Middle Eastern women's studies has come a long way since 1996, when Beth Baron, one of Nikki Keddie's students, published a review essay on the field (“A Field Matures: Recent Literature on Women in the Middle East,” Middle Eastern Studies 32 [1996]: 172–86). Recent books and articles have moved beyond familiar controversies such as veiling to include analyses of reproductive politics, homosexuality, and suffrage. Islam still provides an indispensable framework for the study of Muslim Middle Eastern women, but it is not necessarily the only organizing principle of many works on this subject. The interaction of Islamic thought with ideologies such as modernism, nationalism, and feminism has shed necessary light on the emerging political participation of women throughout the Middle East.
This useful volume brings together some of Keddie's earlier work on Middle Eastern women. Divided into three parts, it spans a broad chronology and a vast geographic region encompassing the Middle East, including Afghanistan, and North Africa. Book I discusses the ancient societies of the Near East and traces the rise of Islam and the position of women in early Islamic communities. Keddie explores familiar subjects such as polygamy and veiling as legislated in the Qurʾan, a discussion enriched by her treatment of less familiar topics such as slaves and concubines. As Keddie acknowledges, “Most of the scant documentation about medieval women concerns powerful women rather than ordinary ones” (p. 44). She then provides an overview of the next 400 or so years from the rise of the Mongols to the Napoleonic invasion of Egypt in 1798. The narrative in this latter section is rather cursory, in part, I suspect, because of the unevenness of the historiography of Middle Eastern women during that period.
As the Middle East crossed the threshold of modernity in the 19th century, the region came face to face with colonial powers trying to control it. Keddie considers the impact of encounters with the West, arguing that Western accounts, “despite their biases, tell something of women” (p. 60). I would argue that despite the easy access to the 19th-century Middle East that Western sources offer historians, there should be ongoing attempts to integrate indigenous materials such as manuscripts and archival documents in studies of Middle Eastern women. In assessing the historiography of the field, distinctions should also be made between scholarship that draws significantly on indigenous sources and scholarship that is largely derived from Western material.
The decline of harems and the rise of monogamy are viewed as important changes in the social lives of people in the Middle East, though Keddie is careful to note there were regional discrepancies in such practices. These changes also enabled women to assume different public personas. Women such as the Babi leader Qurrat al-ʾAyn participated in protest movements and even preached unveiled. By the beginning of the 20th century, nationalists and Islamic modernists grappled with the role of women in contemporary Middle Eastern societies, an issue most notably taken up by the Egyptian writer Qasim Amin in his Liberation of Women (1899).
Keddie's study makes it possible to see the similarity between and popularity of certain dominant ideas about women in various parts of the Middle East. These included women's demands for schooling, suffrage, and changes to traditional marriage and divorce laws. In addition, she highlights the ways in which women of other faiths, especially Christian and Jewish women, promoted social services for others.
After World War I, the involvement of Middle Eastern women in politics varied by region due in part to domestic politics and local traditions. Despite these variations, most countries expanded women's educational and healthcare opportunities. Women in Turkey, Iran, Egypt, Syria, and Lebanon formed associations and founded newspapers to promote causes important to them. The first part of the book concludes with a summary of social and political developments in various countries from the end of World War II to the present and includes a balanced analysis of the impact of Islamism on women's movements in the Middle East. The range of sources that Keddie has consulted to make this broad study possible is quite impressive. We learn about women's activism not only in well-documented countries such as Iran, Turkey, and Egypt but also in lesser studied regions such as Jordan, Afghanistan, and Yemen.
Book II deals with the ways scholars have approached Middle Eastern women's history. I do not fully agree with Keddie's assessment that works in the field “are often marked by a certain defensive and apologetic tone” (p. 225). Although a “defensive and apologetic tone” can be detected in some of the writings of feminist pioneers of the interwar era or in the works of ideologues of the contemporary period, many historians have been careful not to adopt that posture but, rather, to explain it. Yet Keddie's observations about the impact of the culture wars on Middle Eastern women's studies are relevant and timely. She also shows how the incorporation of new sources by generations of scholars has made it possible for us to explore new avenues for research. Keddie has gone to some length to discuss not only historical accounts but also anthropological studies of women in the Middle East, thus encouraging by example a conversation among scholars in different academic disciplines.
The last part of the book consists of an interview with Keddie conducted by fellow scholars Farzaneh Milani and Nancy Gallagher. The interview, as well as the supplement to it, is an indispensable part of this work, even though it departs from the book's earlier emphasis on the historical narrative. After reading the interview and the supplement, one better understands Keddie's decision to dedicate this book to Parvin Paidar, another trailblazing scholar of women's history. After all, Keddie's career manifests the global impact of the feminist movement and the ways it transformed not only Middle Eastern scholarship but also the lives of its pioneering historians in the West. Keddie recalls some of the discrimination she experienced as a woman working in the field of Middle Eastern history, though she concludes optimistically that since “the largely successful struggles for women's rights that began in the sixties and became stronger afterwards, I have rarely felt discriminated against as a woman” (p. 353).
Others of us will have different stories to tell of discrimination, exclusion, and the willful silencing of academic voices by peers and mentors. Keddie's ground-breaking career and scholarship, however, will ensure that her powerful words will resonate with readers for generations to come. As she anticipates, “Naturally not everyone agrees with my scholarly views,” but the conversations Keddie has engendered here and elsewhere have undoubtedly brought us all “a better understanding of humanity” (p. 354).
