imperial players), showing Gallienus as the most prolific at 85 instances (defensive works and baths being prominent), followed by Aurelian, Probus and Gordian III (each in the upper 40s, the latter busiest, of course, in his North African homeland). Ch. 4 analyses the dedicants and patrons on the epigraphy and interestingly shows no significant differences from pre-third-century contexts.
All told, this volume brings together in very accessible fashion a large and scattered body of data and offers much food for thought and certainly scope for further exploration, such as on the scale of these works in their regional contexts and for wider urban patterns especially.
